Live data from Hacker News

Universal Basic Income Is Silicon Valley’s Latest Scam

medium.com

11–20 of 30 posts

Re: Universal Basic Income Is Silicon Valley’s Latest Scam

#11
post #3

In the article: ------------------- Had Andrew Jackson not overturned the original reconstruction proposal for freed slaves to be given 40 acres and a mule as reparation, instead of simply allowing them to earn wage labor on former slaveowners’ lands, we might be looking at a vastly less divided America today. ---------------------- Andrew Jackson was long dead. It was Andrew Johnson who rejected 40 acres and a mule.…

That may have been edited, as I read "Johnson".

Re: Universal Basic Income Is Silicon Valley’s Latest Scam

#12
Paranoid, cynical garbage. Silicon Valley also produces affordable, reliable, high resolution ultrasound diagnostic devices that save many lives with noninvasive procedures, but it is more gripping to talk about taxis.

The biggest problem with inequality is the floor and that is a problem UBI robustly addresses. Once people are off the floor they have many options and are not forced into the gig economy or any other specific option.

Re: Universal Basic Income Is Silicon Valley’s Latest Scam

#15

People waiting for UBI can get in the same line as the people waiting for the singularity.

Except UBI is something we can actually implement if we want to do so.

Could you please be more specific? So far I haven't seen a proposal that solves price inflation and reliable money source is very unclear as well - it'd be great if you could clarify.

Re: Universal Basic Income Is Silicon Valley’s Latest Scam

#16
post #12

Paranoid, cynical garbage. Silicon Valley also produces affordable, reliable, high resolution ultrasound diagnostic devices that save many lives with noninvasive procedures, but it is more gripping to talk about taxis. The biggest problem with inequality is the floor and that is a problem UBI robustly addresses. Once people are off the floor they have many options and are not forced into the gig economy or any other…

Care to compare market caps of those ultrasound manufacturers with that of Uber?

Re: Universal Basic Income Is Silicon Valley’s Latest Scam

#17
post #12

Paranoid, cynical garbage. Silicon Valley also produces affordable, reliable, high resolution ultrasound diagnostic devices that save many lives with noninvasive procedures, but it is more gripping to talk about taxis. The biggest problem with inequality is the floor and that is a problem UBI robustly addresses. Once people are off the floor they have many options and are not forced into the gig economy or any other…

Care to compare market caps of those ultrasound manufacturers with that of Uber?

Care to compare the global market size of transportation versus specialized medical devices?

Yours is a bad faith comparison unless you do this.

Re: Universal Basic Income Is Silicon Valley’s Latest Scam

#18
This article seems to make the argument:

Premise 1: There's this big problem of inequality

Premise 2: UBI is not a perfect solution for solving this inequality

Therefore, probably,

Conclusion: We should reject this solution

This is called Nirvana fallacy [0], also known as the perfect solution fallacy. For example: "Seat belts are a bad idea. People are still going to die in car crashes."

[0]: https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Nirvana_fallacy

Re: Universal Basic Income Is Silicon Valley’s Latest Scam

#19
> their loyal vassals, the software developers

And there it is - the fashionable people striking back against the geeks who were supposed to grow up and lead lonely, miserable, solitary existences but who have inexplicably found themselves in positions of relative importance. And the popular “in crowd” will do whatever they can to keep that from continuing.

Post reply on HN