Live data from Hacker News

Lego Porsche Crashtest in Slow-Motion (2017) [video]

youtube.com

11–18 of 18 posts

Re: Lego Porsche Crashtest in Slow-Motion (2017) [video]

#11

I was surprised to see that the rear portion of the car wasn't as heavily damaged, but when they picked it up, I noticed the floor appeared to be one large piece. My guess is, that was able to absorb enough of the crash energy, to bring the vehicle to a stop.

I have made one of these and it is not one piece. The floor is just very sturdy because it has a lot of long flat bars and is very will connected with a lot of fixings. The “skin” of the car on the other hand is very flimsy because they had to use a lot of tricks to get all the panels to have the correct angles with only standard LEGO parts. Many of them will flex when you touch them because they only have 2 attachme…

Fragility grows with size. The test speed of the downscaled version should be higher if anything.

Re: Lego Porsche Crashtest in Slow-Motion (2017) [video]

#15

I was surprised to see that the rear portion of the car wasn't as heavily damaged, but when they picked it up, I noticed the floor appeared to be one large piece. My guess is, that was able to absorb enough of the crash energy, to bring the vehicle to a stop.

I have made one of these and it is not one piece. The floor is just very sturdy because it has a lot of long flat bars and is very will connected with a lot of fixings. The “skin” of the car on the other hand is very flimsy because they had to use a lot of tricks to get all the panels to have the correct angles with only standard LEGO parts. Many of them will flex when you touch them because they only have 2 attachme…

Later in the video there’s a brief glimpse of the crash at real-time camera speed. The car is moving very fast.

Whatever the speed, this doesn’t look survivable, for either occupants or frankly any imaginary plastic people in the range of all that wickedly sharp LEGO shrapnel and flying wheels. I think a real 911 would do substantially better in a crash test; this is more like the result of those supercar crashes you see where some poor sod has lost control into Armco at 180mph.

Re: Lego Porsche Crashtest in Slow-Motion (2017) [video]

#17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have made one of these and it is not one piece. The floor is just very sturdy because it has a lot of long flat bars and is very will connected with a lot of fixings. The “skin” of the car on the other hand is very flimsy because they had to use a lot of tricks to get all the panels to have the correct angles with only standard LEGO parts. Many of them will flex when you touch them because they only have 2 attachme…

Later in the video there’s a brief glimpse of the crash at real-time camera speed. The car is moving very fast. Whatever the speed, this doesn’t look survivable, for either occupants or frankly any imaginary plastic people in the range of all that wickedly sharp LEGO shrapnel and flying wheels. I think a real 911 would do substantially better in a crash test; this is more like the result of those supercar crashes you…

Anytime the drivers compartment is completely open on one side before the paramedics cut it apart is a very bad crash indeed.
Post reply on HN