Live data from Hacker News

Slack closes account of an Iranian user living in Canada

twitter.com

91–100 of 638 posts

Re: Slack closes account of an Iranian user living in Canada

#91
This kind of thing can kill Slack or other networks because if you have a team of 100 people and just one can't use the platform, you'll switch. The network effect seems likely to work in reverse in this case.

Beyond that I find it outrageously unethical.

Re: Slack closes account of an Iranian user living in Canada

#92

This link might give you a perspective https://twitter.com/stewart/status/391346582764789760

So you're assuming it's due to ethnic prejudice, based on nothing but the ethnicity of Slack's CEO?

The jewish propaganda machine is really after Iranian people wherever they are. A man proud of his Jewish heritage, may be connected to his peoples ideology. A proof, of course not, a correlation, maybe!

Re: Slack closes account of an Iranian user living in Canada

#93

Wow. This seems rather unprecedented and unnecessary, based upon the lack of action in this regard by other companies I don't know why Slack would do this. If for instance this kind of arbitrary action took place on GitHub I could see it having a detrimental impact to free software projects. This is another good reason to choose Zulipchat and other self-hostable platforms instead of proprietary SaaS solutions.

Totally agree about going to the self-hostable path. I would add as an alternative, looking for non-US products, maybe from neutral countries.

As someone mentioned in the twitter thread, this could happen to any product: Google, Facebook, even taking the bus!

Re: Slack closes account of an Iranian user living in Canada

#94

Why don't you use a free alternative as Matrix? If you self host, then you are the only one who controls who your users are.

It's not always your choice, and getting an organization to switch may be quite hard. Although Slack seems to be trying to help by pulling a stunt like this.

If I were in charge of an organization that used Slack for communication, I would immediately search for and start using an alternative service which would be hosted on premises.

Re: Slack closes account of an Iranian user living in Canada

#95
post #16
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Iran's been on my list of "wanna go" destinations for a while (Food and architecture mainly). Looks like I'd have to choose between that and having any connection with a US based company. Great.

Everyone I have ever met that has been to Iran absolutely raves about it. I've never met a single person that didn't extend their stay, and doesn't rate it as hands down the best country they have ever been to. It's very, very high on my list. But if you have an American or British passport you currently can't go without an escort. (I'm an Overlander, I drove AK-Argentina and am now driving right around Africa. I've…

So I saw an interesting little travel show, where Norwegian presenter Line Elvsåshagen was trying to travel on the "kindness of strangers": she'd post on instagram that she was looking for people to meet/eat/stay with, and film the result.

This worked even in Iran, and she met up with a Norwegian-Iranian family; but her government assigned minder/'translator' wouldn't let her sleep in their house. She counted as a journalist and there's no way Iran would let a loose journalist float around their society interviewing unsupervised ordinary people for the TV.

Pity, it does look like an interesting place to visit.

Re: Slack closes account of an Iranian user living in Canada

#96
post #74

As an outsider, I am really surprised by how deep-rooted America's hostility is towards Iran. Shi'ite Iran certainly has human rights issues, but as far as terrorism is concerned the majority of them are orchestrated by Sunni groups. 9/11 hijackers, Al Queda, Islamic State, Paris attackers - are all Sunni.

Iran is an easy enemy for the US government to offer to its citizens.

Because of the fairly harsh anti-US rhetoric circulated by the Iranian government to its citizens since the revolution (itself because of our previous support of the Shah and current support of Israel) for purposes of maintaining power, it's easy to say "Look, Iran hates America."

The Shia / Sunni distinction is largely lost on the average American.

And just as a personal note, almost every Iranian I've met in the US has been an awesome person. They've got a fascinating history and culture.

Re: Slack closes account of an Iranian user living in Canada

#98
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Face recognition will solve that for you.

Good luck guessing ethnicity for Iran. There will be many who look less middle-eastern than your average "Californian with a tan". You'd have the same problem with most near-east or Mediterranean countries. Being at the crossroads for a few millennia will do that to a place.

State face recognition doesn't have to be any more accurate than other forms of institutional, armed, racism.

Re: Slack closes account of an Iranian user living in Canada

#99
post #64

A couple of our employees from Syria also got blocked today. They were using Slack from Syria though. EDIT: I don't understand why they ban/block the account rather than "simply" block access from IPs from the country. This seems really strange and overreaching.

How do you have employees in Syria? It’s a violation of federal sanctions. Edit: In the US, UK, and EU.

We're not a US company (I hope there are no sanctions in our own country. I somehow doubt it, but I'm not entirely sure to be honest, so I won't mention the country to avoid getting us in potential trouble... Anyone knows which other countries enforce similar sanctions on Syria??).

Re: Slack closes account of an Iranian user living in Canada

#100

Wow. This seems rather unprecedented and unnecessary, based upon the lack of action in this regard by other companies I don't know why Slack would do this. If for instance this kind of arbitrary action took place on GitHub I could see it having a detrimental impact to free software projects. This is another good reason to choose Zulipchat and other self-hostable platforms instead of proprietary SaaS solutions.

Totally agree about going to the self-hostable path. I would add as an alternative, looking for non-US products, maybe from neutral countries. As someone mentioned in the twitter thread, this could happen to any product: Google, Facebook, even taking the bus!

Neutral countries? What’s a neutral country?
Post reply on HN