Live data from Hacker News

Google Engineer Builds Facebook Disconnect

techcrunch.com

11–20 of 51 posts

Re: Google Engineer Builds Facebook Disconnect

#12
If you are that worried about Facebook privacy, just create a fake account and stuff it with fake data on your fake persona. This way, not only you will be expressing your disdain for Facebook's lack of privacy, you'll also be saying to Facebook: I don't like you but I use you ;-)

Or better yet, use OpenID.

Re: Google Engineer Builds Facebook Disconnect

#15
post #3

Of course one should be 'worried' about privacy with his/her data on facebook, but i don't think one should care less with the information google has about a huge amount of people. Just as a reminder: they know what you look for on the web (google itself), they know what you talk to your friends (gtalk), they know what you get via email (gmail), they know what videos you watch to (on youtube) and they now even have a…

Why is it bad if google or facebook know a lot about people? Can you give me some examples?

Re: Google Engineer Builds Facebook Disconnect

#16
post #5
post #2

I do something similar with adblock filters. I don't use Facebook, so I have no privacy issue with connect, but it does improve load/render times by multiple seconds.

Would you mind sharing? Sounds useful.

I block the following:

static.ak.fbcdn.net

||connect.facebook.net^

*.facebook.com

Among a bunch of others, but these are the FB-related ones.

Re: Google Engineer Builds Facebook Disconnect

#17
post #7

Come on, we already have a perfectly good protocol for this, OpenID. It's unfortunate how big companies try to lock users in their own authentication services rather than educate them about OpenID (although I think the new JanRain widgets turn OpenID into a "Connect with X" service, which is great).

Unfortunately, OpenId is too complicated for most folks. paste in your url? c'mon. Even Brad Fitzpatrick realizes this:

http://code.google.com/p/webfinger/

"People have been trying to use URLs as identifiers for people (as OpenID does), as it has great readability/discoverability properties, but this effort has largely failed because of UI/UX design failings, user confusion about URLs, etc."

Re: Google Engineer Builds Facebook Disconnect

#18
post #17
post #7

Come on, we already have a perfectly good protocol for this, OpenID. It's unfortunate how big companies try to lock users in their own authentication services rather than educate them about OpenID (although I think the new JanRain widgets turn OpenID into a "Connect with X" service, which is great).

Unfortunately, OpenId is too complicated for most folks. paste in your url? c'mon. Even Brad Fitzpatrick realizes this: http://code.google.com/p/webfinger/ "People have been trying to use URLs as identifiers for people (as OpenID does), as it has great readability/discoverability properties, but this effort has largely failed because of UI/UX design failings, user confusion about URLs, etc."

You don't have to, there are widgets you can use where you just select your provider and enter your username, and everything's done.

Re: Google Engineer Builds Facebook Disconnect

#19
post #3

Of course one should be 'worried' about privacy with his/her data on facebook, but i don't think one should care less with the information google has about a huge amount of people. Just as a reminder: they know what you look for on the web (google itself), they know what you talk to your friends (gtalk), they know what you get via email (gmail), they know what videos you watch to (on youtube) and they now even have a…

Maybe a Facebook engineer will make "Google disconnect" now?

Re: Google Engineer Builds Facebook Disconnect

#20
Direct link to the Chrome extension: https://chrome.google.com/extensions/detail/ejpepffjfmamnamb...

It is a bit odd to blame this on Google unless the guy created it at work. From the page: "the work here is entirely my own and in no way endorsed by Google."

edit: disclaimer is on the actual download page!

Post reply on HN