Live data from Hacker News

Presidential Alerts

time.com

31–40 of 122 posts

Re: Presidential Alerts

#31

I still don’t understand the actual point of this, beyond the optics of a vaguely-defined “emergency preparedness.” Emergencies are inherently local. Even if smartphones had been widespread in 2001 and the presidential alert system had been active on 9/11, what purpose would a nationwide alert have served?

It's not hard to imagine much bigger emergencies than 9/11.

Re: Presidential Alerts

#32
"Presidential Alerts" is a terrible name in a time where presidents from either party tend to have about 40% approval or less. The name just automatically angers a significant portion of the population, no matter who the president happens to be. Considering that the presidency is a political position, it's not unreasonable to expect "Presidential Alerts" to be of a political nature, even though that is not how the system is intended to be used.

How about "National Alert System" or just continue calling it the "Emergency Alert System" (except now with new abilities). Put a procedure in place to let the president use it if needed.

Re: Presidential Alerts

#34
Why are these labeled as "Presidential"?

The combination of being impossible to configure as filtered and naming leaves me with the distinct taste of living under an aspiring dictatorship in my mouth.

Re: Presidential Alerts

#35
post #5

Why can't I disable or opt out of this?

Probably because Google and Apple make essentially every phone in use and they agreed to ignore your settings in favor of the President's.

I guess the benefit of not having control is that you can't be accused of being a jerk for having it go off during a movie or in court or whatever, since you have no choice.

Re: Presidential Alerts

#36
A bunch of us just got one.

SERIOUSLY? Does it _HAVE_ _TO_ say "presidential alert"? Do I have to be reminded of "him" during a time of potential crisis?

What could "Cheeto-Satan" have to say in a real emergency that is of any value whatsoever?

Re: Presidential Alerts

#37
My iPhone X with iOS 12 made the siren noise, but no message appeared on the screen and I can't find any alert message in the notifications page, messages, or elsewhere. So I only got 1 bit of information :-(.

Re: Presidential Alerts

#39

A bunch of us just got one. SERIOUSLY? Does it _HAVE_ _TO_ say "presidential alert"? Do I have to be reminded of "him" during a time of potential crisis? What could "Cheeto-Satan" have to say in a real emergency that is of any value whatsoever?

Hoo boy, I would love to see the raw upvote/downvote tally on that comment.

Re: Presidential Alerts

#40

"Presidential Alerts" is a terrible name in a time where presidents from either party tend to have about 40% approval or less. The name just automatically angers a significant portion of the population, no matter who the president happens to be. Considering that the presidency is a political position, it's not unreasonable to expect "Presidential Alerts" to be of a political nature, even though that is not how the sy…

.
Post reply on HN