Live data from Hacker News

Israeli scientists develop tissue implants that won't be rejected

israel21c.org

31–34 of 34 posts

Re: Israeli scientists develop tissue implants that won't be rejected

#31
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apologies for an unsubstantial comment, but biology blows my mind. Do we know when these features in our immune system evolved? I assume something this foundational is shared with fish or maybe earlier?

Vertebrates have an adaptive immune system. It’s astounding from a biological and information theory perspective. Genes basically mutate themselves so they can form an enormous variety of proteins instead of the typical one to one mapping of gene to protein. Then there is a protein selection process that weeds out those antigens that bind to the host of that don’t bind to anything, leaving those that can bind to fore…

I think you described it pretty well. my version of the same: During their development Lymphocytes have 'gene cassettes' that get shuffled randomly so that the specificity of the receptor (antibody for cells, T cell receptor for T cells) is random for each individual lymphocyte cell during development. The ones that bind "Self" stuff are killed off during their development and the rest of them other just hang out waiting for something that binds their receptor. (There is a step here where T cells must bind to MHC within an affinity window to survive) If they find it the reproduce rapidly making many more cells with that specify. once amazing thing is that during that cell replication at the sites of antibody specificity the DNA copying gets sloppy, allowing new mutations to 'fine tune' the specificity of the antibody to the antigen (called somatic hypermutation). The cells that bind the tightest to the foreign antigen, reproduce the most robustly providing an 'evolution' of increasing affinity to the antigen. This stuff is only the tip of the iceberg - immunology it is amazing.

Re: Israeli scientists develop tissue implants that won't be rejected

#33

This is interesting stuff but I don't think the article describes anything groundbreaking. The cells used by the scientists in the article are called adipose-derived stem cells and their applications are already well known in the regenerative medicine industry. See https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3668445 The biologists I develop software with have been talking about adipose-derived stem cells for over a…

Isn't the story eerily similar to the Macchiarini scandal at Karolinska from a few years ago? https://forbetterscience.com/2016/04/26/the-stem-cell-faith-... He also thought he could use adipose stem cells for implants but it didn't work and patients died. E.g if the new method causes implants not to be rejected that would indeed be a breakthrough, but many have tried and failed so one should be extremely skeptical about these claims.
Post reply on HN