Live data from Hacker News

James Murdoch in line to replace Musk as Tesla chairman

reuters.com

61–70 of 91 posts

Re: James Murdoch in line to replace Musk as Tesla chairman

#61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The United States, Canada and others are too sprawling and sparse for that. Cars are going to be a fact of life for a very long time yet. As far as helping to solve climate change, cars are part of it, but I wish people paid much more attention to the larger contributor: Agriculture. I often get the feeling that people think changing cars to electric will solve the problem. It's important and helps, but it's just one…

Europe is also large, and there is much better public transportation. If the US really wanted to replace cars, the US could replace cars. The problem is we equate cars with 'freedom', so we are doomed to live forever in the past until that changes (or we destroy ourselves)

It's not just 'freedom'. It's a practical matter given the vast distances between even individual houses in certain parts of the US. Europe, as a whole, is large, but European nations individually are not very big in relation to a lot of US states. People should absolutely be able to travel within their countries however best suits them.

Re: James Murdoch in line to replace Musk as Tesla chairman

#63
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is no getting rid of cars for the foreseeable future, making them electric is the obvious next step for reducing their environmental impact

If we can't get rid of cars I'm really not sure there is a future.

Seems a bit hyperbolic. Even if mass transit was ascendant/dominant, you'd still have "last mile" issues where only a car would suffice.

Wishing for cars to go away is as pie-in-the-sky as wishing POTS or Email would disappear. Simply not going to happen - it's too ubiquitous.

Re: James Murdoch in line to replace Musk as Tesla chairman

#64

Sorry, we live in a world where News Corp has been at the epicenter of cultivating "Merchants of Doubt"[1] when it comes to anthropogenic climate change. Anyone tied up in that universe deserves skepticism if not outright rejection for the unbelievable damage they have wielded on society's ability to address climate change. The cost to society is enormous, and their grandchildren and grandchildren's children will pay…

I don't know his exact political leanings but he looks to be more liberal than his father. His wife for instance works for the Clinton Climate Initiative.

Wow, actually just looked at her Twitter feed, it's pretty hardcore anti-Republican. Their Thanksgivings must be interesting.

Re: James Murdoch in line to replace Musk as Tesla chairman

#65

Sorry, we live in a world where News Corp has been at the epicenter of cultivating "Merchants of Doubt"[1] when it comes to anthropogenic climate change. Anyone tied up in that universe deserves skepticism if not outright rejection for the unbelievable damage they have wielded on society's ability to address climate change. The cost to society is enormous, and their grandchildren and grandchildren's children will pay…

Elon Musk must leave, I saw him smoking a joint

Re: James Murdoch in line to replace Musk as Tesla chairman

#66
post #53

Sorry, we live in a world where News Corp has been at the epicenter of cultivating "Merchants of Doubt"[1] when it comes to anthropogenic climate change. Anyone tied up in that universe deserves skepticism if not outright rejection for the unbelievable damage they have wielded on society's ability to address climate change. The cost to society is enormous, and their grandchildren and grandchildren's children will pay…

Are electric cars genuinely seen as part of the solution to climate change? Surely there is no place for cars in our utopian green future, they are terribly inefficient means of transportation and completely anti-social and anti-urban. The future is in advanced metro systems, high speed rail, cycling etc. In this future, cars would become decided niche. I had never thought of Tesla being one of the 'good guys', espec…

In most of the country, per passenger, per person transported a mile, cars are more efficient than public transportation. Electric cars take less than half the energy per mile driven. So they definitely have a role.

The reason why is that a bus has to run whether or not it has passengers on it. A lot of empty buses without passengers are running around all day and night in most metro areas.

So yes, public transit makes a lot of sense where it makes sense. But it only makes sense within a relatively small number of very dense cities.

Re: James Murdoch in line to replace Musk as Tesla chairman

#67
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

James Murdoch is good friends of Elon Musk. So it is technically nepotism.

Their friendship would make it cronyism, not nepotism.

Nepotism:

"the practice among those with power or influence of favouring relatives or friends, especially by giving them jobs."

https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/nepotism

Re: James Murdoch in line to replace Musk as Tesla chairman

#68
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They're also brilliant businessmen who have built the most successful news empire in America

The father might fit that description, but none of the second generation who've taken roles in the family business have distinguished themselves.

Ya I honestly have no idea of what every individual in their family has achieved but I guess James is up to bat for Tesla, I hope he can make some positive reforms in the work culture as well as keep working to increase the market share of electric cars

Re: James Murdoch in line to replace Musk as Tesla chairman

#69

Sorry, we live in a world where News Corp has been at the epicenter of cultivating "Merchants of Doubt"[1] when it comes to anthropogenic climate change. Anyone tied up in that universe deserves skepticism if not outright rejection for the unbelievable damage they have wielded on society's ability to address climate change. The cost to society is enormous, and their grandchildren and grandchildren's children will pay…

From another commenter. > threeseed > James Murdoch has been on the board for a while and is very good friends with Elon Musk. So this brings a sympathetic chairman who isn't going to crack down on Musk's erratic behaviour. It seems a bit late to be concerned about this guy wielding influence at Tesla.

Almost every board has some sympathetic board members. Very different story for that person to be chairman.

Especially when the intent of the SEC agreement was that there was to be objective oversight of Musk.

Re: James Murdoch in line to replace Musk as Tesla chairman

#70
post #66
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are electric cars genuinely seen as part of the solution to climate change? Surely there is no place for cars in our utopian green future, they are terribly inefficient means of transportation and completely anti-social and anti-urban. The future is in advanced metro systems, high speed rail, cycling etc. In this future, cars would become decided niche. I had never thought of Tesla being one of the 'good guys', espec…

In most of the country, per passenger, per person transported a mile, cars are more efficient than public transportation. Electric cars take less than half the energy per mile driven. So they definitely have a role. The reason why is that a bus has to run whether or not it has passengers on it. A lot of empty buses without passengers are running around all day and night in most metro areas. So yes, public transit mak…

Can you please cite your sources.

According to this article as long as you have about 11 people on a bus its more efficient. https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2012/11/can-we-please...

Post reply on HN