Live data from Hacker News

Holla - An open source Campfire

alexmaccaw.co.uk

41–50 of 61 posts

Re: Holla - An open source Campfire

#41

I must be an old curmudgeon because whenever I see Campfire I think "it's like IRC but with a better client" and wonder what the big deal is. Sure, it's in a browser but is it really that big a deal? I just can't seem to get properly excited about Campfire and it's ilk.

Indeed. One of the things that makes me laugh as well is that 37signals themselves use Propane - which is an OS X app which gives campfire a more desktop-like experience.

IRC is still great

Re: Holla - An open source Campfire

#42

The only thing I dislike about Campfire is that it doesn't support some other protocol, like XMPP or IRC, so that I can use it in a normal chat client, with normal chat client features, like desktop notifications. This one doesn't seem to, either.

If you use OS X, try http://propaneapp.com/

Re: Holla - An open source Campfire

#44

I must be an old curmudgeon because whenever I see Campfire I think "it's like IRC but with a better client" and wonder what the big deal is. Sure, it's in a browser but is it really that big a deal? I just can't seem to get properly excited about Campfire and it's ilk.

That it's not typically blocked by crappy Internet firewalls/filters is a big bonus. This is a big deal for me since plenty of the places I consult at tend to be a little overzealous in the "security" department.

Re: Holla - An open source Campfire

#45

I must be an old curmudgeon because whenever I see Campfire I think "it's like IRC but with a better client" and wonder what the big deal is. Sure, it's in a browser but is it really that big a deal? I just can't seem to get properly excited about Campfire and it's ilk.

The ability to have context on room join is the deal maker where I work. IRC doesn't work that way.

Re: Holla - An open source Campfire

#46
post #42

The only thing I dislike about Campfire is that it doesn't support some other protocol, like XMPP or IRC, so that I can use it in a normal chat client, with normal chat client features, like desktop notifications. This one doesn't seem to, either.

If you use OS X, try http://propaneapp.com/

Propane doesn't support IRC/XMPP/any other group chat protocol.

Re: Holla - An open source Campfire

#47

The only thing I dislike about Campfire is that it doesn't support some other protocol, like XMPP or IRC, so that I can use it in a normal chat client, with normal chat client features, like desktop notifications. This one doesn't seem to, either.

Try Mibbit. It also does desktop notifications now (In Chrome).

Re: Holla - An open source Campfire

#48
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It was a freaking chat room!

It was a note for note cover of the 37Signals UI that was clearly designed to evoke Campfire, done by Google. What's the web chat room designed prior to Campfire that looks virtually identical to Campfire?

Every chatroom looks the same. It's like moaning that email clients steal UI from each other. Of course they do.

Re: Holla - An open source Campfire

#49
post #42

The only thing I dislike about Campfire is that it doesn't support some other protocol, like XMPP or IRC, so that I can use it in a normal chat client, with normal chat client features, like desktop notifications. This one doesn't seem to, either.

If you use OS X, try http://propaneapp.com/

I did, when I was on OSX... but now I've switched back to Linux, and kinda miss it. It would be great if I could just connect to Campfire with Pidgin, or any libpurple chat client.

Re: Holla - An open source Campfire

#50
post #14

great product! I love it. We currently use Jaconda.im at my office. Holla seems as good ! Only one little bug in the demo, when I click on "XMPP/Jabber" I'm redirect to http://getholla.com/$%7BgetXMPP%28%29%7D with an error (The page you were looking for doesn't exist)

Ah yes, I'm planning on adding xmpp support soon - it shouldn't have been exposed on getholla (it's stripped out of the Github version)

Please do. I'm being willing to pay for such an app with XMPP support.

Have tried Campfire, Ignite/sparkweb, all the versions of jabber I can find, and various IRC servers. So far I have not found a single one that I can successfully install on a RHEL server that will do both a web interface and an XMPP/Jabber backend so that my team can communicate effectively.

Post reply on HN