Live data from Hacker News

Pong written in both flash and HTML5. Left side is flash, right side is HTML5.

labs.codecomputerlove.com

11–20 of 129 posts

Re: Pong written in both flash and HTML5. Left side is flash, right side is HTML5.

#18
While I'm seeing better perf on the flash side (XP, FF 3.6.12), Pong isn't exactly an ideal test bed.

Interesting that on the page they say "We believe the two technologies are not in competition" but that is exactly what this type of demo is going to stir up. While the improvements in browsers and javascript engines as of late has been nice, I think we're still a few years off from real parity, especially on lower-spec'd machines. Make no mistake, Flash on the web will be obsoleted by HTML5. But not yet, especially for all those people who don't update their browser every month.

For the time being, if Flash evangelists really wanted to make a point, they should do this same type of set up, but with a complicated (hardware-accelerated?) visualization.

Re: Pong written in both flash and HTML5. Left side is flash, right side is HTML5.

#19

IBM thinkpad T61, 2GB ram, running firefox 3.6.8 for Ubuntu 9.10 (yeah yeah, I know), and Flash 10,1,82,76 . Ball is nice and smooth on HTML5 side, and kind of jerky on flash side. That could just be Linux+flash issues, but the animation for HTML5 is super-smooth, so I'm guessing it's just bad flash plugin.

Flash on linux sucks quite a bit unfortunately :(

Re: Pong written in both flash and HTML5. Left side is flash, right side is HTML5.

#20
post #12

Interesting problem of tuning both sides speed. Here (small Atom netbook hooked to big screen) the ball moves noticeably faster on the Flash side. To the point of making me lose a Pong match with myself.

Why so somber? You also won the match! ;)
Post reply on HN