Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 86 posts

Re: Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

#31
post #4

Insanely so. I go to sleep thinking about what I’ll be working on the next day and rise excited to get started. It’s an amazing feeling and I reflect daily that I’m blessed for having a career that I excel at, pays well, and whole heartedly enjoy.

I think the question is about the meaning your job has for the system at large, not for you as an individual.

But gratz anyway

Re: Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

#32
I'm web engineering manager and front-end contributor for a small team inside a small pharma. I love solving business problems, but I witness a lot of self-inflicted issues outside my department that we are then tasked to fix.

So my knee-jerk answer would be, "no." However the salary + bonus + benefits from this job are providing me resources that will enable my family to be nearly debt-free in a year or two (mortgage notwithstanding). The pay is above tech start-up grade, even well-funded ones.

Re: Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

#34
Is it meaningful? Not that much. We probably enable many use cases that won't really change much. Nonetheless the kind of expertise we are building might be applied to other fields with more meaningful impact. Will my company pursue these other fields? Probably not in the short term.

At least I'm not actively harming anybody and today in IT this is a huge privilege.

Re: Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

#35
post #26
post #23

Why would meaningless and 9-5 be synonyms? Why does late evening imply meaning and regular managed schedule lack of it? Why would a company on edge of crash implied more meaning then the stable one? For whatever it is worth, position I have now is a lot of what I was looking for professionally and I can be 9-5. Thankfully, they want output and not butt in seat. It is not saving world and have no such illusions. But m…

I don't think late evening is the alternative. 9-5 links to "corporate" and "corporate" links to "meaningless job" for many reasons: first of all if you work for a company, the profit will come before the interests of your customers. If the company is big and profitable, it will be able to support more and more mechanism to detach its profit from the actual value brought to the customer or society or both. Also the b…

Then alternative is what exactly? Working only in non-profits?

Re: Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

#36

Working in Healthcare/Education is pretty rewarding knowing the products we put out are helping people (both improving education for new doctors and improving clinical care). Sometimes working in Healthcare is annoying (Changes are slow and there are legal restrictions everywhere, e.g. any time you mention the word "cloud" the C-level folks yell "but HIPAA!" and refuse to listen), but it's still good to know we're do…

"e.g. any time you mention the word "cloud" the C-level folks yell "but HIPAA!"

I worked for a former healthcare project manager in a completely unrelated industry and I would say 80% of her time was spend worrying about our industry's version of HIPAA. She viewed all new tech projects and software releases through the lens of "How does this violate our industry security standard?". The results were stagnated project releases and high developer turnover.

Re: Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

#37
post #35
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think late evening is the alternative. 9-5 links to "corporate" and "corporate" links to "meaningless job" for many reasons: first of all if you work for a company, the profit will come before the interests of your customers. If the company is big and profitable, it will be able to support more and more mechanism to detach its profit from the actual value brought to the customer or society or both. Also the b…

Then alternative is what exactly? Working only in non-profits?

That's a starting point. Otherwise publicly-funded projects or institutions.

Re: Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

#38
Consultant at a global ERP provider - Its not that meaningful but some days are better then others. Most the time it feels like herding cats.

I make rent and have something left over to invest. Can you ask for much more?

Re: Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

#40

I work in IT at a large insurance company. Most days, I get to cheer someone up and help them with a tech thing they are stuck on. I'm not curing cancer, I'm not fixing the atmosphere, but at least I can detect when I helped someone out. It's mixed bag, but it definitely puts the needle over 50%.

Your work is more important than you know. Many people in large orgs are still afraid to talk to the "Trolls in IT."
Post reply on HN