Live data from Hacker News

Sobriety startups shaking up the 12-step model

abc.net.au

31–40 of 201 posts

Re: Sobriety startups shaking up the 12-step model

#31
post #19

It only hit me in the past few months how ingrained alcohol/drinking culture is in adult lives. It’s absolutely everywhere (ads, sports events, festivals, workplace, nightlife, social events). It’s actually crazy how lightly we treat this addictive, toxic substance that we joke about despite how many people it kills every year and harms directly and indirectly. At some point I was unknowingly drinking 4-5 times a wee…

Depends on the quantity I guess, but... why is drinking 4-5 times a week not ok? Something like a glass of wine or a small beer should be fine, right? In some countries (e.g. France) it's a wide-spread habit to drink a glass of wine at lunch, and it doesn't seem to harm public health.

You're right when you say that the quantity is important.

The UK talks about "units" of alcohol. One unit is 10ml of pure alcohol. Drinks in the UK are labled with their Alcohol by Volume (ABV) percentage. To work out how many units are in a drink you multiply the serving size in litres by the ABV number. Current UK guidelines are no alcohol at all if you're pregnant, and less than 14 units a week with some days alcohol free and don't save up the units for a binge.

In the past wine used to be weaker and serving sizes were smaller. One unit of wine is one glass at 125ml at 8%. In the UK by law everywhere selling glass by the wine has to offer a 125ml serving. That doesn't have to be a prominent offer though, it could be a footnote to the menu. UK serving sizes tend to be 175ml (for a small) or 250ml (for a large). This means there's huge variation in the quantity that people drink when they describe "5 glasses a week".

Five glasses * 125ml * 8%ABV is 5 units.

Five glasses * 175ml * 12.5%ABV is 11 units.

Five glasses * 250ml *12.5%ABV is 15.5 units.

15 units a week isn't hugely worrying, but it's a big difference. I guess we'd want people drinking 15 units a week to unwind after work to take up some exercise or mindfulness instead.

There's some cultural variation too. When a middle class couple in the UK talk about "a glass of wine" that could mean "half a bottle", and "a few times a week" could mean "most days". I used to work in a factory and people spoke about "going for a beer" after work, and that never meant one beer, it meant a drinking session where two or three beers are drunk.

Re: Sobriety startups shaking up the 12-step model

#32

It only hit me in the past few months how ingrained alcohol/drinking culture is in adult lives. It’s absolutely everywhere (ads, sports events, festivals, workplace, nightlife, social events). It’s actually crazy how lightly we treat this addictive, toxic substance that we joke about despite how many people it kills every year and harms directly and indirectly. At some point I was unknowingly drinking 4-5 times a wee…

It used to be much more ingrained. Factory or construction workers used to drink during work, and if those old movies are to believe men would pour themselves drinks all the times. These days it is mostly acceptable to decline alcohol.

I concur. I used to work in a plastic factory in the 70's and at lunchtime there was a fair stream of machine operators who's make a beeline for the pub opposite. Pint or two of beer and a pie was the standard lunch.

Re: Sobriety startups shaking up the 12-step model

#33
This is very interesting, but it's important to realize that it has only been since the late 1950's that alcoholism has been treated as a disease. It started with a program called PAR at the post office that evolved into EAP (Employee Assistance Program) available at most major employers today.

Prior to the 20th century it was generally safer to consume an alcoholic beverage than otherwise because, well, alcohol kills bacteria.

But modern advertising has transformed Alcohol and Pornography into something truly mutated from their initial purposes. I'm sorry, but tech industry workers are mostly to blame for this - downvote me all you want, but I drink all I want as long as it doesn't involve getting behind a wheel of a car or being around children.

I've been through the Silicon Valley "Microdosing" culture and I used marijuana pretty heavily most of my childhood & adult life. I can confidently say drinking, no matter the amount is generally a better bet societally with self-driving cars on their way soon.

Example: I was camping in the great north and drinking water straight out of the lake, I could have bought a kit to try and sanitize the water with chemicals - but shots of Everclear grain alcohol got the job done.

Re: Sobriety startups shaking up the 12-step model

#34
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Depends on the quantity I guess, but... why is drinking 4-5 times a week not ok? Something like a glass of wine or a small beer should be fine, right? In some countries (e.g. France) it's a wide-spread habit to drink a glass of wine at lunch, and it doesn't seem to harm public health.

New findings show there’s no such thing as a “safe amount of alcohol” https://www.npr.org/2018/08/24/641618937/no-amount-of-alcoho...

Well, the increased risks from 1 glass of wine per day is abysmal. Even 2 glasses of wine.

Re: Sobriety startups shaking up the 12-step model

#35
Hey all HNers that might be wanting to stop drinking, or have trouble staying sober even though you try!

The community in https://reddit.com/r/stopdrinking is amazing and keeps me and many others on a sober path.

I've soon been sober for a year, and I was on a very destructive path. Would never have kept at it without that sub.

Here's how it helped me:

1. In the beginning I was hurting and feeling really isolated - posting semi-regular helped me vent and people with more sobriety under their belt gave support directly.

2. When I've been to occasions (weddings, birthday parties) that include drinking, I've been able to jump into the chat and find instant support telling me to not have the first drink.

3. There's a daily check-in where you post to pledge today's sobriety. In the beginning I pledged each day.

4. I have a badge by my name that keeps track of each day I've been sober. Having to reset that to zero is more motivating than you might believe at first.

5. I now comment on other users posts, trying to keep their mood up and push them to not drink by giving them support.

Also, the community and mods are superb, kind people.

Re: Sobriety startups shaking up the 12-step model

#36

It only hit me in the past few months how ingrained alcohol/drinking culture is in adult lives. It’s absolutely everywhere (ads, sports events, festivals, workplace, nightlife, social events). It’s actually crazy how lightly we treat this addictive, toxic substance that we joke about despite how many people it kills every year and harms directly and indirectly. At some point I was unknowingly drinking 4-5 times a wee…

It used to be much more ingrained. Factory or construction workers used to drink during work, and if those old movies are to believe men would pour themselves drinks all the times. These days it is mostly acceptable to decline alcohol.

It used to be acceptable and widespread to drink at lunch in white collar jobs, too.

Re: Sobriety startups shaking up the 12-step model

#37
post #31
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Depends on the quantity I guess, but... why is drinking 4-5 times a week not ok? Something like a glass of wine or a small beer should be fine, right? In some countries (e.g. France) it's a wide-spread habit to drink a glass of wine at lunch, and it doesn't seem to harm public health.

You're right when you say that the quantity is important. The UK talks about "units" of alcohol. One unit is 10ml of pure alcohol. Drinks in the UK are labled with their Alcohol by Volume (ABV) percentage. To work out how many units are in a drink you multiply the serving size in litres by the ABV number. Current UK guidelines are no alcohol at all if you're pregnant, and less than 14 units a week with some days alco…

> Five glasses x 250ml x 12.5%ABV is 15.5 units.

I’ve always found it easier to visualize drink quantities relative to a standard bottle, 750ml for most wine and spirits.

So that 250ml serving is 1/3 of a bottle per glass.

Re: Sobriety startups shaking up the 12-step model

#38
Most people with substance abuse problems “grow out of it” with no outside help at all.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.psychologytoday.com/us/arti...

Just from personal experience partying with lots of drugs and drinking in the rave scene when I was in my 20s and djing and promoting, the vast vast majority of people just got tired of it one day and quit — or it interferes with their jobs or their families and they did the right thing and stopped eventually.

12 steps’s entire thing about how once you’re an addict you’re going to be one for the rest of your life is just wrong.

Re: Sobriety startups shaking up the 12-step model

#39
post #19

It only hit me in the past few months how ingrained alcohol/drinking culture is in adult lives. It’s absolutely everywhere (ads, sports events, festivals, workplace, nightlife, social events). It’s actually crazy how lightly we treat this addictive, toxic substance that we joke about despite how many people it kills every year and harms directly and indirectly. At some point I was unknowingly drinking 4-5 times a wee…

Depends on the quantity I guess, but... why is drinking 4-5 times a week not ok? Something like a glass of wine or a small beer should be fine, right? In some countries (e.g. France) it's a wide-spread habit to drink a glass of wine at lunch, and it doesn't seem to harm public health.

I guess it depends what you define as "not ok". I mean, why is smoking 4-5 times a week not ok? Why is shooting up heroin 4-5 times a week not ok?

In the end, we're simply willfully poisoning ourselves. For some reason we, as a society, have decided that it's OK to poison ourselves with certain substances (caffeine, cigarette smoke) but not others (heroin, methamphetamines). We've made this socially acceptable. So if by "ok" you mean socially acceptable, thensure, it's ok.

Re: Sobriety startups shaking up the 12-step model

#40
post #11

After years and years of struggling with alcoholism and AA, I got sober with naltrexone using the "Sinclair Method". I followed the treatment plan for a few weeks and at the end quitting drinking was easy and obvious. That was just over ten years ago and I haven't had a drink or gone to any meetings since. I'm only one person and I'm fully aware that the plural of anecdote isn't data. However, the experience was so d…

First congrats on finding something that works for you and making it stick!

From that perspective, I can see why you would not like folks that insist on AA being a monopoly, but I'm curious about that position. I've seen a lot of people that hate AA and a lot of people that think it saved their lives, but I've never seen anyone say that AA must be the only way to sobriety. What's the angle?

Post reply on HN