Live data from Hacker News

Facebook to ban misinformation on voting in upcoming U.S. elections

reuters.com

91–100 of 151 posts

Re: Facebook to ban misinformation on voting in upcoming U.S. elections

#91
post #9

The upcoming US elections may prove to be a watershed moment for modern democracies in general. There is a widely held belief in academic cycles that mass voter manipulation through social media has managed to trump all other kinds of propaganda, causing people to become electoral zombies. This belief is based on flimsy evidence and on a mountain of bias. I hope facebook and the other media do everything by the book…

[deleted]

Re: Facebook to ban misinformation on voting in upcoming U.S. elections

#92
post #81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

An accurate presentation of the facts very rarely looks like presenting precisely two opposing sides as having equally valid ideas, and then refusing to contextualise the debate that you've artifically created in doing so.

A presentation is subjective. Unless you are literally showing people recorded values and scientific study methodology verbatim, it is subjective and open to interpretation to some degree.

Of course a presentation is subjective. There are, however, significantly better ways of presenting a debate over something than finding the one person who holds the exact opposite of the current mainstream view and bringing them on radio or television or giving them opinion columns in the newspaper, repeatedly, until they manage to whip up a crowd who are angry enough at the state of the world and want someone to blame to believe them.

Re: Facebook to ban misinformation on voting in upcoming U.S. elections

#93
post #16
post #9

The upcoming US elections may prove to be a watershed moment for modern democracies in general. There is a widely held belief in academic cycles that mass voter manipulation through social media has managed to trump all other kinds of propaganda, causing people to become electoral zombies. This belief is based on flimsy evidence and on a mountain of bias. I hope facebook and the other media do everything by the book…

I'm not sure what this comment has to do with the article. This is about targeted ads telling people they could vote by text message or that their polling place isn't safe. What does that have to do with "mass delusions" and "academic cycles"?

it is a bit meta, because i didnt have anything to comment on facebook's move, it seems rather obvious, (although it would probably be easier for them as company to ban political advertising altogether this time).

Re: Facebook to ban misinformation on voting in upcoming U.S. elections

#94
post #9

The upcoming US elections may prove to be a watershed moment for modern democracies in general. There is a widely held belief in academic cycles that mass voter manipulation through social media has managed to trump all other kinds of propaganda, causing people to become electoral zombies. This belief is based on flimsy evidence and on a mountain of bias. I hope facebook and the other media do everything by the book…

[deleted]

neither of these sources are peer-reviewed.

Re: Facebook to ban misinformation on voting in upcoming U.S. elections

#95
The nytimes, cnn and washingtonpost should join Facebook, Google and Twitter to form an organization to get rid of misinformation once and for all. We can call it the Ministry of Truth or something like that so it has credibility. Maybe the good honest unbiased folks at snopes can run it for them with some help from the JDL and SPLC.

Re: Facebook to ban misinformation on voting in upcoming U.S. elections

#96
post #21
post #9

The upcoming US elections may prove to be a watershed moment for modern democracies in general. There is a widely held belief in academic cycles that mass voter manipulation through social media has managed to trump all other kinds of propaganda, causing people to become electoral zombies. This belief is based on flimsy evidence and on a mountain of bias. I hope facebook and the other media do everything by the book…

> This will be an easy way to finally dissolve these mass delusions and make it obvious that societal change is real. How so? If the democrats win, the republicans will be able to claim that Silicon Valley is manipulating the voters by deplatforming conservatives. If the republicans win, the democrats will be able to claim more Russian bot/fake news manipulation.

my assumption is that you can fool people one time. The republicans may get a chance to blame 'deplatforming' . But democrats blaming again the russians when facebook is vigilant and the whole world is watching closely .... hard to be convincing.

Re: Facebook to ban misinformation on voting in upcoming U.S. elections

#97
post #17
post #9

The upcoming US elections may prove to be a watershed moment for modern democracies in general. There is a widely held belief in academic cycles that mass voter manipulation through social media has managed to trump all other kinds of propaganda, causing people to become electoral zombies. This belief is based on flimsy evidence and on a mountain of bias. I hope facebook and the other media do everything by the book…

> This belief is based on flimsy evidence and on a mountain of bias... Isn't that pretty much all political beliefs? Facebook is not so different from any other individual or organization in this regard.

i mean the academics, and i dont mean their political belief, but their conviction that the "fake news/russia/misinformation" complex is solely responsible for the trump election.

Re: Facebook to ban misinformation on voting in upcoming U.S. elections

#98
post #47
post #40

I really don't think you should remove information (or even be able to sue someone, except for defamation) for it being false, because it gives people the false impression that if information is printed or allowed on Facebook that it's probably accurate. We need to give everyone the impression that whatever they read might be false, because it actually might be false. Maybe that will make people think critically abou…

This. Assume everything is false until proven otherwise.

“Believe none of what you hear, and only half of what you see”

Re: Facebook to ban misinformation on voting in upcoming U.S. elections

#99
post #9

The upcoming US elections may prove to be a watershed moment for modern democracies in general. There is a widely held belief in academic cycles that mass voter manipulation through social media has managed to trump all other kinds of propaganda, causing people to become electoral zombies. This belief is based on flimsy evidence and on a mountain of bias. I hope facebook and the other media do everything by the book…

Instead of mass voter manipulation of voters through the establishment media? Nobody would be in a panic at all if Hillary had won.

America had to pick between an idiot, a criminal, and a socialist. They literally had no one to vote for. The country would be upset regardless of who won.
Post reply on HN