Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Mystery Missile Launch Seen off California Coast

cbsnews.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

51–60 of 88 posts

Re: Mystery Missile Launch Seen off California Coast

#51

Post by cyanbane »

ryandvm wrote: post #18

http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/e3gf3/a_missile_... tl;dr: We're launching a missile tonight. Stay away please. Edit: Doh. The date for this is Nov 9th, not last night. Not sure how I missed that - this isn't rocket science.

'Call of Duty: Black Ops' comes out for the major video game consoles tonight, my guess is that these guys didn't want to be stuck at work (shooting missiles) on release night when they could have been at home playing with virtual ones, so my guess is that they just bumped it up a night.

Re: Mystery Missile Launch Seen off California Coast

#52

Post by vietor »

bl4k wrote: post #43

The fact that the US military response was 'nope, wasn't us' instead of 'oh my fucking god can you believe somebody just fired a missile off the coast of LA!' pretty much tells me it was them.

Possible alternative explanation:

http://www.examiner.com/weather-in-los-angeles/missile-launc...

Fits with your point about the DoD being all kinds of crazy if they suspected it was an actual event they had no hand in.

As usual the low quality of video and unreliability of eye-witnesses are going to make this way more crazy than it needs to be, regardless of the actual eventual outcome.

EDIT: A better explanation with historical pictures: http://www.smartplanet.com/technology/blog/thinking-tech/the...

Re: Mystery Missile Launch Seen off California Coast

#54

Post by tibbon »

vietor wrote: post #52
bl4k wrote: post #43

The fact that the US military response was 'nope, wasn't us' instead of 'oh my fucking god can you believe somebody just fired a missile off the coast of LA!' pretty much tells me it was them.

Possible alternative explanation: http://www.examiner.com/weather-in-los-angeles/missile-launc... Fits with your point about the DoD being all kinds of crazy if they suspected it was an actual event they had no hand in. As usual the low quality of video and unreliability of eye-witnesses are going to make this way more crazy than it needs to be, regardless of the actual eventual outcome. EDIT: A better explanation wi…

Surely the FAA could verify if there was a flight taking off in that trajectory right?

Re: Mystery Missile Launch Seen off California Coast

#55

Post by tibbon »

bl4k wrote: post #43

The fact that the US military response was 'nope, wasn't us' instead of 'oh my fucking god can you believe somebody just fired a missile off the coast of LA!' pretty much tells me it was them.

If it is a missile, then clearly a group of people with a boat should go and recover whatever it is. Since the military denies that they own it, then it seems to be abandoned property.

Surely someone would be interested in buying the remains of it for the technology.

Since the military doesn't own it, then they can't really say anything about you selling/reverse engineering/posting online abandoned property that's probably sitting in international waters now can they?

Either that, or the military is caught in a lie to the American people.

I know if I see what looks to be an ICBM over my city, I'm headed for the closest fallout shelter and assuming the worst. Anyone putting up faux-ICBMs over major cities is clearly causing terrorism, as in causing terror, uncertainty and fear among the public by not explaining and warning them.

Re: Mystery Missile Launch Seen off California Coast

#56

Post by metageek »

tibbon wrote: post #55
bl4k wrote: post #43

The fact that the US military response was 'nope, wasn't us' instead of 'oh my fucking god can you believe somebody just fired a missile off the coast of LA!' pretty much tells me it was them.

If it is a missile, then clearly a group of people with a boat should go and recover whatever it is. Since the military denies that they own it, then it seems to be abandoned property. Surely someone would be interested in buying the remains of it for the technology. Since the military doesn't own it, then they can't really say anything about you selling/reverse engineering/posting online abandoned property that's pr…

>Surely someone would be interested in buying the remains of it for the technology.

...unless it, say, exploded.

Personally, I wouldn't want to pick up an unexploded missile anyway; there'd be no way to know whether it didn't explode because it doesn't have a warhead, or just hasn't exploded yet.

Re: Mystery Missile Launch Seen off California Coast

#58

Post by vietor »

tibbon wrote: post #54
vietor wrote: post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Possible alternative explanation: http://www.examiner.com/weather-in-los-angeles/missile-launc... Fits with your point about the DoD being all kinds of crazy if they suspected it was an actual event they had no hand in. As usual the low quality of video and unreliability of eye-witnesses are going to make this way more crazy than it needs to be, regardless of the actual eventual outcome. EDIT: A better explanation wi…

Surely the FAA could verify if there was a flight taking off in that trajectory right?

I would hope that the retain sufficient records to do so, and expect that they will. Whether that will get news coverage is a separate question...

And I'm sure that, regardless, some fraction will insist that it's a cover-up and continue to talk about it for the next decade.

Post reply on HN