Live data from Hacker News

Tell recruiters politely “no” with a simple link

no-thank-you.de

31–40 of 53 posts

Re: Tell recruiters politely “no” with a simple link

#31
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's really shocking is that I've never once had an acceptable experience with a recruiter that has reached out to me. I've taken over 40 interviews this year in a variety of fields. I've had a much better experience and indeed received offers when applying to an ad or application posted on Indeed, Linkedin, Angel.co or the company website.

What is the general bad experience that you have? I've engaged with one recruiter that made a good first impression, it took a bit of convincing to have him find me jobs with a suitable market rate (they probably like lower salaries because it increases their chance of success and this payout) but then he actually offered me a couple jobs that I think I would have had a hard time finding myself. I never acted on any…

This goes for internal and external recruiters, in my opinion:

The phone screen always goes just peachy. "Wow, this is great. Awesome experience. You sound great on the phone. We would love to have you come in."

Then you either get rejected after the first round, ghosted after the third round, or shockingly they give you an offer and then after the first month "it isn't working out".

Interviewers are either way too candy-coated or way too curt.

Maybe this is just my experience, but I have over 8 years of legitimate professional experience in this industry and have been employed at megacorps and 20 person companies alike.

I got so sick of the charade that I currently work for an oil company!! Go figure.

Re: Tell recruiters politely “no” with a simple link

#32

I wish LinkedIn would let recruiters realize that I'm only willing to work within specified geographical areas. Probably 80% of my LinkedIn recruiter spam is for jobs that require moving to SV or NYC. It's a waste of everybody's time. Even better would be a mechanism that cost recruiters actual $$$ for spamming people whose profiles clearly indicate they're unsuited for the job or unwilling to relocate to the job's l…

But u can actually right ?

Re: Tell recruiters politely “no” with a simple link

#33
I wouldn't find recruiters so annoying if they at least took 15 minutes to figure out who I was and what I'm interested in.

I have only once—once!—received a cold-call (well, email) from a recruiter that was in any way relevant to me as a person and a professional. And I still didn't want it. That's a pretty shitty track record.

Re: Tell recruiters politely “no” with a simple link

#34

I wish LinkedIn would let recruiters realize that I'm only willing to work within specified geographical areas. Probably 80% of my LinkedIn recruiter spam is for jobs that require moving to SV or NYC. It's a waste of everybody's time. Even better would be a mechanism that cost recruiters actual $$$ for spamming people whose profiles clearly indicate they're unsuited for the job or unwilling to relocate to the job's l…

Not sure if that's still the case but LinkedIn used to have a service called the Inmail Response Guarantee [1]. The simplest way to ensure the recruiter does cost money is to respond to your inmail.

[1]: https://business.linkedin.com/talent-solutions/blog/2009/09/...

Re: Tell recruiters politely “no” with a simple link

#35

Recruiters can be annoying, but they're also just doing their jobs. I think it would be better if you collected some templates for politely copy & paste point out why you're not interested on the website. If people don't back off, you can still send something that's worded more strongly.

“Just doing their job” is never an excuse.

The recruiters that annoy me are the ones who blatantly send me copy and pasted messages while clearly just having done a keyword search (and certainly not reading the parts about what I’m not interested in), who go quiet as soon as I ask for specific information (or make it clear that I expect a sufficiently large benefits package over what I have to make it worth my while), who don’t pay attention to my location but require me to work on site. Basically the ones who are wasting my time and are rude to me. Those people can go f themselves.

I have had a few, rare, great interactions with recruiters who seemed to genuinely care about placing good candidates in good companies in positions that the candidate is well suited to. Unfortunately for every one of those I’ve interacted with, I get 50 messages from the ”hey I have a lowish paying role doing something you specifically said you didn’t want to do” recruiters.

Re: Tell recruiters politely “no” with a simple link

#36
post #33

I wouldn't find recruiters so annoying if they at least took 15 minutes to figure out who I was and what I'm interested in. I have only once—once!—received a cold-call (well, email) from a recruiter that was in any way relevant to me as a person and a professional. And I still didn't want it. That's a pretty shitty track record.

Think of their track record - they call 100 people, get one that is a match to their opening. Statistically we should expect only 1 in 100 recruiter calls to be useful. It makes sense.

Re: Tell recruiters politely “no” with a simple link

#37
Much like many posters here, I have some preset responses that I send to recruiters. In particular, it’s a “I’m not looking right now, but I’ll save your info and let you know if my situation changes!”. This worked really well when my startup fell apart, and I was able to “scramble the jets” and get interviews set up within a week at a ton of companies. I think that the author confused “polite” with “passive aggressive” (or maybe it’s a cultural difference between my country and Germany).

I always try to leave recruiters with a positive impression, so as to not burn future bridges.

...except Herman Search. Every single recruiter has approached me flashing large salary numbers for boring, stressful sounding financial tech jobs, and being pushy/downright aggressive when I don’t show interest. I’ve asked every recruiter to put me on their do not contact list, but still, every couple of months, I get another generic male white frat bro recruiter, new to the company, reaching out again with the exact same tact. It toes the line between unprofessional and confrontational. With all due respect, which is none, fuck Herman Search.

Re: Tell recruiters politely “no” with a simple link

#40
post #11
post #5

Since the GDPR came in, the amount of recruitment spam has dropped dramatically for me

I respond to any recruitment spam with a GDPR request for all of the data they have on me, and a request to delete it after they've sent it. This has worked very well so far.

Do you know where I can find guidelines or a template on writing a GDPR request or do you (almost) literally just say hey please send me all the data you have, GDPR requires you do so if I ask and I’m asking thanks? (I’m in the EU)
Post reply on HN