Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 86 posts

Re: Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

#21
Working in Healthcare/Education is pretty rewarding knowing the products we put out are helping people (both improving education for new doctors and improving clinical care).

Sometimes working in Healthcare is annoying (Changes are slow and there are legal restrictions everywhere, e.g. any time you mention the word "cloud" the C-level folks yell "but HIPAA!" and refuse to listen), but it's still good to know we're doing meaningful work.

Re: Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

#23
Why would meaningless and 9-5 be synonyms? Why does late evening imply meaning and regular managed schedule lack of it? Why would a company on edge of crash implied more meaning then the stable one?

For whatever it is worth, position I have now is a lot of what I was looking for professionally and I can be 9-5. Thankfully, they want output and not butt in seat. It is not saving world and have no such illusions. But my work is occasionally useful to real people I know personally and I work in team of people I trust.

Re: Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

#24
post #19

Yes, helping people with chronic medical conditions improve their health and quality of life.

Do you now? Have real data to back this up or is it just a feel good guess?

It is easy to deceive oneself that an app or a tracker equals health... better than pen and paper and minor instruction manual.

Now if you're actually working on safety critical health devices (say, insulin pump or oxygen meter or maybe a CPAP or perhaps heart monitor), then I hope you're working on cutting the price tag as they're super expensive for not really any good reason...

We were trying to figure out a reliable way to track sugar levels relatively nonincasively but found out that it was less accurate than a chart and simple alarm...

Sometimes being actually rational sucks, you see that your junk does not work or that you have to be smarter than super well funded geniuses at MIT or Stanford to matter. And have comparable fabrication and chemical analysis facilities and biolabs to even attempt anything.

Research is expensive. As in really expensive now in terms of hardware. As in some big universities not in USA being too poor to afford hardware. That's not even counting lab space to actually house it.

Re: Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

#25
post #15

Yes it is. We build a machine that shaves of pennies from donations to orphanages and funnels them directly into hedge funds. To do so we have to build a neural network! and in Tensorflow no less! And here is the real kicker: I rewrote the interface in Haskell. If that isn't meaningful, I don't know what is!

Cool, what kind of fossil fuel does the machine run on?

Tires soaked in the blood of a white rino, but to make it meaningful, we first use crispr to modify the protein in the blood.

Re: Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

#26
post #23

Why would meaningless and 9-5 be synonyms? Why does late evening imply meaning and regular managed schedule lack of it? Why would a company on edge of crash implied more meaning then the stable one? For whatever it is worth, position I have now is a lot of what I was looking for professionally and I can be 9-5. Thankfully, they want output and not butt in seat. It is not saving world and have no such illusions. But m…

I don't think late evening is the alternative. 9-5 links to "corporate" and "corporate" links to "meaningless job" for many reasons: first of all if you work for a company, the profit will come before the interests of your customers. If the company is big and profitable, it will be able to support more and more mechanism to detach its profit from the actual value brought to the customer or society or both. Also the bigger the company, the less relevant is the impact of most individuals inside the company.

Re: Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

#27

Working in Healthcare/Education is pretty rewarding knowing the products we put out are helping people (both improving education for new doctors and improving clinical care). Sometimes working in Healthcare is annoying (Changes are slow and there are legal restrictions everywhere, e.g. any time you mention the word "cloud" the C-level folks yell "but HIPAA!" and refuse to listen), but it's still good to know we're do…

We're in healthcare and we're going to the cloud! (still on-prem for a couple of years, but it's in the pipeline. My tests are all in the cloud nowadays)

I agree that it is rewarding, and it doesn't feel that slow where I work. We cover more than half the hospitals in our country, and a couple of university-hospitals. There's plenty of change they want - and (surely the university ones) - have plenty of ideas of what they'd like to see.

For us "but HIPAA!" is "but GDPR!" for quite some time though. But we're hardly unique in that.

It's definitely a nice industry if you want to have a meaningful job. But it does come with some stress as well though.

EDIT: Fix my English :D

Re: Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

#28

I work because I must provide for my family. That's enough meaning for me.

Same, I help writing systems to 'optimise advertisement effectiveness' == encourage consumerism and maybe creative negative value for society. It sucks but I have to support my family and extended family as the main bread earner.

On the other hands, I often donate to wikipedia, supporting local FOSS communities and mentoring young students. Currently helping my friend with his air pollution measurement station project too. All that I won't be able to do if I take a lower paying job but more meaningful job (previously I was working as a civil engineer, building bridge and stuff).

Re: Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

#29
post #16

Nope. I work in equity research and am lucky enough to be on the team that I'm on, but it doesn't seem meaningful or worthwhile. I generate investment ideas through industry, company-specific, and technology-specific research and then publish these ideas in reports for my client base. Most of my job is then debating investors on specific technology investments or trends. Sell-side finance (e.g. investment bank) is br…

Isn't equity research a training ground for working on the buy side where the money is made?

And isn't the work very interesting? (at least for the first 8 hours)

Re: Ask HN: Is your work meaningful?

#30
I work in IT at a large insurance company. Most days, I get to cheer someone up and help them with a tech thing they are stuck on. I'm not curing cancer, I'm not fixing the atmosphere, but at least I can detect when I helped someone out. It's mixed bag, but it definitely puts the needle over 50%.
Post reply on HN