Live data from Hacker News

WeWork Gets a Visit from Financial Reality

bloomberg.com

111–120 of 380 posts

Re: WeWork Gets a Visit from Financial Reality

#111
post #5
post #4

>The Gulf investors backing the Vision Fund seem to have decided that WeWork is not a tech bet but simply an aggressive punt on real estate. This is the bogey man of a huge number of current 'tech startups' - What if it turns out Tesla really are a car company! Or if We Work are actually an office rental company! OR gasp Uber is a cab company! (1) We now have a glut of companies operating in traditional markets that…

In 1999 there was an email going round about how ridiculous dotcom valuations were. Taking Amazon, I think, as an example it said it would have to earn more than Kodak, Boeing, Caterpillar etc to ever be worth it's valuation. There was a general sense of "it's just a bookstore". Now I know everything is more mature and the situation is different, but I also remember feeling very confident that Amazon was waaay overva…

If you'd invested in Amazon in 1999, you'd have lost 80% over the next year. It stayed flat until about 2008.

It's difficult to decompose a stock price, but I think Amazon gets most of its from AWS.

Re: WeWork Gets a Visit from Financial Reality

#112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> was a basket containing Amazon.com, pets.com and all the rest overvalued? Yes. This has been extensively studied. Almost every investor who deployed new capital in the late 90s lost money on those investments. > as long as AMZN was >= 20% of your basket You’d have to torture causality to come up with a portfolio that would have made sense in the 90s and would have been 20%+ Amazon. It wasn’t even in the top 10 most…

But it obviously would have been a major component of any "Internet" basket at any date after its IPO in 1997. But 20% major? Perhaps not.

Keep in mind, too, that $1 in January 1999 would buy what $1.53 does today [1]. Saying you’d be 20% Amazon in 1999 is the same as saying you’d have bought the stock then. Yes, of course—with that prescience you’d overperform.

[1] https://data.bls.gov/cgi-bin/cpicalc.pl?cost1=1&year1=199901...

Re: WeWork Gets a Visit from Financial Reality

#113
post #72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're right on Tesla and WeWork, but not on Uber. Uber doesn't buy and own the car, which means it requires much less capital. This small change has many implications, and the tech helps solves many of the problems that come up. I am not saying it is properly valued (over or under or whatever). Just that given the choice between an Uber (or Lyft or yourlocalapp.com) or a cab company with the same fleet, customers, a…

Is Uber still using capital to pay operating expenses? [Edit] Doesn't Uber subsidize vehicle leases for drivers?

Doesn't Uber subsidize vehicle leases for drivers?

I don't remember if Uber does, but Lyft does.

Re: WeWork Gets a Visit from Financial Reality

#114
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I tried using a Regus space the other week. It didn't seem that much better than any other co-working space in regards to noise and bad manners?

Have you been in a WeWork office, though? IME all shared offices are incredibly noisy, I don't understand why anyone would want to rent there.

IME all shared offices are incredibly noisy

I did a lot of co-working from 2009-2012 in several cities. The atmosphere was always very quiet and professional. People were very cautious about creating noise, and few people every spoke aloud unless they were on the same team.

I'm not sure what changed. Was it the bro-ification of the tech industry? Did coworking get a lot cheaper, and brought in a lower class of people? Was it Starbucks making its stores less attractive to campers? It doesn't sound like I'd go back to coworking again.

Re: WeWork Gets a Visit from Financial Reality

#115

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But it obviously would have been a major component of any "Internet" basket at any date after its IPO in 1997. But 20% major? Perhaps not.

Keep in mind, too, that $1 in January 1999 would buy what $1.53 does today [1]. Saying you’d be 20% Amazon in 1999 is the same as saying you’d have bought the stock then. Yes, of course—with that prescience you’d overperform. [1] https://data.bls.gov/cgi-bin/cpicalc.pl?cost1=1&year1=199901...

5X is worse case, it's 15X in dollar terms, but an equivalent investment in Dow would be almost 3X so thus the discount.

It's also worse case because it assumes you buy at the $107 peak. It didn't spend much time above $100...

Re: WeWork Gets a Visit from Financial Reality

#116
post #4

>The Gulf investors backing the Vision Fund seem to have decided that WeWork is not a tech bet but simply an aggressive punt on real estate. This is the bogey man of a huge number of current 'tech startups' - What if it turns out Tesla really are a car company! Or if We Work are actually an office rental company! OR gasp Uber is a cab company! (1) We now have a glut of companies operating in traditional markets that…

>Not only this, but WeWork are going to learn about the cyclical nature of office rental revenue.

I don't know anything about office rental so I'm curious, what makes it cyclical? You also seem to imply that we're high on the cycle (otherwise it wouldn't be a problem for WeWork in the future), why do you think that?

Re: WeWork Gets a Visit from Financial Reality

#117
post #93

https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-01-08/wework... "In addition to the corporate finance weirdness: “Going forward, the company will no longer be called WeWork but rather The We Company.” (“The switch is not a legal name change,” okay.) And: “Rather than just renting desks, the company aims to encompass all aspects of people’s lives, in both physical and digital worlds,” which is—and I have spent years w…

WeDie with free beer/kombucha/whatever sounds pretty amazing tbh. Funeral home industry could benefit from some disruption.

Re: WeWork Gets a Visit from Financial Reality

#118
post #5
post #4

>The Gulf investors backing the Vision Fund seem to have decided that WeWork is not a tech bet but simply an aggressive punt on real estate. This is the bogey man of a huge number of current 'tech startups' - What if it turns out Tesla really are a car company! Or if We Work are actually an office rental company! OR gasp Uber is a cab company! (1) We now have a glut of companies operating in traditional markets that…

In 1999 there was an email going round about how ridiculous dotcom valuations were. Taking Amazon, I think, as an example it said it would have to earn more than Kodak, Boeing, Caterpillar etc to ever be worth it's valuation. There was a general sense of "it's just a bookstore". Now I know everything is more mature and the situation is different, but I also remember feeling very confident that Amazon was waaay overva…

What about pets.com and webvan? I feel like we are back in the webvan days again. Except the companies figured out they could trick regular folk into doing deliveries instead of driver who is an actual employee with some kind of benefits.

Re: WeWork Gets a Visit from Financial Reality

#119

I feel like WeWork would be one of the first companies to go under in case a recession hits the US market. Everyone who works there is probably going to decide en masse that they can do the same things from home or a Starbucks

Sounds about right. Spent a couple years at a WeWork in Los Angeles. It's a luxury, a glorified co-working community. People enjoy the beer. One shake of the economy and everybody will cut WeWork and go back home or somewhere considerably more affordable.

One shake of the economy and everybody will cut WeWork and go back home or somewhere considerably more affordable

Or even free.

When I was in the Seattle tech scene about ten years ago, the State of Washington had free co-working space at the convention center as a way to stimulate local entrepreneurship. The desks were a little strange, but they were free!

Re: WeWork Gets a Visit from Financial Reality

#120
post #93

https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-01-08/wework... "In addition to the corporate finance weirdness: “Going forward, the company will no longer be called WeWork but rather The We Company.” (“The switch is not a legal name change,” okay.) And: “Rather than just renting desks, the company aims to encompass all aspects of people’s lives, in both physical and digital worlds,” which is—and I have spent years w…

WeDie with free beer/kombucha/whatever sounds pretty amazing tbh. Funeral home industry could benefit from some disruption.

> We're disrupting funeral homes.

Man, that sounds...horrible.

Post reply on HN