Live data from Hacker News

Pirate Party Leader to Be Prague mayor

praguemonitor.com

81–90 of 106 posts

Re: Pirate Party Leader to Be Prague mayor

#81
post #19
post #2

Any Czech person around to chim in and shed some light on the implications?

There's a joke going on that the Pirate Party is the IT department of the communist party. In general the trouble with Pirates is unpredictability. They are very socially liberal, but economically and geopolitically they attract a wide mix of opinions. The have a higher incidence of conspiration theorist, they have a strong anti-US base, and in general they avoid to address these topics since it cannot pass the inter…

> There's a joke going on that the Pirate Party is the IT department of the communist party.

Yes, because in Eastern Europe, if you're even slightly left, or don't agree with U.S. on everything, you must be a communist.

Apparently from one block to the other.

As someone from that part of the world, I generally find it annoying that people automatically assume left == communist because of the Soviet past. As a result, we mostly have only right-wing or neoliberal type parties in Eastern Europe, because if you propose any sort of social democracy, you'd end up being attached to communism.

I view it as very unfortunate and simplistic. As in, communism didn't work out, let's run waaay to the right. Oh, right is bad? Let's run even further to the right, that outta fix it!

(Failing to realize that what you really dislike is authoritarianism, which these all share.)

How about a social democracy? The Scandinavian model? Market economy with strong social programs.

So you could start a business without being absolutely mortified about what'd happen if it fails, for example? How else is the overall standard of living supposed to improve over there? Corporate tax cuts and trickle-down economics has been tried, it doesn't work.

Re: Pirate Party Leader to Be Prague mayor

#82
post #49

How is life in Prague for English-only speakers who want to relocate for a few months? The city itself is so beautiful.

Prague and Brno would be the two options I'd consider seriously. Prague definitely has a larger English-speaking population, but Brno is not far behind and is generally cheaper. Prague is exceptionally beautiful, however, and so if you are only going for a few months it might be worth the cost (although travel from Brno to Prague is not terrible on the freeway).

It's worth learning as much Czech as you are able to, but you would be fine managing on your own for a few months, especially if you can befriend a local who can help you get on your feet when you arrive (tips on currency conversion, places to eat, places to avoid, setting up a transit pass, etc.)

Life in Prague if you're coming to visit is quite great. I love every minute of the almost two years I was able to spend there and around the Czech and Slovak republics.

Re: Pirate Party Leader to Be Prague mayor

#83
post #56
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

At least they have a proper left.... We could use a lot more of this in the US.

Only an American leftist could look at the chaos and nonsense that is a former soviet republic and say "how can we replicate that misery in the US?"

Czech Republic was never part of the USSR. Warsaw pact, yes. Heavily influenced (and invaded 50 years ago) by the USSR, yes. But you'll look a bit clueless if you say it was in the USSR, and people won't take your opinion seriously.

Re: Pirate Party Leader to Be Prague mayor

#84

Who are the partners in his coalition ? Left ? Moderate or radicals ? Greens ? Others ?

Basically anyone because the point here is to get ANO out of the government. No radicals though. They're moderate left, but they cooperate with parties on the right as well. Greens in the Czech Republic are radical communists.

I wouldn't call them moderate left. They have quite few right wing policies in their program - lowering taxes, flat tax rate, keeping deficit low, removing bureaucracy.

They would be appealing to people who are right wing economically, but don't like the conservative/religious baggage, which comes with US republicans or UK's conservatives.

Re: Pirate Party Leader to Be Prague mayor

#85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Basically anyone because the point here is to get ANO out of the government. No radicals though. They're moderate left, but they cooperate with parties on the right as well. Greens in the Czech Republic are radical communists.

I wouldn't call them moderate left. They have quite few right wing policies in their program - lowering taxes, flat tax rate, keeping deficit low, removing bureaucracy. They would be appealing to people who are right wing economically, but don't like the conservative/religious baggage, which comes with US republicans or UK's conservatives.

Yes but at the same time they're proposing more government control on issues like Airbnb, Uber, etc. Regardless of whether I or you think it's good or bad, it's leftist.

Low taxes are not necessarily rightist, people would want low and fair taxes even within a full-on socialism; same with everything else you listed, IMO these ideas are neutral. Keeping deficit low is just basic financial management, everyone wants that regardless of their ideas about control.

The difference is whether they want more free market or more government control, even if the control is very cheap, straight forward and efficient or even beneficial, it doesn't matter.

The Chinese communist party also lowered taxes and tries to lower bureaucracy but remains communist (I know, it's much more complex - let's not dive into Chinese politics - and I'm not trying to compare them, just an example how a popularly "rightist" idea can be proposed/implemented by a leftist party).

But yes, as you said they're appealing to people on the right - because as someone who's pro-free market it's better to vote moderate left (and hope they won't focus on the ideas you don't like) than conservative right (who will definitely focus on ideas you don't like these ideas are their main point).

Re: Pirate Party Leader to Be Prague mayor

#86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Prague is a beautiful city and they were generally friendly to me and didn't mind speaking English. Some don't and sign language helped when I traveled. But they knew I was a tourist (I was a brown Indian guy who is not exactly the type there ;)). One thing I found surprising for being an European city is how hard it is to find any kind of food past 9 PM. Maybe I picked a neighborhood like that to stay? Also, stores…

Travelling there next week, anything you would recommend?

Check out this YT channel, the most awesome Czech travel guide (videos in English): https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCt7oj318jVQi7vRbc1bNjJA

Re: Pirate Party Leader to Be Prague mayor

#87
post #4
post #2

Any Czech person around to chim in and shed some light on the implications?

Yes, I'm Czech living in Prague. Last 4 years the Prague local government was led by ANO, the party led by StB (communist secret police) member billionaire Andrej Babis. Their campaign was extremely strong then and they won - today Prague is in horrendous state, bridges are literally falling down (2 more just this week), traffic is worse (extremely worse!) than ever due to idiotically planned long roadworks that have…

> If you don't want to vote ANO then you vote ODS if you're more on the right (as in free market) and the Pirate party if you're more on the left.

Can you explain more what the platform of the "Pirate" party is? As an American I would have thought the the "Pirate" party would be far right libertarian (free market, downsize government, reduce or eliminate taxes).

Re: Pirate Party Leader to Be Prague mayor

#88
post #49

How is life in Prague for English-only speakers who want to relocate for a few months? The city itself is so beautiful.

Prague and Brno would be the two options I'd consider seriously. Prague definitely has a larger English-speaking population, but Brno is not far behind and is generally cheaper. Prague is exceptionally beautiful, however, and so if you are only going for a few months it might be worth the cost (although travel from Brno to Prague is not terrible on the freeway). It's worth learning as much Czech as you are able to, b…

Thanks everyone for the feedback here.

Staying close to the airport is probably the top priority ;)

Is Prague safe for a quiet+european+foreign+laptop-carrying male? Or should i stick to the tourist areas?

Re: Pirate Party Leader to Be Prague mayor

#89
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, I'm Czech living in Prague. Last 4 years the Prague local government was led by ANO, the party led by StB (communist secret police) member billionaire Andrej Babis. Their campaign was extremely strong then and they won - today Prague is in horrendous state, bridges are literally falling down (2 more just this week), traffic is worse (extremely worse!) than ever due to idiotically planned long roadworks that have…

> If you don't want to vote ANO then you vote ODS if you're more on the right (as in free market) and the Pirate party if you're more on the left. Can you explain more what the platform of the "Pirate" party is? As an American I would have thought the the "Pirate" party would be far right libertarian (free market, downsize government, reduce or eliminate taxes).

In the Czech Republic they're center to left, definitely not free market/libertarian. They propose government control of many issues like for example shared economy or housing, banking etc.

At the same time yes, they propose to downsize the government and tax reduction, but not elimination. They also propose digitalization of government and reduction of bureaucracy, but they also want that as a base to build more control on.

Many specifics of the Czech Republic are at play here, since the party is no longer a minor one and at the same time is the only major "non traditional" one (no historical baggage including people - actually that's very important) that isn't Babiš (ANO, but everyone knows the party is him, basically - including people in the party who went public), it attracts the interest of many very different people ranging from left wing radicals to free market anarchists; people who weren't as "radical" (they're not radical at all but definitely more than other parties) rather joined ODS (right, major party), ČSSD (left, almost irrelevant) or TOP09 (center, now totally irrelevant).

Then the free market anarchists created their own party (Svobodní - "The Free Ones", never even became relevant except a very tiny little bit of relevance in the EU parliament) and the result is that Pirate party is more leftist. Sadly soon after conservatives have "attacked" (joined and changed the program) the party and made it conservative, and a lot of previously pro-free market people became conservative because of the immigration crisis and rapidly increasing EU influence that nobody here really likes, left or right (these same issues also gave rise to the fourth biggest party SPD, which is an openly racist pro-russian one, luckily they're largely irrelevant except for municipal politics in few places).

Re: Pirate Party Leader to Be Prague mayor

#90
post #49

How is life in Prague for English-only speakers who want to relocate for a few months? The city itself is so beautiful.

There is a huge expat community, almost everyone speaks English and IT jobs are open to everyone and will help you with visa and sometimes even relocation. I worked in a company with hundreds of foreigners, they all like it here.

Which neighborhoods can u recommend? Preferably walk-able with cafes etc and some expats..
Post reply on HN