Live data from Hacker News

The Hand Licking Incident

raisingfutureadults.blogspot.com

241–250 of 358 posts

Re: The Hand Licking Incident

#241

I dunno about this story. When I saw my son lick his hands the very first time, this was the convo: - Are your hands tasty? No - Are your hands dirty? No - Are your hands dry? Yes! Problem solved. Plus a quick visual inspection will usually confirm dry hands. It’s not like an insidious disease with no visible symptoms.

Sounds like debugging - sometimes it takes 5 minutes. For other people and other problems, it can take 5 days.

Re: The Hand Licking Incident

#242
> He felt we were interfering with his solution to his problem, not helping him. He was too young to understand the cause and effect relationship, and the way the adults around him had handled it just ensured that he would never come to us to ask for help with his real problem.

This passage really resonated with me. I fall into the same cognitive trap as that kid on a fairly regular basis. It happened between me and my parents until well after I left home, and it still happens between me and my wife and close friends. I've been aware of it for a while but have never seen it so clearly articulated. This has motivated me to redouble my efforts to take a more mature approach internally.

Re: The Hand Licking Incident

#243

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The first one's just ambiguity isn't it? "Where did you hurt yourself? At Timmy's place"

Yes, but its an example of how small children think

Sometimes adults also think like this, in slightly less obvious ways.

Re: The Hand Licking Incident

#244

I dunno about this story. When I saw my son lick his hands the very first time, this was the convo: - Are your hands tasty? No - Are your hands dirty? No - Are your hands dry? Yes! Problem solved. Plus a quick visual inspection will usually confirm dry hands. It’s not like an insidious disease with no visible symptoms.

I second that, the story is interesting and has the value of a general lesson, but on second thought it sounds like other obviously made-up anecdotes, such as "the car that wouldn't start after buying strawberry icecream" or the "emails that didn't go farther than 500km".

There is a little kid obsessively licking his hands in winter? They must have become very red and inflamed after only two or three days. Therefore, first thing a parent does seeing them red, is to put some cream on. End of the story.

Re: The Hand Licking Incident

#245

Am I the only one who thinks the parent is to blame for this because she didn't have the common sense to give gloves to her kid in the cold weather... To me that's unacceptable.

I just want to comment in a constructive way on this.

Do you have kids? If so, have you thought about, sorted out and covered all the things that would be unacceptable? What about what other people might think unacceptable, but you don't? If you however don't have kids, imho you are hardly entitled to criticise.

There are many legit reasons that could cause the mother to not necessarily provide gloves. Then again yes, maybe she wasn't paying attention. Who knows. That's not even the point.

It's very easy for us here to voice our opinion and openly criticise. But it would be sad if that's what someone gets for being open about mistakes they made and how they finally worked it out.

Re: The Hand Licking Incident

#246

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A sign of maturity is to a) recognize when code is crazy, and b) document why it is so in a comment.

Here let me fix that for you: "document why it is so in an executable test".

Sometimes possible, but not always.

An executable test is good for documenting what a piece of code should do, but not always entirely sufficient for documenting why.

Re: The Hand Licking Incident

#247
post #80

This reminds me of something that happened with our child. She started pulling her hair out at night as she fell asleep. Large clumps were pulled out over a month or two and every night there would be small amounts of hair removed. There was a lot of pressure to go to a psychologist from her GP and medication was suggested too. We were talking about it a lot and her hair was getting thin. One night we gave her a new…

You might enjoy this similar anecdote from an SSC post. > The Hair Dryer Incident was probably the biggest dispute I’ve seen in the mental hospital where I work. Most of the time all the psychiatrists get along and have pretty much the same opinion about important things, but people were at each other’s throats about the Hair Dryer Incident. > Basically, this one obsessive compulsive woman would drive to work every m…

This is a great solution! Now I just have to figure out how to disconnect my gas range and put it in my car every day :)

Re: The Hand Licking Incident

#249

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is it abusive and poor? No ones perfect, and parenting is the ultimate 'make it up as you go'. Could they have done better? Probably. Did they learn from their mistakes? Yes.

I realize the author learned from the situation and I hope they're a better person now, but I would certainly consider their behavior abusive. It's fortunate the kid was just dealing with dry skin. Imagine if it was something like OCD where they were dealing with an irresistible compulsion and had no way to express what they were experiencing. Is spanking an acceptable response? How about one or both parents telling…

Isn't the line for abuse subjective? Doesn't it partially rely on the motivations of the 'abuser'? If you circumcise your male child for religious reasons, is that abuse? What about forcing them to eat their vegetables?

Maybe we're just arguing semantics here? For me abuse is a strong word and something that social services should be getting involved with.

Re: The Hand Licking Incident

#250

Am I the only one who thinks the parent is to blame for this because she didn't have the common sense to give gloves to her kid in the cold weather... To me that's unacceptable.

Parenting is always a novice’s game, so it’s fairly easy to find fault. Even the article makes it obvious that the “problem” had an obvious and easily corrected solution.
Post reply on HN