Live data from Hacker News

Brendan Eich Writes to the US Senate: We Need a GDPR for the United States

brave.com

1–10 of 238 posts

Re: Brendan Eich Writes to the US Senate: We Need a GDPR for the United States

#3

Data protection we do need indeed, but the EU is the last entity I want to be emulating on internet laws, except maybe China.

I just love having internet laws written by people who can't use a computer without help. Makes so much sense...

Re: Brendan Eich Writes to the US Senate: We Need a GDPR for the United States

#4

Data protection we do need indeed, but the EU is the last entity I want to be emulating on internet laws, except maybe China.

What specifically do you take exception to with regard to GDPR/EU Internet laws? Having hands-on experience with compliance, I find GDPR to be quite reasonable - if anything, I'd say it's overly lax with regards to deletion of data that's not visible to the user (i.e. logs, 'shadow profiles', etc.).

Re: Brendan Eich Writes to the US Senate: We Need a GDPR for the United States

#5

Data protection we do need indeed, but the EU is the last entity I want to be emulating on internet laws, except maybe China.

I just love having internet laws written by people who can't use a computer without help. Makes so much sense...

Do you actually know any MEP? The younger generations are less stupid than you might think.

Politics is a slow game, the people who grew up with Windows 95 are only now starting to get elected.

Re: Brendan Eich Writes to the US Senate: We Need a GDPR for the United States

#6
It's funny, I was listening to the Hanselminutes, and in a recent episode, his guest (a lawyer) was underlining that the US partially created the current situation where current its companies are at loss in front of GDPR: by refusing to take the lead on data privacy issues, the US didn't have a framework for privacy laws, and couldn't negotiate a convergence of laws with the EU (I'm paraphrasing).

https://www.hanselminutes.com/647/how-gdpr-is-affecting-the-...

Re: Brendan Eich Writes to the US Senate: We Need a GDPR for the United States

#7

Data protection we do need indeed, but the EU is the last entity I want to be emulating on internet laws, except maybe China.

I just love having internet laws written by people who can't use a computer without help. Makes so much sense...

Is something wrong with the data protections laws that apply to medical data? Those could be expanded for all private data.

Re: Brendan Eich Writes to the US Senate: We Need a GDPR for the United States

#8

Data protection we do need indeed, but the EU is the last entity I want to be emulating on internet laws, except maybe China.

That's acute, considering there's at least a couple of major competitors in every area of Chinese internet economy, unlike the Google, Facebook, YouTube and Amazon de-facto monopoly.

Re: Brendan Eich Writes to the US Senate: We Need a GDPR for the United States

#9

Data protection we do need indeed, but the EU is the last entity I want to be emulating on internet laws, except maybe China.

I just love having internet laws written by people who can't use a computer without help. Makes so much sense...

Like a 35 year old with a degree in information and communications technology law?

Seems like he might possibly have encountered a computer or two given his special interests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jan_Philipp_Albrecht

As well as GDPR, which is one of the better IT related laws, he has sensible views on mass surveillance.

Re: Brendan Eich Writes to the US Senate: We Need a GDPR for the United States

#10
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I just love having internet laws written by people who can't use a computer without help. Makes so much sense...

Do you actually know any MEP? The younger generations are less stupid than you might think. Politics is a slow game, the people who grew up with Windows 95 are only now starting to get elected.

In the current legislature, there is one former software programmer MEP and a Linus's uncle, who is not a programmer but knows a bit about software.

There's also Julia Reda, but she is really just a filesharer and a politician.

Post reply on HN