Live data from Hacker News

Real Men Use Android: Special Forces Favor Google Phone

wired.com

41–50 of 52 posts

Re: Real Men Use Android: Special Forces Favor Google Phone

#42
post #7
post #4

One problem with releasing your code as open source is it can get used in ways that you don't approve of, eg weapon systems by the military or crapware by the carriers.

This is why the GPL is better than Apache. The military would have to release their code.

Never argue licensing with people with guns.

Re: Real Men Use Android: Special Forces Favor Google Phone

#43

Pretty good article. For one that works directly with the troops as well as building tools for the R&D department for my company. We are building and showing off tools just like what is explained in this article to try and win contracts just like this. We are always looking for more things and ways to help the troops out. This article does a good job of actually telling the public what the private sector builds for t…

For all the flack vets/servicemen get, it's not their war. Policymakers such as Bush determined what servicemen would do. Servicemembers can save lives in Katrina, and they may be ordered to carry out bombing missions--a lot of people were commissioned/enlisted during 9/11 after being moved by the collapse of the twin towers: it is a case of bait and switch, when we were sold the falsehoods of the "War on Terror."

What the military does is not a binary answer. The public chooses the commander in chief and the policy (Congress). It's a system that has endured for the last three centuries. You have the power to change it, and if you don't like it and don't speak up, remember V for Vendetta: "If you're looking for the guilty, you need only look into a mirror."

I sometimes remember the story of my girlfriend's grandpa: He was a Japanese soldier drafted in the Second World War. Around the same time, my maternal grandmother was serving as a provincial administrator of the Republic of China version of the IRS as one of the first college educated female accountants. She had to dress up as a man, cut her hair short to avoid being summarily raped and shot in Nanjing, then-capital of China. So now you know I'm of Chinese ethnicity dating a Japanese girl. My girlfriend's grandpa on a China mission was ordered by his commander to shoot one of the prisoners. If he refused, he would most likely be shot (most militaries allow this; the UCMJ allows this in combat). It was a choice between his life or somebody else's. If you watched Dark Knight, you know it's never a black or white answer. It's always a cruel decision to make. Just ask any Vietnam vet who saw combat. If my girlfriend's grandpa didn't shoot the man, my girlfriend might not exist. If he did, he would be a conscientious objector at the expense of his life, and I would not meet my girlfriend. All the while it's awful 40 million Chinese people lost their lives to the Japanese. There are your obvious offenders, the ones that do enjoy raping and killing people, but they are not normal and are present even in civilian society. A lot of them are likely decent people, and would secretly free Chinese prisoners if they had the opportunity.

I wish we could all be pacifists, but should we eliminate the military? I'm sure that's a resounding no, and I realize my sentiment may not be the most popular on HN, but we would be looking at anarchy without the men manning the silos too.

War is awful and thankfully the Internet seems to be eliminating 99.9% of armed conflicts. There is no point in senseless loss of life. But we still need a good defense--maybe not as much power as we have now, bur nonetheless something to protect the border.

Re: Real Men Use Android: Special Forces Favor Google Phone

#45

Pretty good article. For one that works directly with the troops as well as building tools for the R&D department for my company. We are building and showing off tools just like what is explained in this article to try and win contracts just like this. We are always looking for more things and ways to help the troops out. This article does a good job of actually telling the public what the private sector builds for t…

For all the flack vets/servicemen get, it's not their war. Policymakers such as Bush determined what servicemen would do. Servicemembers can save lives in Katrina, and they may be ordered to carry out bombing missions--a lot of people were commissioned/enlisted during 9/11 after being moved by the collapse of the twin towers: it is a case of bait and switch, when we were sold the falsehoods of the "War on Terror." Wh…

That was interesting to read, thanks.

>>40 million Chinese people lost their lives to the Japanese

More than I've read, reference? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_war_crimes#Mass_killin...

(Also, see famine parts there.)

Also, that figure seems much higher than the official Chinese: http://wiki.answers.com/Q/How_many_Chinese_were_killed_by_th...

How many did the Chinese communist party get killed with hunger in the sixties and during the culture revolution?

>>War is awful and thankfully the Internet seems to be eliminating 99.9% of armed conflicts.

I think that is more of the democratic peace theory -- democracies don't fight wars with each others (-: not even USA :-). In the rest of the world, we really hope that China stays stable and go democratic...

Re: Real Men Use Android: Special Forces Favor Google Phone

#46
post #34
post #29

Apparently "real men" can't be pacifists. Good to know.

I like one of the comments over there: >Wrong on so many levels. Primarily the assumption that real men shoot third world peasants in the face for pay.

...so third world girls have the chance to go to school.

Re: Real Men Use Android: Special Forces Favor Google Phone

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apparently "real men" can't be iPhone users. Good to know. :)

Back in AF, pilots in training would be obsessed with their iPhones playing X-Plane. It actually is a fantastic simulator considering that many of these pilots could very possibly be flying your commercial jet someday :) My buddy who went the cargo AF pilot route is a heavy iPhone user, but I guess the rest of the military doesn't consider the AF a real branch and call it the "Air Farce." The AF is going towards the…

> The AF is going towards the UAV route

Can you explain what this means?

Re: Real Men Use Android: Special Forces Favor Google Phone

#48
post #29

Apparently "real men" can't be pacifists. Good to know.

Link bait headline distracts from content of article, as usual.

(As a pacifist I wouldn't contribute to this project, but your comment doesn't really address the substance of the article, which is very interesting and makes some interesting statements about the sort of smartphone technology being used in warfare.)

Re: Real Men Use Android: Special Forces Favor Google Phone

#49
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Macho. But a phone is exactly where you want a VM. In fact, I would love to be able to push vm images for my phone from my desktop machine. Wake up, plug phone, push image. Security upgrades, new GPS data, my downloaded podcasts, news, emails, etc. I want to be able to come home with a new handset, plug it, and have my "phone" back.

Totally different use of the term "virtual machine". You're talking about a virtualised execution environment, or hardware virtual machine (as executed by virtualbox, xen or whatever); he's talking about a runtime virtual machine (like the CLR, JVM, or Dalvik).

The distinction is negligible on the mobile phone where the the 'runtime VM' takes care of memory allocation for even "native" C code.
Post reply on HN