Live data from Hacker News

Samsung Phone Users Perturbed to Find They Can't Delete Facebook

bloomberg.com

441–450 of 478 posts

Re: Samsung Phone Users Perturbed to Find They Can't Delete Facebook

#441

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Windows Phones didn't had crap on them either. This is strictly a Android issue.

Windows 10 comes with crap even in Pro version these days (Candy Crush etc.), so it was just because nobody cared enough to create that crap for Windows Phone.

These aren't preinstalled though. It places a tile in the default setup for it, and the app gets installed if you click on it. If you delete the tile instead, the app is never even installed.

Re: Samsung Phone Users Perturbed to Find They Can't Delete Facebook

#442
post #433

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Safari, AppStore, Phone, Messages, Clock, Photos, Camera, Health, Settings. I think that's the full list of the apps that can't be removed from iPhone.

Calculator?

Can be deleted as well.

Re: Samsung Phone Users Perturbed to Find They Can't Delete Facebook

#443
post #163
post #156

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Many Android phones don't have "crap" installed on them. This is a phone manufacturer issue and not an Android phone.

It's both. Why does Android have undeletable apps anyway?

It doesn't have undeletable apps, since adb lets you delete anything (although the exact semantics of "delete" will be different for apps that are installed on the system partition - but not in a way that matters to end users).

It has apps that cannot be installed from the phone UI. Which kinda makes sense, since you don't want people randomly uninstalling, say, the app store, and then complaining that their phone is bricked. OTOH, someone who knows how to do this via adb can be presumed to know what they're doing.

Re: Samsung Phone Users Perturbed to Find They Can't Delete Facebook

#444
post #299

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That isn't really accurate, you're just defining "crapware" is such a way so that Google's apps don't qualify. That's a double standard. Google Drive, Gmail, Google Photos, Play Music, Play Movies, Play Games, Play Books, Duo, Google+, and YouTube could all be called as crapware since they aren't required for core phone functions (and upsell for-profit services). I guess it is somewhat a discussion what we mean by "c…

> That isn't really accurate, you're just defining "crapware" is such a way so that Google's apps don't qualify. That's a double standard. I need to clarify - I'm not an Apple hater, I own an iPhone, 2 iPads, 2 Macbook Pros and a Mac Mini at the time of this comment. But, this same logic can be applied to Apple as well. For example, I don't use Apple's photos app at all. And I can't delete it. There is absolutely no…

I get constantly bugged to upgrade to Mojave on my work computer, where corporate IT policy has disabled being able to install it. So the installer can tell I can't do it, but not the notifier.

Re: Samsung Phone Users Perturbed to Find They Can't Delete Facebook

#445

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google recognizes this issue, which is part of the drive behind bringing Android One to the high-end phone market. This is a branding designation that Google sells to OEMs that requires them to drop almost all bloatware: > Android One is a series of smartphones that run the unmodified Android operating system. It is a hardware and software technical standard created by Google intended to provide a consistent user exp…

> Google recognizes this issue, which is part of the drive behind bringing Android One to the high-end phone market. Sorry, did you mean "low-end" here? Because the Pixel serves the high-end market quite well, I think.

No, Android One has been on the low-end market for many years. It's being extended to the high-end market only relatively recently. I don't believe any model of Pixel has been Android One. ("Android One" is not synonymous with "stock Android" like on the Pixel.)

Re: Samsung Phone Users Perturbed to Find They Can't Delete Facebook

#446

Earlier quoted context omitted.

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/jellyphone/atom-world-s...

Wow, that's really small. Actually it's what phones used to be before 2007.

I have the original Jelly phone, and it's actually smaller than Nokia phones I used in pre-smartphone days.

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/jellyphone/jelly-the-sm...

Re: Samsung Phone Users Perturbed to Find They Can't Delete Facebook

#447
post #363

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google recognizes this issue, which is part of the drive behind bringing Android One to the high-end phone market. This is a branding designation that Google sells to OEMs that requires them to drop almost all bloatware: > Android One is a series of smartphones that run the unmodified Android operating system. It is a hardware and software technical standard created by Google intended to provide a consistent user exp…

Almost all non-Google* bloatware. I'm using an Android One phone as well, but there's still a dozen or so of Google's apps that I would like to be able to remove. I chose less bloatware as well, but let's not pretend that there's no bloatware in Android One.

That's fair, although I think this reduces the bloat below Apple levels.

Re: Samsung Phone Users Perturbed to Find They Can't Delete Facebook

#448
post #121
post #107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

...except for Apple.

Apple is doing a lot better nowadays, but it's still not perfect though, for example: you can't delete iTunes on MacOS.

Yes, you can. You can also recompile the kernel with new options, or do whatever else. This has been misstated repeatedly in this thread, but macOS simply is not backed by a trusted hardware chain, end of story. It's not iOS. With SIP Apple has effectively implemented something like a more granular system immutable flag with kern.securelevel set to 1 like it was back until 10.3 or so (can't remember exactly when they changed it to 0), but just as you could drop down to single user mode back then SIP can also be disabled or modified at will. Having the restricted flag set on a bunch of core system .app bundles under macOS and a sane default policy is simply not the same thing as "you can't get rid of it". And I do think Apple should be legally required to provide decent built-in support for an owner controlled trust chain, but I don't think mixing up "you need to really know and be sure of what you're doing" with "it's hard prevented outside of bugs" is helpful.

Re: Samsung Phone Users Perturbed to Find They Can't Delete Facebook

#449

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I know I can clean up crapware, via adb, but on principle vote with my wallet. It's not acceptable to charge me something that rounds to a thousand euros and then fleece me for a few extra bucks. Right now, I restrict my selection to Android One [1] phones. The current one is a Nokia 8 Sirocco. [1] https://www.android.com/one/

I've had similar feelings... having finally ditched my Huawei Nexus 6P, which I came to loathe. This was after years of buying Google developer devices (going back to the G1). The 6P was the last straw, as I came to resent spending hundreds on something with a soldered-in battery that could be (and turned out to be) unusable after 24 months. The battery was a wreck. I ended up getting an unlocked new LG V20 from eBay…

Odd question. I bought V20 as a replacement for a Zenfone ( long story ). I like it. It does its job. I think I tried everything and I cannot root it. ADB just does not work regardless of what I try.

Anyone had similar issue?

Re: Samsung Phone Users Perturbed to Find They Can't Delete Facebook

#450
2019: Samsung Phone Users Perturbed to Find They Can't Delete Facebook

2023: iPhone Users Perturbed to Find They Can't logout from Facebook

2025: Google Phone Users Perturbed to Find Their photos are automatically posted on Facebook

2027: Facebook Branded Phone Users Perturbed to Find Their life is cached 24/7 and automatically posted on Facebook

Post reply on HN