Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Amazon Rekognition updates face detection, analysis and recognition capabilities

aws.amazon.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–20 of 57 posts

Re: Amazon Rekognition updates face detection, analysis and recognition capabilities

#11

Post by darkport »

metildaa wrote: post #2

Woo, better facial recognition for all kinds of nefarious purposes! Edit: Dead serious, how will Rekognition positively affect the common person? All I see is a myriad of possible ways government, corporations and individuals have abused camera footage today, and emboldened with better technology these problems are likely to get much worse.

It’s quite hard to do this randomly. You need a substantial data set to train the machine to recognise your targets face. You can’t just upload 5 or 6 blurry social media photos.

Re: Amazon Rekognition updates face detection, analysis and recognition capabilities

#12

Post by simple_man »

metildaa wrote: post #2

Woo, better facial recognition for all kinds of nefarious purposes! Edit: Dead serious, how will Rekognition positively affect the common person? All I see is a myriad of possible ways government, corporations and individuals have abused camera footage today, and emboldened with better technology these problems are likely to get much worse.

This will catch lots of criminals. That is a good thing.

Re: Amazon Rekognition updates face detection, analysis and recognition capabilities

#13

Post by tictok4 »

bhhaskin wrote: post #10

I went to a concert the other night, and they where scanning driver licenses and running facial recognition on everyone entering. It was very disconcerting. It is clear to me that we need new laws to protect against the misuse of this technology. Laws that apply to everyone without exceptions for law enforcement. If we don't I fear we are headed towards a 1984 type of future.

Where was this? I would have refused entry and demanded a refund.

Re: Amazon Rekognition updates face detection, analysis and recognition capabilities

#14

Post by origami777 »

pjmorris wrote: post #7
foolfoolz wrote: post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

all this FUD around facial recognition being bad for everyone feels eerily similar to the FUD that strong encryption is good for terrorists

FUD aside, I'm with the GP on a question that you might have an answer for: How will Rekognition positively affect the common person?

Outside of facial recognition, the service will allow online marketplaces and dating sites to stay safer. They all have a problem where spammers and fraudsters post images with content meant to deceive or abuse site policies.

With facial recognition, app developers can build services like the ones tgat Google and Apple have built in their phones; the ability to look at your photos to see which ones have you or others that are close to you, organize those, etc. Who knows what else Devs will come up with.

Re: Amazon Rekognition updates face detection, analysis and recognition capabilities

#15

Post by tintor »

bhhaskin wrote: post #10

I went to a concert the other night, and they where scanning driver licenses and running facial recognition on everyone entering. It was very disconcerting. It is clear to me that we need new laws to protect against the misuse of this technology. Laws that apply to everyone without exceptions for law enforcement. If we don't I fear we are headed towards a 1984 type of future.

Also don't go to concerts that do this.

Re: Amazon Rekognition updates face detection, analysis and recognition capabilities

#16

Post by king_magic »

origami777 wrote: post #14
pjmorris wrote: post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

FUD aside, I'm with the GP on a question that you might have an answer for: How will Rekognition positively affect the common person?

Outside of facial recognition, the service will allow online marketplaces and dating sites to stay safer. They all have a problem where spammers and fraudsters post images with content meant to deceive or abuse site policies. With facial recognition, app developers can build services like the ones tgat Google and Apple have built in their phones; the ability to look at your photos to see which ones have you or others…

I cannot think of a single way facial recognition will really truly help either of those “stay safer”.

I find Google and Apple’s photo recognition features to be of extremely limited usefulness to begin with. Don’t really except other devs to come up with other compelling use cases.

Facial recognition is a technology without a killer app. Unless that killer app is over-the-top, oppressive Big Brother-like security.

Re: Amazon Rekognition updates face detection, analysis and recognition capabilities

#17

Post by teej »

tintor wrote: post #15
bhhaskin wrote: post #10

I went to a concert the other night, and they where scanning driver licenses and running facial recognition on everyone entering. It was very disconcerting. It is clear to me that we need new laws to protect against the misuse of this technology. Laws that apply to everyone without exceptions for law enforcement. If we don't I fear we are headed towards a 1984 type of future.

Also don't go to concerts that do this.

It’s not like this is listed on the ticket. You don’t know how the venue is going to enforce until you’re there for the first time.

Re: Amazon Rekognition updates face detection, analysis and recognition capabilities

#18

Post by aviv »

dawhizkid wrote: post #6

I played around with Rekognition a few months ago and frankly wasn’t that impressed with what it could do. As far as I can remember it could sort of compare if the same person was in two photos (definitely false negatives with various photos of myself I compared), basic OCR of text off images, and not very accurate recognition of certain things/objects.

It is always a couple versions behind the build that the NSA/CIA has on their AWS account.

Re: Amazon Rekognition updates face detection, analysis and recognition capabilities

#19

Post by foolfoolz »

pjmorris wrote: post #7
foolfoolz wrote: post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

all this FUD around facial recognition being bad for everyone feels eerily similar to the FUD that strong encryption is good for terrorists

FUD aside, I'm with the GP on a question that you might have an answer for: How will Rekognition positively affect the common person?

i see a big opportunity in home security.

domestic abuse, alert in case your abuser is at your home. and automatically lock your door.

restraining order? add their face and do the same. i see a future where getting a face scan is a requirement of every restraining order

this tech can save lives

Re: Amazon Rekognition updates face detection, analysis and recognition capabilities

#20

Post by jtwaleson »

metildaa wrote: post #2

Woo, better facial recognition for all kinds of nefarious purposes! Edit: Dead serious, how will Rekognition positively affect the common person? All I see is a myriad of possible ways government, corporations and individuals have abused camera footage today, and emboldened with better technology these problems are likely to get much worse.

I work in tele-medicine and we use rekognition to see if users are following the instructions correctly. E.g. you have to be at a certain distance from the screen, close an eye, take your glasses off, etc.

Also, things like virtual try-on for glasses use facial recognition tech. This allows you to map frames on your face so you can buy them online.

These applications don't use facial recognition to identify users, but to be smart digital assistants. They can function anonymously and don't have to store sensitive information.

There are many good applications.

Post reply on HN