Live data from Hacker News

Amazon reveals private Alexa voice data files

heise.de

21–24 of 24 posts

Re: Amazon reveals private Alexa voice data files

#21

Mods: The title should likely be changed back to the original ("Amazon reveals private Alexa voice data files"). The story here isn't that Echo stores recordings (they tell you they do, you can even listen to them) and it wasn't done "via GDPR" since that's a law, not a method of communication or platform.

Is you squint and tilt your head just enough, it's a communication protocol. Send a data request with the right header, data comes back.

Re: Amazon reveals private Alexa voice data files

#22
post #7

Since it seems like quite a lot of people are surprised that Amazon stores these recordings... PSA: you can go into the Alexa app and look at your Echo history and even listen to recordings of each interaction.

Google is the same - see your recordings here: https://myactivity.google.com/myactivity?restrict=vaa I'm not sure if it's codified in law, but big tech companies are moving towards 'if we store non-anonymized user data, it must be possible for the user to log in and see it themselves'. I think they do that so they can argue that storing and playing back the audio is a feature of the product, rather than something anc…

I was surprised they store a real recording. I thought they submitted some pre-processed form which saves bandwith, partly anonymizes the speech and then hands it off for recognition.

Re: Amazon reveals private Alexa voice data files

#23

Amazon also has people listen to your voice recordings so they can manually label the outcome for future training data.

Everyone does this, training data needs labels.

Obviously I recognize that training data needs labels as that’s why I said they did it. But I bet you ten bucks the average consumer does not expect humans to hear what they say to Alexa.

Re: Amazon reveals private Alexa voice data files

#24
post #7

Since it seems like quite a lot of people are surprised that Amazon stores these recordings... PSA: you can go into the Alexa app and look at your Echo history and even listen to recordings of each interaction.

Google is the same - see your recordings here: https://myactivity.google.com/myactivity?restrict=vaa I'm not sure if it's codified in law, but big tech companies are moving towards 'if we store non-anonymized user data, it must be possible for the user to log in and see it themselves'. I think they do that so they can argue that storing and playing back the audio is a feature of the product, rather than something anc…

This used to be called "search history", and then "web history", and now "my activity". These controls for user data have been a best practice Google has been following for many years.

https://policies.google.com/technologies/retention

Post reply on HN