Live data from Hacker News

Corretto – No-cost, multiplatform, developer-preview distribution of OpenJDK

aws.amazon.com

91–100 of 147 posts

Re: Corretto – No-cost, multiplatform, developer-preview distribution of OpenJDK

#91

"This initial release is a developer preview release for testing and validation purposes." Well... that's not really production-ready then, is it? I assume they intend to make it 'production-ready' at some point in the future, but those two statements are directly at odds.

I think the idea is that it will be.

Re: Corretto – No-cost, multiplatform, developer-preview distribution of OpenJDK

#92
post #30
post #15

> Amazon Corretto is a no-cost, multiplatform, production-ready distribution of the Open Java Development Kit I really, really wish AWS would start using practical/self-explanatory names for their products.

Well, it's corrected coffee, which matches their intention and general java/beans/jar theme. I kinda like it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caff%C3%A8_corretto

TIL you 'correct' coffee by adding alcohol.

Re: Corretto – No-cost, multiplatform, developer-preview distribution of OpenJDK

#93

"This initial release is a developer preview release for testing and validation purposes." Well... that's not really production-ready then, is it? I assume they intend to make it 'production-ready' at some point in the future, but those two statements are directly at odds.

Quite a number of software houses use pre-alpha-preview betas in production. I’m not sure what motivates them, my theory is that upgrading everything bi-weekly is great busywork for a startup with few users and little traction.

Re: Corretto – No-cost, multiplatform, developer-preview distribution of OpenJDK

#94
post #75
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So same as rhel openjdk ( https://access.redhat.com/articles/1299013 ) ?

> Are the binary plugs that Oracle did not release the source supported? Are the articles that Red Had publishes ever proof read?

> Red Had

:)

Re: Corretto – No-cost, multiplatform, developer-preview distribution of OpenJDK

#95
post #69
post #34

The list of specific patches applied is here: https://docs.aws.amazon.com/corretto/latest/corretto-8-ug/pa... Looks to be mostly or maybe entirely backports. Good to see another option out there, it will be interesting to see how many of these get folded back into openjdk8 as it transfers maintainership.

Amazon has good developers, but the JVM is quite complex and the pool of people who can work on it is pretty rare, I wonder how well they’ll be able to maintain it on their own.

Amazon has loads of money. Presumably if they care about this, they'll pay whatever's necessary to hire the developers they need.

Re: Corretto – No-cost, multiplatform, developer-preview distribution of OpenJDK

#96
post #57
post #26

Surely Amazon Corretto is just going to fracture the Java ecosystem?

You can get Open JDK from any of the following places on them intarweb tubes, and they don't seem to fracture the ecosystem. Linux is available from many places, it may seem fractured, yet Linux seems to be taking over the world. Even Microsoft now "loves" Linux. https://aws.amazon.com/fr/corretto/ https://github.com/corretto https://adoptopenjdk.net/ https://github.com/AdoptOpenJDK https://github.com/ojdkbuild/ojdkb…

Hopefully, OpenJDK would be less fractured than Linux. One thing to note, though, is that you can only call your JDK "OpenJDK" if it's a build of the OpenJDK project, with no substantial additions or removal of code[1]. Most free JDKs are, indeed, OpenJDK, with the exception of the JDK based on IBM's OpenJ9 JVM, even though it uses parts of the OpenJDK codebase.

[1]: http://openjdk.java.net/legal/openjdk-trademark-notice.html

Re: Corretto – No-cost, multiplatform, developer-preview distribution of OpenJDK

#97

We use OpenJDK 8 at Datastreamer as part of our social media and blog/news crawler. It's pretty solid for production use. We're REALLY production as we've been in business for a decade and burn a ton of CPU indexing web content. Think petabytes... :) The only time we use the Oracle JDK is to run their profiler which is pretty darn nice. It's runtime and sampling so you can get a nice sample in a production app by jus…

As of JDK 11, all commercial Oracle JDK features, including low-overhead profiler (Java Flight Recorder), are part of OpenJDK.[1]

[1]: https://blogs.oracle.com/java-platform-group/oracle-jdk-rele...

Re: Corretto – No-cost, multiplatform, developer-preview distribution of OpenJDK

#98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’m honestly surprised they didn’t go with “Simple Java Service”. /s Edit: Added sarcasm indicator

Probably because they don’t own the trademark on Java.

Within reason, you are actually allowed to use someone else's trademark for something like this provided your own trademark is the more prominent. So something like "Amazon Distribution for Java" would be fine.

Re: Corretto – No-cost, multiplatform, developer-preview distribution of OpenJDK

#99
post #15

> Amazon Corretto is a no-cost, multiplatform, production-ready distribution of the Open Java Development Kit I really, really wish AWS would start using practical/self-explanatory names for their products.

It's like they're trying to add an extra layer of stuff that must be learnt in order to use AWS. I have to wonder if it's intended to gear them toward being able to create AWS-specific exams & certifications.

Re: Corretto – No-cost, multiplatform, developer-preview distribution of OpenJDK

#100
post #56
post #49

This is about Amazon removing a revenue stream from Oracle. Amazon also announced a few days ago that they were removing Oracle products from AWS. Expect an article by Ben Thompson on stratechery.com in the next week.

To be fair I trust Amazon just about as much as I trust Oracle.

A long time ago I was looking into the cost of Oracle for a company and trying to compare it to Sql Server.

For SQL Server, you just go to the page and the price is right there.

For Oracle, you have to talk to a salesmen. That turned me off from Oracle.

With AWS, I know exactly how much a resource will cost and there are a myriad of ways you can get detailed billing.

Post reply on HN