Live data from Hacker News

Singapore activist found guilty of hosting ‘illegal assembly’ via Skype

techcrunch.com

1–10 of 187 posts

Re: Singapore activist found guilty of hosting ‘illegal assembly’ via Skype

#4
post #2

Im not sure I understand the story. He was judged for illegal assembly regardless of the Skype call, as far as I understand. Anyone else can comment?

"“The law says that any event which is open to the public, and is ’cause related’, requires a permit when a foreigner speaks."

There was a foreign speaker participating over Skype. As idiotic as the law seems to be, I do believe the case is rather clear. The foreigner did indeed speak at the conference, which was public. The fact that Skype was used as a medium to facilitate that doesn't really change anything.

Re: Singapore activist found guilty of hosting ‘illegal assembly’ via Skype

#5
post #2

Im not sure I understand the story. He was judged for illegal assembly regardless of the Skype call, as far as I understand. Anyone else can comment?

He had a gathering on private property in a mall, where 100 people showed up and listened to a Hong King Activist talk for 2 hours. Sounds quite like a conference IMO.

The right to free assembly isn't a thing in Singapore apparently.

Re: Singapore activist found guilty of hosting ‘illegal assembly’ via Skype

#6

> In Singapore, it is a criminal offence under the Public Order Act to organize or participate in a public assembly without a police permit. :(

It's a police state. A very neat and tidy one, but one with severe penalties; one of the few places still using corporal punishment officially.

Re: Singapore activist found guilty of hosting ‘illegal assembly’ via Skype

#7
post #5
post #2

Im not sure I understand the story. He was judged for illegal assembly regardless of the Skype call, as far as I understand. Anyone else can comment?

He had a gathering on private property in a mall, where 100 people showed up and listened to a Hong King Activist talk for 2 hours. Sounds quite like a conference IMO. The right to free assembly isn't a thing in Singapore apparently.

That’s weird. I thought they were trying to be a modern country?

Re: Singapore activist found guilty of hosting ‘illegal assembly’ via Skype

#8
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He had a gathering on private property in a mall, where 100 people showed up and listened to a Hong King Activist talk for 2 hours. Sounds quite like a conference IMO. The right to free assembly isn't a thing in Singapore apparently.

That’s weird. I thought they were trying to be a modern country?

Many modern countries have heavy restrictions on freedom of speech. The United States is the exception, not the rule.

Re: Singapore activist found guilty of hosting ‘illegal assembly’ via Skype

#10
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He had a gathering on private property in a mall, where 100 people showed up and listened to a Hong King Activist talk for 2 hours. Sounds quite like a conference IMO. The right to free assembly isn't a thing in Singapore apparently.

That’s weird. I thought they were trying to be a modern country?

And challenge the status quo? Not if the government can help it :P
Post reply on HN