Live data from Hacker News

Vladimir Lukyanov's hydraulic computer

pruned.blogspot.com

21–30 of 78 posts

Re: Vladimir Lukyanov's hydraulic computer

#21

In the 1980s people in chemistry labs that needed to find the area beneath a curve used to print/plot the curve, cut out the area and weigh it. This worked quite well as they had accurate scales.

Ha! Very interesting. And the density of paper was uniform enough? Or maybe they used a different material?

I'm not sure if they ever did a scientific study on this, but you can choose your accuracy by playing with the scale of the plot.

Re: Vladimir Lukyanov's hydraulic computer

#22

In the 1980s people in chemistry labs that needed to find the area beneath a curve used to print/plot the curve, cut out the area and weigh it. This worked quite well as they had accurate scales.

There was one experiment in physics lab course (undergraduate level) just ten years ago in which we also had to integrate like this. Not because we lacked better methods but to have experienced that it can be done this way.

Re: Vladimir Lukyanov's hydraulic computer

#24
> he water level in various chambers (with precision to fractions of a millimeter) represented stored numbers

I wonder how did they deal with thermal expansion. Maybe instead of using water at room temp they heated it to something higher and then a thermostat took care of it? But it still would be very hard to distribute heat evenly.

Re: Vladimir Lukyanov's hydraulic computer

#26
post #10

In a related vein, Ars Technica writer Sean Gallagher did a fantastic story on the US Navy's analog fire guidance computers a few years ago: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/03/gears... The instruction videos alone are worth the visit. Geekery of the first order.

Incidentally, these were the computers in the early Heinlein books.

I was mulling the comment here a few days ago pointing out Heinlein's prescient depiction of networked computers, and thinking that the hard part would be having mechanical computers pick up the phone and sending electromagnetic pulses down the line. Perhaps pecking at telegraph keys ...

Re: Vladimir Lukyanov's hydraulic computer

#29

This rather reminds me of the economic model in Terry Pratchett's "Making Money".

Fun fact, the device you're referring to was actually based on a different real-life water-based computer, the MONIAC[1]. It used basins of water, pipes, and adjustable flow regulators as a physical metaphor for the movement of money in macro-economics. I'm personally a really big fan, and I've need meaning to work up a simulation for quite some time now.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MONIAC

Post reply on HN