Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How much compensation would you like from "Hacker Monthly"?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 20 posts

Re: Ask HN: How much compensation would you like from "Hacker Monthly"?

#3
I'd like a link to my HN username, or Twitter username. No money needed.

I think we all frequently write for "free" on websites that earn money from user-generated content/ presence. I don't feel cheated by this.

It's a good investment to write for free (I think of it more like interacting or participating) because I learn stuff from smart people, get relationships with nice people, attention for stuff I work on, and am able to pass on attention to stuff I am a fan of.

I'm not opposed to writers getting compensated with money, but in this case i'm not sure it's the currency that would help either party out the most.

Re: Ask HN: How much compensation would you like from "Hacker Monthly"?

#5
I would rather see the price drop to $0 if not, drop the price by the amount you would be paying the authors. Alternatively, you can look into swag like free subscriptions for contributors.

Though I wonder what kind of change in dynamics on the site would we see once the mturk people find out that you can get paid for posting articles and comments at HN.

Re: Ask HN: How much compensation would you like from "Hacker Monthly"?

#7
As presently, nothing. Just full and proper credit. (Though I believe you recently said a year's subscription comes as part of it, which is great!) Why? Because we don't produce blog posts, etc, in order to merely get into Hacker Monthly - it's just republishing work that's already been produced.

Re: Ask HN: How much compensation would you like from "Hacker Monthly"?

#8
As I mentioned here (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1856101):

We give our authors a print copy plus 1 year digital subscription. The comment contributors get the digital copy plus 1 year digital subscription.

Edit: And of course, full and proper credit (Thanks, Peter). The author also gets to link to his/her websites/twitter account in the his/her biography.

Re: Ask HN: How much compensation would you like from "Hacker Monthly"?

#9
post #2

[deleted]

Paying people per word is just silly. Can we please not carry over this hackish way of valuing a writer's contribution?

If we wanted a metric of the value of the post, I would think up-votes would be a better metric. But personally, I agree with the others here saying that monetary compensation is not a good idea. Or, if you feel the desire to give back to the community financially for financial success you are having,perhaps a donation to PG or YC for maintaining this site.

(Yes, I know he doesn't need it, and I know he gets value from the site. Saying thank you is still a good idea, both because he does good things with money, and because it [the gesture, more than the money] will keep him interested and involved, even as his success and demands for his time continue to grow.)

Re: Ask HN: How much compensation would you like from "Hacker Monthly"?

#10
I would like to say nothing but I know some authors won't want to be included without the magazine being free in some form. I'm afraid this will jeopardize the quality of the articles and reduce overall readership. How about making the electronic (only) version free (again) and giving author credit/promotion.
Post reply on HN