Live data from Hacker News

Drone Sighting Halts Departures at Heathrow Airport

nytimes.com

11–20 of 150 posts

Re: Drone Sighting Halts Departures at Heathrow Airport

#11

> The airport said it had spent several million pounds to purchase the equipment. I feel like this is a problem some smart people could solve quickly if they were asked, similar to the healthcare.gov situation. Ask some MIT students to come up with a solution over a weekend and I bet they would deliver. Knocking a slow moving object out of the sky is literally not rocket science.

Or just some annoyed passengers with a roll of toilet paper? https://imgur.com/gallery/0b4wF3V

Re: Drone Sighting Halts Departures at Heathrow Airport

#12

> The airport said it had spent several million pounds to purchase the equipment. I feel like this is a problem some smart people could solve quickly if they were asked, similar to the healthcare.gov situation. Ask some MIT students to come up with a solution over a weekend and I bet they would deliver. Knocking a slow moving object out of the sky is literally not rocket science.

The tricky part I'm guessing is doing it safely without collateral damage, especially in a crowded area like an airport.

A bullet or other kinetic object could do damage if it falls back down to earth. A directed energy/RF weapon could possibly fry other electronics in aircraft nearby as well.

Re: Drone Sighting Halts Departures at Heathrow Airport

#13
post #9

> The airport said it had spent several million pounds to purchase the equipment. I feel like this is a problem some smart people could solve quickly if they were asked, similar to the healthcare.gov situation. Ask some MIT students to come up with a solution over a weekend and I bet they would deliver. Knocking a slow moving object out of the sky is literally not rocket science.

> Knocking a slow moving object out of the sky is literally not rocket science. But perhaps doing it in a way that doesn't shower the runway with dangerous debris, is?

Don't they already shoot Canada geese at airports because they're such a nuisance? I imagine a similar tactic could be used for drones

Re: Drone Sighting Halts Departures at Heathrow Airport

#14

> The airport said it had spent several million pounds to purchase the equipment. I feel like this is a problem some smart people could solve quickly if they were asked, similar to the healthcare.gov situation. Ask some MIT students to come up with a solution over a weekend and I bet they would deliver. Knocking a slow moving object out of the sky is literally not rocket science.

Probably good to understand what the problem actually is. I don't think _everybody_ involved isn't smart.

Re: Drone Sighting Halts Departures at Heathrow Airport

#15
post #10

Just as in Gatwick before this, the police and the airport are not able to produce even grainy footage of a drone that is supposedly "buzzing" the tower. Gatwick reported "67 sightings", but couldn't confirm if some (all?) were their own drones [1]. And now Parliament is tabling new powers for the police [2]. Was there ever any evidence presented that there was ever a drone present? Is there any evidence that this wa…

Does Heathrow bear a resposibility to prove anything to you or any other random person on the internet? You seem to be insinuating some conspiracy by asking vague questions.

Re: Drone Sighting Halts Departures at Heathrow Airport

#17

> The airport said it had spent several million pounds to purchase the equipment. I feel like this is a problem some smart people could solve quickly if they were asked, similar to the healthcare.gov situation. Ask some MIT students to come up with a solution over a weekend and I bet they would deliver. Knocking a slow moving object out of the sky is literally not rocket science.

> Knocking a slow moving object out of the sky is literally not rocket science.

No, but it's not a matter of some yahoos with a gun shooting them: https://twitter.com/sommervilletv/status/1080724993238069249

Re: Drone Sighting Halts Departures at Heathrow Airport

#18
post #10

Just as in Gatwick before this, the police and the airport are not able to produce even grainy footage of a drone that is supposedly "buzzing" the tower. Gatwick reported "67 sightings", but couldn't confirm if some (all?) were their own drones [1]. And now Parliament is tabling new powers for the police [2]. Was there ever any evidence presented that there was ever a drone present? Is there any evidence that this wa…

They were not all of their drones, because reports were coming in before the police had launched any drones.

Among the people reporting drone sightings before the police turned up at Gatwick were pilots

Re: Drone Sighting Halts Departures at Heathrow Airport

#19

> The airport said it had spent several million pounds to purchase the equipment. I feel like this is a problem some smart people could solve quickly if they were asked, similar to the healthcare.gov situation. Ask some MIT students to come up with a solution over a weekend and I bet they would deliver. Knocking a slow moving object out of the sky is literally not rocket science.

The problem is presumably making sure you don't damage anything else on the ground while you're at it, and proving that the everyone's satisfaction.
Post reply on HN