>
There are lots of companies that are in it to do good or actually improve society.I don't disagree. They rarely get media attention though, and I don't mention them here, because their disruption is a quite different thing from Uber/AirBnB disruption.
For that "lame analysis" part, I'll give you a task: given that you wrote there are lots of such companies, name three. ;).
> I'd even argue that society is net better off with Lyft (not sure about Uber) even though working there as an employee isn't great. Taxis were awful.
Taxis were awful in many places, not everywhere. I'm usually taking people's word for it when they describe how Uber service is better than taxi (though I'm increasingly noticing stories about Uber quality declining). But there are cities, including my home town and the current town I live in, where taxis are almost universally good. And yet, Uber came and attacked taxis everywhere, whether good or bad. You can do things like that when you can freely break the law[0] and get away with it[1], and when you can lose money for longer than all your competitors can stay solvent.
Honestly, Uber story looks pretty much like a typical story of a corporation entering international market and displacing all little local players, except with more disregard for law, and some weird belief people still have that Uber is a startup.
Still, I'll grant Uber that some of the disruption came out for the better, because it allowed more ethical and legal competitors to emerge in this space. And yet:
> working there as an employee isn't great
Here's a thing: do we consider pushing more and more people into wage slavery to be "improving society"?
--
[0] - Not just general "taxi regulations", but also traffic safety (a common story to hear was Uber without valid insurance) and tax laws (in my country, I remember our equivalent of IRS being the most active in hunting down Uber drivers).
[1] - Half of the blame here goes to the municipal governments, who should've punished Uber immediately for breaking local laws. AFAIR only Germany behaved correctly, and started issuing service bans quickly.