Live data from Hacker News

GBatteries (YC W14) let you charge your car as quickly as visiting the pump

techcrunch.com

11–20 of 97 posts

Re: GBatteries (YC W14) let you charge your car as quickly as visiting the pump

#11
476mi/h of charging isn’t gorundbreaking. Aston Martin, Tesla and Porsche already charge at those speeds or faster.

https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1118575_gm-working-on-u...

I believe their “secret sauce” is allowing existing packs which charge slower to get “up to speed”. If so, that’s a pretty limited market as it’s likely that within a few years, all EVs sold will charge faster than the listed speeds. They’ll likely have a maximum tota addressable market of a few hundred thousand cars with only a few thousand real consumers. Most people buying electric cars with slower chargers are doing so because those vehicles fit their lifestyle and wouldn’t have a massive incentive to buy a new charger.

Re: GBatteries (YC W14) let you charge your car as quickly as visiting the pump

#12

There is a fix for slow charging that is literally as fast as filling a tank but nobody wants to use it. (I assume it is the same reason that there are pages and pages of battery improvements that never make it to market.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_battery

In the case of flow batteries, don't a lot of them have poor power to weight figures? Those liquids are heavy, but aren't nearly as power dense as gasoline.

Re: GBatteries (YC W14) let you charge your car as quickly as visiting the pump

#13
post #6

Do people in the US take 15m to visit the pump?

No, it's usually more like 5 minutes

When I'm on road trips with my friends, I can never get them out of a rest stop faster than 25 minutes. When I'm on the road with my wife, 15 minutes is about the right time.

Re: GBatteries (YC W14) let you charge your car as quickly as visiting the pump

#14

The system uses AI to optimize the charging systems in electric cars. Here's one thing that stinks about current/last gen electric cars. I drove with my wife from my apartment in Nob Hill to Santa Cruz, using up about 92% of my range. I was able to find a charger and get fully recharged for my trip back. All of that is fine. What was disturbing, was that while I was climbing those initial hills out of Santa Cruz, my…

Telsas do that, FYI. They take elevation and temperature during a trip to estimate where on the energy usage curve you are at any point in your trip.

Here's an article from 2015 when they introduced that feature: https://www.teslarati.com/closer-look-tesla-firmware-6-1-tri...

Re: GBatteries (YC W14) let you charge your car as quickly as visiting the pump

#15

There is a fix for slow charging that is literally as fast as filling a tank but nobody wants to use it. (I assume it is the same reason that there are pages and pages of battery improvements that never make it to market.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_battery

Flow batteries, at least the kind that are commercially adoptable in the present/near-future (Vanadium redox), scale in capacity very easily. The downsides are twofold:

  * Poor power density
  * Relatively limited nominal power output
These compromises are fine for stationary applications, but for vehicles, they'd be a riskier bet as far as I'm aware.

(disclaimer: not a subject matter expert)

Re: GBatteries (YC W14) let you charge your car as quickly as visiting the pump

#17
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, it's usually more like 5 minutes

When I'm on road trips with my friends, I can never get them out of a rest stop faster than 25 minutes. When I'm on the road with my wife, 15 minutes is about the right time.

Are you sitting at the pump the whole time?

Re: GBatteries (YC W14) let you charge your car as quickly as visiting the pump

#18
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, it's usually more like 5 minutes

When I'm on road trips with my friends, I can never get them out of a rest stop faster than 25 minutes. When I'm on the road with my wife, 15 minutes is about the right time.

That's the time it takes to visit the convenience store. Relevant in some circumstances, but if you're not already in need of a break you only visit the pump and even five minutes is oddly slow. And the article and company site specifically say the time to fill the tank, not to visit a gas station. So they're blatantly lying.

Re: GBatteries (YC W14) let you charge your car as quickly as visiting the pump

#19

The system uses AI to optimize the charging systems in electric cars. Here's one thing that stinks about current/last gen electric cars. I drove with my wife from my apartment in Nob Hill to Santa Cruz, using up about 92% of my range. I was able to find a charger and get fully recharged for my trip back. All of that is fine. What was disturbing, was that while I was climbing those initial hills out of Santa Cruz, my…

Telsas do that, FYI. They take elevation and temperature during a trip to estimate where on the energy usage curve you are at any point in your trip. Here's an article from 2015 when they introduced that feature: https://www.teslarati.com/closer-look-tesla-firmware-6-1-tri...

Absolutely true and it works. For example, my Tesla S (2014) very accurately predicts mileage going from Los Altos to Tahoe (up hill, have to recharge on the way) and from Tahoe to Los Altos (down hill, can barely make it back without charging).

Re: GBatteries (YC W14) let you charge your car as quickly as visiting the pump

#20
Super skeptical here, or at least the wording is misleading as hell.

> The product allows users to charge a 60kWh EV battery pack with 119 miles of range in 15 minutes as compared to 15 miles in 15 minutes today.

> The technology works with off-the-shelf lithium ion batteries and existing fast charge infrastructure by integrating via a patented self-contained adapter on a car charge port

First read says that they're delivering 60kWh in 15min, or they're pumping electrons at 240kW. This is just nonsense -- most deployed DC fast chargers are 50kW... the charger companies and the OEMs are experimenting with 200kW chargers, but those are liquid cooled. So physics says this is nonsense.

Okay, so second read: the 60 kWh is distracting technobabble, and what they're ACTUALLY doing is "adding 119 miles of range in 15 minutes."

The just-announced Nissan Leaf e+ has a 62 kWh battery with 226 miles of range. When you DC Fast Charge, going from 0-80% takes about as much time as going from 80-100% (EV roadtripping is about doing frequent small charging because of this phenomenon, not one-time top-offs like with gas).

The Nissan Leaf e+ is about a 60 kWh battery, and if they're adding "119 miles of range in 15 minutes", that's about half the Leaf's 226 mi range, so call it "30 kWh of charge in 15 min". That means they're charging at an average of 120kW. Okay, now we're back within the realm of physics.

Note the Leaf e+'s (yet unreleased hardware) still only accepts a maximum of 100kW DC fast charging. I think jaguar has experimented with 150kW charging on the ipace (but again, liquid cooled cables).

So they're saying they found a way to cycle fast charging and get about a 20% improvement in average charging rate from the current kinda-top-of-the-line tech, and only for the first 50% battery capacity.

Not nothing, but hardly "as quickly as visiting the pump", especially since whatever tricks they use likely won't continue for the next 50% of the battery.

Post reply on HN