Live data from Hacker News

Bing Is Suggesting the Worst Things You Can Imagine

howtogeek.com

21–30 of 65 posts

Re: Bing Is Suggesting the Worst Things You Can Imagine

#21
Now who has a search engine, which is policed and censored by the chinese government- and doesnt want to stick out as a lawfull evil person here?

Surely such a actor wouldnt shill this article to encite public outrage, and demands to take actions that already have been taken. And are under debate, because a wildly debating competitor appears in the chinese market.

Re: Bing Is Suggesting the Worst Things You Can Imagine

#22

At least searching "muslims are" in Bing gives you honest autocompletes that reflect what people actually search for. Google, on the other hand, evidently censors content it deems to be offensive. If you search "muslims are" in Google, there are no autocomplete results at all. I doubt Google does not have enough data on "muslims are *" searches I have safe search off, meaning I don't want to be patronized when I am s…

Some things should not be autocompleted. I can't think of a reason why a search engine should suggest a completion if you start typing something generic like "xyz are ...".

Searching "muslims are vegetarian" could be seen as another way to search "are muslims vegetarian". A good search engine lets you search query soup like this. They don't necessarily return the same results, but people are pretty bad at querying.

Re: Bing Is Suggesting the Worst Things You Can Imagine

#23

At least searching "muslims are" in Bing gives you honest autocompletes that reflect what people actually search for. Google, on the other hand, evidently censors content it deems to be offensive. If you search "muslims are" in Google, there are no autocomplete results at all. I doubt Google does not have enough data on "muslims are *" searches I have safe search off, meaning I don't want to be patronized when I am s…

    > I don't want to be patronized when I am searching things.
It's more like they're removing the penis graffiti.

Most of the time, I search to find some content. You are probably the same. It's a search engine. Considerations aside from whether a search suggestion helps one locate desired content are beside the point. What's more, in some of the author's cases, the content would be illegal.

If you are serious about researching search trends, then you could use tools, or lobby for more tools, like https://trends.google.com

Re: Bing Is Suggesting the Worst Things You Can Imagine

#25

Not the main point of the article, so off topic, but isn’t “underage children” a pleonasm? Or is it a term that respects that we are all someone’s child, so also when we reach adulthood? The term seems to suggest there is an age from which it is acceptable for children to receive sexual attention from adults. I prefer to think that there is no such age. Most people would probably agree with this. Pleonasms are very c…

> Most people would probably agree with this.

I think you might be overestimating how common your opinion is. In many (maybe most) countries, children are considered capable of consent even before they are granted all privileges of adulthood. Sometimes it's only if the partner is underage as well, but then one will be an adult sooner than the other, so there are exceptions for cases where the age difference is small.

Because of the various exceptions in traditional consent law in contrast to bright-line rules against child pornography (below 18 is illegal, no exceptions), it's possible for legal sex to become illegal as soon as there's a camera between the participants.

The best-known cases are probably of teens being prosecuted for child pornography when they take nude selfies.

Re: Bing Is Suggesting the Worst Things You Can Imagine

#26

Personally I find that brutal honesty about its search suggestions refreshing as opposed to manually excluding anything remotely controversial. Although the reality is probably that somebody is spoofing the search suggestions for laughs above and beyond morbid curiosity and jokes of debatable taste akin to searching for nuclear warheads on eBay.

The issue is that once these thoughts and articles are suggested, they become much more mainstream. Try something less controversial, robbery. No doubt, people search for "how to break into houses", and you might even click on that link if it was a top suggestion. But if people saw that all the time, there would be an increase in robberies, and a decrease in the feeling that it matters. And just because it generates…

> Once it is a suggestion (even at the end of the list) it will get clicks, and move up till it dominates.

So why isn't every article that has ever been suggested moving up until it dominates?

Re: Bing Is Suggesting the Worst Things You Can Imagine

#27
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Did you read further along? There's also suggestions for bestiality and borderline child pornography, both of which definitely fall under adult images and in one or both cases are very illegal.

You said borderline, because it is not past the line of illegality. Thus your second sentence makes no sense.

Borderline but legal child pornography would still be classified as "adult", no? To me, the second sentence makes perfect sense.

Re: Bing Is Suggesting the Worst Things You Can Imagine

#28

Not the main point of the article, so off topic, but isn’t “underage children” a pleonasm? Or is it a term that respects that we are all someone’s child, so also when we reach adulthood? The term seems to suggest there is an age from which it is acceptable for children to receive sexual attention from adults. I prefer to think that there is no such age. Most people would probably agree with this. Pleonasms are very c…

Well, you can have shared belongings, as with things you own with your family members (usually spouse). So my personal belongings is a valid distinction, not a pleonasm.

Re: Bing Is Suggesting the Worst Things You Can Imagine

#30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some things should not be autocompleted. I can't think of a reason why a search engine should suggest a completion if you start typing something generic like "xyz are ...".

Searching "muslims are vegetarian" could be seen as another way to search "are muslims vegetarian". A good search engine lets you search query soup like this. They don't necessarily return the same results, but people are pretty bad at querying.

Yeah, there's nothing wrong with a query like that, and I think autocomplete is fine once you typed "muslims are vege...".

But I don't see why you'd autocomplete a sentence that could go anywhere. Just because many people type that isn't a good reason.

Post reply on HN