Live data from Hacker News

US Announces Withdraw From Postal Treaty

bbc.com

31–40 of 380 posts

Re: US Announces Withdraw From Postal Treaty

#31
Why does the US have to withdraw instead of negotiating? The US are not the only country that is unhappy about the shipping rates with China.

The postal treaty however is hugely important for smaller countries. I don’t want a world where the US destroy the entire postal system for the rest of us.

Re: US Announces Withdraw From Postal Treaty

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What about American innovation that relies on certain parts from China, such as the entire electronic industry which we operate in?

They should pay the cost of shipping their parts from China to the US without a subsidy from the US taxpayer.

seems like this will backfire if we ever want to access the emerging Chinese consumer market.

Re: US Announces Withdraw From Postal Treaty

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What about American innovation that relies on certain parts from China, such as the entire electronic industry which we operate in?

They should pay the cost of shipping their parts from China to the US without a subsidy from the US taxpayer.

Of course you realize that this change will likely disproportionately affect the poor and middle-class (who will see a sharp rise in shipping costs) as well as smaller businesses who rely on thin margins to survive.

The cost of $300 million per year as quoted in the article seems like peanuts compared to some of the other actions this administration has burdened tax payers with.

Re: US Announces Withdraw From Postal Treaty

#37
post #28
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What will be the unintended consequences I wonder? Small businesses who use dropshipping direct from Chinese companies will stop being able to compete with big businesses who buy in bulk and ship from US warehouses. This will benefit the likes of Amazon more than anyone else. Not sure if that's an unintended consequence though.

Which isn’t a bad thing. Maybe we’ll see less spam drop shipped items on Amazon finally. eBay too.

The things you see on Amazon are bought by the container-load from China and sent to Amazon's warehouses for fulfilment. This change will encourage that sort of business because it'll no longer be worthwhile sending direct from China (as the likes of dx.com and aliexpress do now).

Re: US Announces Withdraw From Postal Treaty

#38

Why does the US have to withdraw instead of negotiating? The US are not the only country that is unhappy about the shipping rates with China. The postal treaty however is hugely important for smaller countries. I don’t want a world where the US destroy the entire postal system for the rest of us.

The article says that withdrawing takes a year and they want to negotiate during that year so the withdraw doesn't happen.

Re: US Announces Withdraw From Postal Treaty

#39

We have the same issue in Switzerland with cheap packages from China which are received as mail but do not fit through the automated sorting system. This requires a lot of manual labor which increases the costs for the postal service. This is why sometime this year people who receive such mail will be billed additional fees increasing slowly over the next few years. The treaty allows under developed nations to ship a…

It does require having to leave the treaty - if the UPU Congress refuses to reclassify China. The threat to leave, is meant to apply enough pressure to finally get that reclassification accomplished. They've been intentionally dragging their feet on this matter over time and they only meet under normal circumstances every four years (they can of course hold emergency sessions). It's the exact same problem the US has…

I heavily dislike that america just leaves treaties it does not like instead of improving them. Most smaller countries cannot use the same method.

If my country for instance were to do thay nobody would ship there any more because the billing system would be too complex and expensive and the market is just too small.

Post reply on HN