Live data from Hacker News

The Best History Books 2018

historytoday.com

11–20 of 31 posts

Re: The Best History Books 2018

#11
Off-topic: I majored in history for my BA. For the first year out of college, I struggled to find work, and was worried that I had made a terrible choice. 8 years on, after supplementing my studies with essentially an Associate’s in CS, my view has changed significantly. Here are the most useful skills that I’ve gained from my study of history:

* There’s a phrase among historians that writing history is like drinking in an oceanful of information and pissing out a cup. As a technical writer, this is obviously highly relevant to my work. But I’d venture that this skill will resonate with any “knowledge worker.”

* Towards the end of the major you start thinking about historiography, which is the study of writing history. You question what kinds of primary sources writers are basing their arguments on, and what kinds of biases (or “perspectives” to use a more neutral term) these writers are bringing to their analyses. A relevant skill in this age of “fake news.”

* History professors place a lot of value on concise writing. It’s obvious to me now why that would be the case, but at the time I didn’t make the connection.

* I went into the major with a vague desire to learn more about how society works. In that regard the field definitely does not disappoint. I enjoyed how open-ended the field of inquiry was. Yet at the same time you have to stay somewhat grounded in reality. I.e. when you write about a topic you have to provide primary sources that validate your argument.

Anyways, I don’t have any major agenda for writing all of this, other than the fact that it’s Saturday morning and I’m hyped on coffee and I figured someone might enjoy considering how studying history is still relevant to the modern workforce.

Re: The Best History Books 2018

#12

Anyone have a suggestion for American history? I am looking for something that focuses on how America grew into the leading world power in such a short amount of time comparatively.

I don't have a single book for you as that is a very broad theme, but honestly something textbook-y might be what you're looking for. Google for good surveys of American history. If you want to understand America as a world power, I would supplement a general textbook with some economic and military history. WW2 and the Cold War will be very important. A big factor in America's later dominance was the fact that so many other world powers were utterly devastated by the Second World War and could not maintain their former influence, so understanding the transformative half-century between the 1940s and 1990s will be key to answering your question. But I think you'll also be interested in the late 1800s (especially the post-Civil War period) as that is where you see some of America's industrial power really start to pick up. That's the era of major technological changes like the telegraph and railroads as well as the emergence of industrial powerhouses like Standard Oil.

Re: The Best History Books 2018

#13
post #8
post #2

Jill Lepore’s These Truths was the best history book this year. Perhaps this decade.

When you make such extraordinary subjective claims, please also bother write a small blurb as to what you found so enthralling about it. Because from I read, people are calling out this book out for its terrible bloopers and the author not doing his homework on facts.

The author, Jill Lepore, has been called out for not doing her homework on facts.

Re: The Best History Books 2018

#14

Anyone have a suggestion for American history? I am looking for something that focuses on how America grew into the leading world power in such a short amount of time comparatively.

Jill Lepore's These Truths is a good survey of American history published this year. Its focus is on the notion of America as experiment i.e. Will Democracy work? What makes it possible? And the wild exaggerations that result.

Re: The Best History Books 2018

#15

Off-topic: I majored in history for my BA. For the first year out of college, I struggled to find work, and was worried that I had made a terrible choice. 8 years on, after supplementing my studies with essentially an Associate’s in CS, my view has changed significantly. Here are the most useful skills that I’ve gained from my study of history: * There’s a phrase among historians that writing history is like drinking…

A philosophy graduate who had art history as minor here. I can totally relate to your comment!

Re: The Best History Books 2018

#16
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sounds like this book has a serious number of issues. https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/cr/B07BLKWBYT/ref=mw_dp_cr

Seems that the reviewer himself, S. J. Snyder, attributes a number of errors just based on his interpretative ideological slant.

I read the whole review. There’s nothing from Snyder that strikes me as an ideological critique. Each point is tied to factual errors leading to incorrect analysis and interpretation/presentation. There are a couple other reviews alongside Snyder that detail more factual and interpretive errors. What ideological slant are you seeing in Snyder’s critique?

Re: The Best History Books 2018

#17
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When you make such extraordinary subjective claims, please also bother write a small blurb as to what you found so enthralling about it. Because from I read, people are calling out this book out for its terrible bloopers and the author not doing his homework on facts.

The author, Jill Lepore, has been called out for not doing her homework on facts.

You should give the book a shot. It's received some pretty[0] killer[1] reviews[2] from sources more authoritative than an Amazon rando. And even if you go pretty far right[3], the reviews stay largely positive.

[0] https://www.nybooks.com/articles/2018/11/08/jill-lepore-amer...

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/14/books/review/jill-lepore-...

[2] https://www.chicagotribune.com/lifestyles/books/sc-books-the...

[3] https://www.nationalreview.com/magazine/2018/11/17/liberal-h...

Re: The Best History Books 2018

#18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Pairing A Patriot's History and A People's History makes for some interesting perspective. They don't really offer explicit points/counterpoints, but they certainly frame things differently over similar time periods (which cover America's coming of age to a powerful world presence). https://www.amazon.com/Patriots-History%C2%AE-United-States-... https://www.amazon.com/Peoples-History-United-States/dp/0062...

I know these books are great but do you know any book which is shorter read, sitting around 1000 pages each those are quite heavy reads

A People’s History is ~800 pages and clips along at a good pace. I don’t know that you can go much shorter with an overview of such a long period without sacrificing a lot of substance. I’d highly recommend making the investment into A People’s History - easily one of the most significant histories of America - and Howard Zinn’s other work if you end up appreciating it.

Re: The Best History Books 2018

#19
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When you make such extraordinary subjective claims, please also bother write a small blurb as to what you found so enthralling about it. Because from I read, people are calling out this book out for its terrible bloopers and the author not doing his homework on facts.

The author, Jill Lepore, has been called out for not doing her homework on facts.

Thanks for correcting. I briefly did pause to think it could be a 'her' (as I recognized Jill is commonly a female name), and even went as far as doing a half-hearted second skim of the Amazon URL, but still I lazily went with what my buggy "system 1"[+] endorsed.

[+] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thinking,_Fast_and_Slow

Re: The Best History Books 2018

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Pairing A Patriot's History and A People's History makes for some interesting perspective. They don't really offer explicit points/counterpoints, but they certainly frame things differently over similar time periods (which cover America's coming of age to a powerful world presence). https://www.amazon.com/Patriots-History%C2%AE-United-States-... https://www.amazon.com/Peoples-History-United-States/dp/0062...

I know these books are great but do you know any book which is shorter read, sitting around 1000 pages each those are quite heavy reads

The kids version is a lot shorter, not sure if it is just more terse or what: "A Young People's History of the United States"
Post reply on HN