Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Academics who switched to industry, what's your experience been like?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 77 posts

Re: Ask HN: Academics who switched to industry, what's your experience been like?

#11
I finished my PhD in neuroscience, then went to work for a new biotech startup in the Bay Area. I did a mix of programming and chemistry automation there. Then I started a software company with a lifelong friend and after a couple years we found product market fit and it took off. We’re almost 100 people now.

The work I do now has nothing to do with neuroscience, but I have zero regrets about my PhD. It was a fascinating period for me and I view it as an adventure I did in my 20s. I loved the work I did and it didn’t need to lead into something else.

Re: Ask HN: Academics who switched to industry, what's your experience been like?

#12
An education :) Two start ups after phd and postdoc. Liked academia but couldn't afford it with two young kids. Joined a well funded start up. Was great for the range of problems I got to engage with. Was eventually sold to a multinational and very quickly turned into a soul destroying journey into the abyss. So much dreadful politics and nastiness. Left for another start up and am enjoying it. Have been involved in more of the business side this time, which is also interesting (and maybe depressing). I think I like the early stages of making something new. Supporting production systems and generally being "in operations" isn't my cup of tea. Your experience may vary... Strangely mostly miss teaching rather than research. I do more research now, just don't publish it.

Re: Ask HN: Academics who switched to industry, what's your experience been like?

#14
I did my PhD in Civil Engineering and a 2 year postdoc in Austria (home country). I saw absolutely no future in academia, chances to get a permanent position were really slim and you could only go from one project to the other, which you had to hope to get funding for. Additionally, I was not happy with the group I was at.

So I decided to quit and found a new job at a small start up that is developing and providing consultancy for a CAE software. It was the best decision I ever made. I also did simulations during my academic life, but the pace has picked up significantly. I'm still at the forefront of research, but instead of pondering forever over minuscule details I'm now making stuff work. While the pay has not increased a lot, it's still better and I don't have to worry about getting funding, even though we do some research project, but if we don't get them it's not a huge issue. I have quite a diverse range of responsibilities including some managerial duties and I have grown and learned a lot in the past two years.

To sum up, it was great to leave and I wouldn't return unless I would be offered a professorship. I was extremely lucky with the company I work at and I think being in a small company allows to not just be another number in the system but actually contribute in many different ways. Obviously you need to have the right kind of people (incl. bosses) for that to be possible. Clearly, in a small company the human component is a crucial one.

Re: Ask HN: Academics who switched to industry, what's your experience been like?

#15

When I was post-doc at a well-respected university, the Profs treated me with a combination with disrespect and contempt (when they were not outright ignoring me). I switched to industry; my pay went up 3X-fold, and my talented colleagues praised those problem-solving abilities that I developed over the course of my academic career. My advice to you; f*ck academia! Its a petty pointless prison where you’ll never do a…

I'm sorry to hear that, I never had that experience in my post-doc phase. May I ask in what field/location that was?

Re: Ask HN: Academics who switched to industry, what's your experience been like?

#18

When I was post-doc at a well-respected university, the Profs treated me with a combination with disrespect and contempt (when they were not outright ignoring me). I switched to industry; my pay went up 3X-fold, and my talented colleagues praised those problem-solving abilities that I developed over the course of my academic career. My advice to you; f*ck academia! Its a petty pointless prison where you’ll never do a…

> the Profs treated me with a combination with disrespect and contempt (when they were not outright ignoring me).

That's my experience of working with PhDs in software development (Germany). Yes, you are very smart Mr. Dr. Whatever. No, your PhD doesn't give you authority on picking the building blocks for the front-end and devops stacks. Now chill and bugger off, go back to the C++ image processing ML models (1 year of development and no release still).

Re: Ask HN: Academics who switched to industry, what's your experience been like?

#20
The answers to this question will be as spread as possible, as a PhD is hardly comparable to another PhD.

Academic experience varies as much as the experience of working as a toilet cleaner compared to a man of independent means (= someone who stopped working for his/her money) - had to look this up (German: Privatier). It seems to me that there is no word for this in the English language which transports the true meaning [1]. Prove me wrong, please.

[1]: https://dict.leo.org/german-english/privatier

Post reply on HN