Live data from Hacker News

Tumblr refugees trying to save its NSFW content

fastcompany.com

51–60 of 66 posts

Re: Tumblr refugees trying to save its NSFW content

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Reddit actively discourages people from posting their own original content, other than a small number of subs intended for it.

Are you sure? Among the reddit snobs not posting "original content" is frowned upon

I think he's talking specifically about NSFW subreddits, where many do say "no self generated content" specifically to avoid tumblr-style underage problems.

Re: Tumblr refugees trying to save its NSFW content

#52
post #35

Awful site. Won't even load if cookies are blocked. Summary, after stripping all markup: The internet is for porn, goes the song from musical Avenue Q. Since Tumblr announced this week that it will no longer be part of that internet, many users are mounting an exodus to existing networks like still-freewheeling Twitter, as well as efforts to build a new kind of Tumblr, the kind of Tumblr that Tumblr had been until no…

The text loaded fine for me with javascript disabled. No ads or autoplaying videos.

Re: Tumblr refugees trying to save its NSFW content

#53
post #35

Awful site. Won't even load if cookies are blocked. Summary, after stripping all markup: The internet is for porn, goes the song from musical Avenue Q. Since Tumblr announced this week that it will no longer be part of that internet, many users are mounting an exodus to existing networks like still-freewheeling Twitter, as well as efforts to build a new kind of Tumblr, the kind of Tumblr that Tumblr had been until no…

Just use reader view, it's not like you don't have the option.

Re: Tumblr refugees trying to save its NSFW content

#56
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tumblr was pretty terrible at handling CP reports. Like, I reported someone who posted sexually explicit photos supposedly of themself whilst admitting they were underage, and it took two months for Tumblr to send a form message saying they were looking into it and might or might not do something.

This is not going to be a popular comment, but it seems like the main problems in that situation are poor parenting and the harsh criminalization of willful adolescent behavior as "child" "pornography".

Either way, it would be a nice feature for an image service to help protect children who might fall into this crack. I think it's one of those things where legally you probably want to run a service like this as a carrier so that you don't get yourself in trouble by making mistakes. But as company that tries to be a good citizen in a society, I think you want to make it as difficult as possible for children to post NSFW images of themselves. I don't necessarily think of Verizon as a good corporate citizen most of the time, but I think it's completely reasonable for people in society to ask them to do so.

Re: Tumblr refugees trying to save its NSFW content

#57
post #16

No mention of reddit?

I think reddit serves a different purpose. It's not about personal accounts and subscribing to people; instead, everyone has a few collaborative lists (subreddits) and you don't really repost things. Upvotes are similar but again not the same.

It might be used as a substitute but the people that stuck to Tumblr this long probably consciously chose not to move to reddit.

Re: Tumblr refugees trying to save its NSFW content

#58
post #14

This decade feels like the Victorian era all over again. How long did the last one last?

Here is one plausible theory: http://www.rationaloptimist.com/blog/the-censorious-age

it's mostly observations, not theory. And he doesn't even touch on the Spanish Inquisition that sprang out of silicon valley and anti-Trump media after his election.

Re: Tumblr refugees trying to save its NSFW content

#59
post #20
post #11

That's cute. The Tumblr Refugees don't think that Twitter is censored.

It’s not. The only caveats are that you have to mark porn as porn, and you’re not allowed to get paid for it. Source: https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/xwavkq/j

Twitter is massively censored. I don't know why anyone would claim otherwise. Twitter lies about shaddowbanning people, and is highly selective of enforcement of their policies.

Re: Tumblr refugees trying to save its NSFW content

#60

The issue they are going to run into is that they are automatically going to be labeled a porn site. As such they will automatically lose the top tier of advertisers and payment processors. In addition, because they are new and probably won’t have the filtering systems in place, very offensive content including cp will likely get posted. This will further make them a pariah to the main stream internet with app stores…

Apple didn't ban Tumblr for NSFW content, they dropped it from the store because they couldn't keep CP from showing up in the app.
Post reply on HN