Live data from Hacker News

Do You Know Cobol? If So, There Might Be a Job for You

wsj.com

21–30 of 54 posts

Re: Do You Know Cobol? If So, There Might Be a Job for You

#21

I can't tell if this is in the article as it's paywalled, but a company in York recently put up an advert for £20k/year for Cobol programmers with no programming experience required, doubling at the end of the training period.

Is that a livable wage there?

£400 a week, in York? Hell yes. £800 once you’re done training for someone who couldn’t program before they started is not just good, it’s fantastic for anywhere in the U.K. outside London for a junior.

Re: Do You Know Cobol? If So, There Might Be a Job for You

#22
post #4

I’m curious why there aren’t more x -> x conversion/adapter tools available. Most languages have the same core data models/abstract concepts, if there really is an enterprise/business demand for a product, usually some company would come up with a solution. Personally I’m curious about COBOL and learning from it’s design, but I’m intrigued by this question in general.

There is likely more to solve than just code. COBOL is often running in a proprietary environment with dependencies on things like job schedulers, databases, terminals, network protocols, character sets, etc.

Check the COBOL job postings, and you'll see desired skills in TSO, JCL, CICS, Natural/Adabase, VSAM, etc. Or equivalents of those for OS/400, MPE, or VMS mid-range platforms.

Re: Do You Know Cobol? If So, There Might Be a Job for You

#23

> The problem is that Cobol isn’t popular with new programmers. Enough with the COBOL shortage myth. Don't be fooled, not being popular is not the problem. The problem is COBOL jobs aren't competitive, they often even pay worse than other tech jobs. That's why they are either being outsourced or offered to 60 year olds in their spare time. (So arguably they're not that mission-critical, either.) But then who is writi…

Maybe the author of the article browses HN and/or Reddit and saw some comments about there being few COBOL programmers (I've seen a couple of comments about it in the past), and decided to write an article about it?

Re: Do You Know Cobol? If So, There Might Be a Job for You

#24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is that a livable wage there?

£400 a week, in York? Hell yes. £800 once you’re done training for someone who couldn’t program before they started is not just good, it’s fantastic for anywhere in the U.K. outside London for a junior.

Thanks! I don't know anything about York, and am honestly not even sure what the £:$ conversion is at the moment.

(Being paid to learn a skill from scratch does sound pretty objectively good, though.)

Re: Do You Know Cobol? If So, There Might Be a Job for You

#25

I can't tell if this is in the article as it's paywalled, but a company in York recently put up an advert for £20k/year for Cobol programmers with no programming experience required, doubling at the end of the training period.

There is no mention of salaries in the article. But if you want to read it: https://outline.com/ZC4jn8

Re: Do You Know Cobol? If So, There Might Be a Job for You

#26

I really dislike slotting things down to a language. If you are proficient in the underlying programming concepts, the language simply does not matter with the right amount of motivation.

The missing link here is that COBOL is being used as shorthand for experience with mainframe programming, which of course you can’t really get unless you’ve been employed programming mainframes before. Anyone complaining about a lack of COBOL programmers is essentially complaining that nobody else is picking up on the training costs for their non-standard, incredibly expensive infrastructure, and that they don’t want to train people themselves.

Re: Do You Know Cobol? If So, There Might Be a Job for You

#27
post #4

I’m curious why there aren’t more x -> x conversion/adapter tools available. Most languages have the same core data models/abstract concepts, if there really is an enterprise/business demand for a product, usually some company would come up with a solution. Personally I’m curious about COBOL and learning from it’s design, but I’m intrigued by this question in general.

Hi! First post on here. The conversion/adapter tools exists. It's not a technical issue. The problem is that cobol applications are normally monolithic, and a migration to another system represents an huge risk because: 1) you migrate like a Big Bang migration, or; 2) you migrate step by step. Imagine a bank with applications running at 30 or 40 years without problems... Nobody in his perfect judgment will accept to…

There can also be an intermediate phase of migrating from a hardware mainframe to a virtualized mainframe. I understand that's what TicketMaster did a while ago.

> Hi! First post on here.

Welcome, and very nice post. :)

Re: Do You Know Cobol? If So, There Might Be a Job for You

#28
post #3

Well, Indian offshore companies have been training many COBOL guys since Y2K. These days, most of the SAP related jobs are outsourced to India. How can one expect that the same fate won't befall those who want to master COBOL now? How about salaries?

> How can one expect that the same fate won't befall those who want to master

FTFY.

No programming language requires proximity. The only jobs you can expect to never be offshored are in (literal) plumbing.

This said, anything involved with Very Big Companies is probably more at risk, because it makes more sense for them to move entire departments offshore just to save a few percentage points on aggregate costs (actual productivity be damned). So I expect this will soon happen to the likes of Salesforce, if it's not already. AWS is definitely already happening.

Also anything getting too mainstream, because then it makes sense for outsourcers to invest in training high numbers of people. I expect the market to soon be flooded by Python outsourcers, now that it's making real inroads in the enterprise space (with bigdata etc).

Re: Do You Know Cobol? If So, There Might Be a Job for You

#29

I really dislike slotting things down to a language. If you are proficient in the underlying programming concepts, the language simply does not matter with the right amount of motivation.

So someone with a strong competency in C#, PHP, or JavaScript should be able to write Assembly? I'm not saying you're wrong, but I feel like there's a piece there that's missing.

Yes, someone with a strong competency developing software in any language should be able to learn to write Assembly/any other language. There will be a learning curve, but the ability to reason abstractly is fully transferable.

Re: Do You Know Cobol? If So, There Might Be a Job for You

#30

I can't tell if this is in the article as it's paywalled, but a company in York recently put up an advert for £20k/year for Cobol programmers with no programming experience required, doubling at the end of the training period.

Is that a livable wage there?

£20k for a 21 y/o would be good, more than many entry office jobs. And jumping to £40k would put you ahead of many office and other roles that 30+ y/o might hope to get (more than a local teacher with a few years of experience for example). Yes there are some higher paying jobs in the area - but if you are looking for a first role fresh out of uni - that would be pretty good. Exp if no experience needed.
Post reply on HN