Live data from Hacker News

Facebook Is Full of Emotional-Support Groups

theatlantic.com

11–20 of 83 posts

Re: Facebook Is Full of Emotional-Support Groups

#11

Anecdote, but it sure seems to me that the need for emotional support groups has skyrocketed within my lifetime. I’m sure all the members of these groups are legitimate (I’m not making a “snowflake” argument) but what in the hell is going on?

My guess is that not only is life is much more complex nowadays, but we are continually showered by polished profiles on Instagram et al showing lives that our own do not compare to. This creates feelings of inferiority and missing out, and eventually depression and other emotional problems. Add to that the general pattern towards a society of increasing inequality, and it's possible to see why in this hypercompetitive context so many people are struggling to maintain a baseline of self-esteem.

Re: Facebook Is Full of Emotional-Support Groups

#12

Anecdote, but it sure seems to me that the need for emotional support groups has skyrocketed within my lifetime. I’m sure all the members of these groups are legitimate (I’m not making a “snowflake” argument) but what in the hell is going on?

Has the need really skyrocketed though? Or has the use of them just become more normalized (and perhaps more convenient thanks to the internet), and less people feel the need to just "suck it up" and deal with their problems alone?

Re: Facebook Is Full of Emotional-Support Groups

#13

Anecdote, but it sure seems to me that the need for emotional support groups has skyrocketed within my lifetime. I’m sure all the members of these groups are legitimate (I’m not making a “snowflake” argument) but what in the hell is going on?

Maybe the need didn't skyrocket but the demand did. People used to not have channels to read about their problem, so they were isolated and not talking about it. Now it's easier to anonymously get informed, create support group, join them without much social stigma.

But maybe the need did skyrocket, I don't have data to support either or both hypothesis

Re: Facebook Is Full of Emotional-Support Groups

#15
If any Facebook employees are reading this, there's a really annoying "feature" that will show a list of suggested friends to add to a private group. I've accidentally added people to private groups by accidentally clicking a single time while scrolling.

Imagine being in an AA group or HIV support group and adding your coworker to it on accident.

Please change this.

Re: Facebook Is Full of Emotional-Support Groups

#16
I'd never seen beyond the login screen of Facebook until a site I run started getting sporadic bursts of traffic from there, so I ventured in to try and find the links. I was stunned and devastated to discover how many thriving little communities there were in this niche area (local archeology), it's everything the open web was supposed to be but it has been walled off, completely invisible to outsiders, all for the benefit of one corporation and its advertising customers.

Re: Facebook Is Full of Emotional-Support Groups

#17
I run a facebook breakup support group for men.

About half of the people that request to join the group discover the group themselves on facebook.

For me as a website owner (rapidbreakuprecovery.com) the group has been a convenient way to offer a forum-like functionality without any of the overhead involved with running forum software.

I suspect facebook users have come to expect that these types of groups exist and they're typing things such as "breakup" in the group search field.

There other breakup support groups that are routinely recommended in the sidebar as well as a support group specifically for divorced dads. So it seems that facebook's scale is allowing smaller niche communities to exist where they would not have existed before.

From a usability perspective it's not great. It's easy to set up and it's easy to get members, but I would happily switch to something more discrete, and that's a better fit for support group dynamics (interesting idea by sodosopa).

Re: Facebook Is Full of Emotional-Support Groups

#18
post #14

Facebook is one of the biggest sites in the world. You could replace 'emotional support' with anything and it'd be full of those groups.

Sure, but then what would "journalists" at theatlantic have to write about?

Journalism today is all about writing nonsense and throwing on Facebook, Google or Trump on the headline for views.

Re: Facebook Is Full of Emotional-Support Groups

#19
post #6

I joined a group for T2 diabetes at some point because I have a stubborn friend that doesn’t want to receive proper treatment and I basically wanted to ask about available options. Next thing I know is that Facebook started giving me ads for diabetics. Having such an influential company know about your illnesses and sell that to advertisers or healthcare insurance agencies or credit agencies or god knows what else is…

So I'm curious: have you tried removing details from your Facebook ad preferences?

On the desktop website go to: Settings | Ads | Your Interests. There is a huge ontology of various subjects that have been algorithmically assigned to you. If you remove these, I believe ads targeted to those interests should go away. I periodically just sweep them all clean so I have no interests. I get very few ads and those that I go get are completely generic. I never see anything that would seem creepily aware of who I am.

Re: Facebook Is Full of Emotional-Support Groups

#20
post #6

I joined a group for T2 diabetes at some point because I have a stubborn friend that doesn’t want to receive proper treatment and I basically wanted to ask about available options. Next thing I know is that Facebook started giving me ads for diabetics. Having such an influential company know about your illnesses and sell that to advertisers or healthcare insurance agencies or credit agencies or god knows what else is…

That is absolutely terrifying. As far as I know, FB does not allow you to target users by the group they join. (pages targeting is allowed).

Which means it is likely that the Facebook algorithm is doing that without even prompted by the advertiser.

Did you visit a lot of links related to T2 diabetes? Another possibility is that the Facebook pixel could have helped the website target you again.

Post reply on HN