Live data from Hacker News

The Era of the Drone Swarm Is Coming

mwi.usma.edu

21–30 of 51 posts

Re: The Era of the Drone Swarm Is Coming

#21

Not mentioned in the article in the context of hardening is the use of electromagnetic pulse weapons as the basis for anti-drone swarm countermeasures. You don't need to jam their comms or disrupt their nav or hit them with shotgun pellets if you can glitch the unhardened control circuitry of their little motors.

Directional, reusable electromagnetic pulse weapons are still science fiction. Producing any significant EMP today requires a large explosion.

Re: The Era of the Drone Swarm Is Coming

#22
post #2

I would encourage countries like China or Russia to develop cheap mass drone swarm systems that can deny access to airspace to any adversary. A country could sell this sort of service for hundreds of billions of dollars to another country like an insurance policy. Entire wars could be made impossible. It would be great progress for the world.

There is a long history of people claiming that new weapons would make war impossible, going back to the crossbow. So far the predictions have been wrong.

Re: The Era of the Drone Swarm Is Coming

#23
post #13

I'm surprised there's no mention of the short film "Slaughterbots" on this exact topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HipTO_7mUOw&vl=en It's very well done and has an HN vibe to it (with a dark twist, of course).

No need to panic. Just because the video has high production values doesn't mean it's an accurate prediction of the future, or that effective countermeasures won't be found.

Re: The Era of the Drone Swarm Is Coming

#25
post #21

Not mentioned in the article in the context of hardening is the use of electromagnetic pulse weapons as the basis for anti-drone swarm countermeasures. You don't need to jam their comms or disrupt their nav or hit them with shotgun pellets if you can glitch the unhardened control circuitry of their little motors.

Directional, reusable electromagnetic pulse weapons are still science fiction. Producing any significant EMP today requires a large explosion.

An EMP wirelessly overvolts circuits, burning them like a blown fuse. What kind of magnetic field would it take to induce too much current inside an Arduino?

Re: The Era of the Drone Swarm Is Coming

#27
post #23
post #13

I'm surprised there's no mention of the short film "Slaughterbots" on this exact topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HipTO_7mUOw&vl=en It's very well done and has an HN vibe to it (with a dark twist, of course).

No need to panic. Just because the video has high production values doesn't mean it's an accurate prediction of the future, or that effective countermeasures won't be found.

I’m gonna have to say I disagree. We are already making tiny drones the size of bees. And you don’t need that size to make a reliable, one shot bomb to kill someone.

Anyone with time, a bit of money, and a plan can make a swarm of drones to fly into a crowd automatically and blow themselves up remotely.

The fact that I hasn’t happened already just surprises me.

Re: The Era of the Drone Swarm Is Coming

#28
post #9

I’ve brought up this eventuality countless times in the past couple of years (including recently mentioning this in my software company). I don’t think people are realizing the dangers to minitrization and ease of manufacturing small drones that could kill people. Either through mini bombs, or carrying diseases. What are we doing about it? Seems like we aren’t doing anything

Some people are doing things. There's an outfit at DIU (Defense Innovation Unit) called Rogue Squadron who's job it is to conduct counter-UAS research.

I’ll check it out. I’m still trying to find a way we can protect ourselves though. The best I can come up with is (at home) a droppable net that covers your windows that has a current running through it. Maybe something similar for a personal device.

Beyond that, hacking into their WiFi or navigation signals. But how do you do that?

Re: The Era of the Drone Swarm Is Coming

#29
post #23
post #13

I'm surprised there's no mention of the short film "Slaughterbots" on this exact topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HipTO_7mUOw&vl=en It's very well done and has an HN vibe to it (with a dark twist, of course).

No need to panic. Just because the video has high production values doesn't mean it's an accurate prediction of the future, or that effective countermeasures won't be found.

We've never really found an effective countermeasure to bullets apart from avoiding people who want to shoot us.

If someone develops what is essentially a bullet with 365-degree acceleration, I doubt there is going to be a better strategy than hoping that one is never fired at us.

Re: The Era of the Drone Swarm Is Coming

#30
post #29
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No need to panic. Just because the video has high production values doesn't mean it's an accurate prediction of the future, or that effective countermeasures won't be found.

We've never really found an effective countermeasure to bullets apart from avoiding people who want to shoot us. If someone develops what is essentially a bullet with 365-degree acceleration, I doubt there is going to be a better strategy than hoping that one is never fired at us.

Modern US military body armor is actually quite an effective countermeasure against most bullets. Check the casualty statistics from recent conflicts.
Post reply on HN