Live data from Hacker News

Even After Fix, Windows 10 Update Is Botching File Operations

gizmodo.com.au

151–159 of 159 posts

Re: Even After Fix, Windows 10 Update Is Botching File Operations

#151
post #48

This article is super deceptive, these two bugs are completely unrelated, and the one still standing is pretty obscure: 1. You're extracting a Zip file and intend to overwrite your own data 2. The data isn't overwritten, but it doesn't tell you about it 3. You delete the Zip file, thinking that it's extracted. I'm not discounting that this is a Bug, but I can't think of a time I would've ever lost data because of thi…

You’ve never edited a file and rezipped it? I did that a lot in the nand2tetris course, where you upload zips. This would be a nasty surprise when the other party carries on as if you send the old while you think you sent the new. Probably would have been testing my hear out on the course. And I don’t get your attitude. The data is still gone. The fact that it’s unrelated to the original bug isn’t any kind of comfort…

Aha, this explains it:

>Developer tools at Facebook

Re: Even After Fix, Windows 10 Update Is Botching File Operations

#152
post #5

Microsoft has turned Windows Update into a cancer that is the single reason I am going to abandon their platform in future machine purchases. Can't believe I'm longing for the days of Vista (well post-SP1).

What are you switching to in the future for desktop/laptop?

Sorry late reply, I'd have to do more research but if my machine pooped the bed today probably Linux Mint. Maybe wait for Apple's rumored Mac Mini Pro announcement next week to see if it's not the worst?

Re: Even After Fix, Windows 10 Update Is Botching File Operations

#153

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think that iMac would last for 12 years. I would save that money for Mac Pro which they promised to be good.

Well I don't have the money now so I am sitting and waiting anyway. :D I will keep watching and observing. Last I read, the latest Mac Pro is noisier than the iMac Pro which you have to fully load all its CPU cores and both videocards to even hear . To me the [lack of] noise is extremely important in a machine. (That's why I spent $400 on a PC box, CPU cooler and the most silent fans I could find, last year.) That, p…

They are building new Mac Pro from the scratch, don't look at latest one, it's considered a failure (overheating GPUs, etc). But well, if you just want monoblock, then iMac Pro is no brainer, of course. I have opposite view and prefer modular components, especially for long-lasting hardware.

Re: Even After Fix, Windows 10 Update Is Botching File Operations

#154

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well I don't have the money now so I am sitting and waiting anyway. :D I will keep watching and observing. Last I read, the latest Mac Pro is noisier than the iMac Pro which you have to fully load all its CPU cores and both videocards to even hear . To me the [lack of] noise is extremely important in a machine. (That's why I spent $400 on a PC box, CPU cooler and the most silent fans I could find, last year.) That, p…

They are building new Mac Pro from the scratch, don't look at latest one, it's considered a failure (overheating GPUs, etc). But well, if you just want monoblock, then iMac Pro is no brainer, of course. I have opposite view and prefer modular components, especially for long-lasting hardware.

If we're talking PCs then I fully agree. Modular beats monoblock all-around.

Apple has a terrible track record on repairs in warranty however (it's basically a 50/50, lot of luck involved). Whatever I end up buying I'll just pray it doesn't break. So modular or not, doesn't make much of a difference. If anything breaks you're likely screwed. That's why I'm most likely buying an iMac Pro.

But since that ain't happening yet, I'll be curiously following what other machines will they come up with in the meantime.

Re: Even After Fix, Windows 10 Update Is Botching File Operations

#155
post #90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe you can make computers easier to use by providing abstracted, context-dependent views of the data instead. Mobile phones rely on that prerty successfully. But they also do not merge these views with the single file manager the system has. Therein lies the true madness of the Windows Explorer in my oppinion. If you want to have a view for the barely computer literate average user, (ab-)use the myriad predefined…

Mobile iOS don't abstract complexity; they don't have complexity. Mobile apps are just silo's that can barely communicate with each other. Nobody working on a PC wants that. You cannot simultaneously give people the power to work on files between multiple apps, organize them how they want, and make it as dumb as iOS. You want to zip up your photos and email them to your boss? Good luck getting your photo gallery to d…

How many smartphone users do even know what a zip file is? I'm fairly certain that at least 70% don't and that is an optimistic estimate. Even more, I think that almost every advanced use case relies on some deeper than average knowledge that the user must have about how some particular technological thing works. This means that at least 70% or 80% of users likely won't even understand what that use case is even about.

Re: Even After Fix, Windows 10 Update Is Botching File Operations

#156
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Never happened to me with Windows. It's not the best, but works. Linux on the over hand it's a continuous installation of drivers and fixing functionality that works out of the box on my windows: graphics problems, audio, screen, usb, WiFi. Of course and then you try to install some module and says you have incompatible modules. Then you need to figure out what modules you need to change to match the version of the m…

I don't know, what exactly you are doing with your Linux installation, but you are doing it wrong. Try installing something released in last 20 years or so.

Just let version of Ubuntu and follow all the steps there. Just standard

Re: Even After Fix, Windows 10 Update Is Botching File Operations

#157
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Never happened to me with Windows. It's not the best, but works. Linux on the over hand it's a continuous installation of drivers and fixing functionality that works out of the box on my windows: graphics problems, audio, screen, usb, WiFi. Of course and then you try to install some module and says you have incompatible modules. Then you need to figure out what modules you need to change to match the version of the m…

You don't appreciate the difference between knowing what's happening to your system well enough to fix it and hoping that an "update" doesn't cause too much unrecoverable damage when it installs itself behind your back.

I just need to do some work, not fixing the os

Re: Even After Fix, Windows 10 Update Is Botching File Operations

#158
post #109
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Never happened to me with Windows. It's not the best, but works. Linux on the over hand it's a continuous installation of drivers and fixing functionality that works out of the box on my windows: graphics problems, audio, screen, usb, WiFi. Of course and then you try to install some module and says you have incompatible modules. Then you need to figure out what modules you need to change to match the version of the m…

Working out of the box is nice, but what's magically fixed can be magically broken just as easily. Traditional Linux was more work to get working, but once I got it working I could rely on it to stay working rather than getting broken in the next update. (Linux is no different from windows these days, so I've moved to FreeBSD).

I don't know, windows just works most of time just fine. Linux is way more problematic, that's why I just use Windows.

Re: Even After Fix, Windows 10 Update Is Botching File Operations

#159
post #158
post #109

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Working out of the box is nice, but what's magically fixed can be magically broken just as easily. Traditional Linux was more work to get working, but once I got it working I could rely on it to stay working rather than getting broken in the next update. (Linux is no different from windows these days, so I've moved to FreeBSD).

I don't know, windows just works most of time just fine. Linux is way more problematic, that's why I just use Windows.

I find windows more problematic, because of the unpredictability. FreeBSD experience: spend a day or two setting it up, but after that you can rely on it always working. Windows experience: it works the first time, but every few months it will have an update that breaks things for a bit.
Post reply on HN