Live data from Hacker News

The cost of keeping Singapore squeaky clean

bbc.com

1–10 of 138 posts

Re: The cost of keeping Singapore squeaky clean

#4
The area of Singapore is 278 sq miles, approximately the size of 17 miles square. Whatever policies that work in such small high density places won't work in larger countries. However, one can try to decentralize as much as possible; such decentralization may not work in large countries either.

Re: The cost of keeping Singapore squeaky clean

#6
I am right now in Singapore for a visit and personally I don't have the feeling of a very clean city. There are some things that drive me crazy as a european. I went to a hawker with some Singaporeans and we got new disposable chopsticks for every dish. Wich means I ended up with three pairs of chopsticks. All plates were disposable. Either of plastic or styrofoam. Like in the article we didn't clean our trays, a cleaner took them the second we finished eating. I asked the Singaporeans how they feel about all the plastic and they just replied that's just how it is. Especially, that you get a plastic bag for every two items in the supermarket drives me nuts. Even when I am holding a backpack directly in front of the cashier he starts packing the items faster in a plastic bag than I can say anything. They even have watered sponges for their finger tips so they can be quicker with the plastic bags.

Needless to say, that all the trash ends up somewhere. Maybe not so much in percentage, but you will definitely find litter every few meters. The difference to my hometown in Germany is, that the litter there stays for years but also not so much new litter per day is produced. Maybe the Singaporeans should place more public trash bins or get some moop bags.

Re: The cost of keeping Singapore squeaky clean

#7
post #5
post #3

What you should wonder is if this model is desirable in any term.

From what I have heard from people living there most people seem OK with it.

But...but freedom.

It's aggravating to see how many Americans think individual freedom should absolutely and automatically trump every other concern.

Re: The cost of keeping Singapore squeaky clean

#8
What I found really interesting when I there earlier this year was that the ethnic Chinese complained quite a bit about the strict laws, but the ethnic British or Malaysian didn't seem to be bothered by the plethora of laws, the didn't really seem to interfere with their daily life

Re: The cost of keeping Singapore squeaky clean

#9
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From what I have heard from people living there most people seem OK with it.

But...but freedom. It's aggravating to see how many Americans think individual freedom should absolutely and automatically trump every other concern.

It's aggravating to see how many people regardless of nationality would willingly trade away their freedom for some temporary gain and encourage others to do likewise. The next government can lay off all the litter picker-uppers but you won't get your freedom back in return.

Re: The cost of keeping Singapore squeaky clean

#10
post #5
post #3

What you should wonder is if this model is desirable in any term.

From what I have heard from people living there most people seem OK with it.

All over the world there are testosterone poisoned males engaging in as much obnoxious behavior as they can get away with (e.g. riding motorcycles with no mufflers). Particulary coming from the Southern US it is absolutely delightful to be in a place where "rednecks" are completley suppressed.
Post reply on HN