Live data from Hacker News

Voting Machine Used in Half of U.S. Is Vulnerable to Attack, Report Finds

wsj.com

61–70 of 207 posts

Re: Voting Machine Used in Half of U.S. Is Vulnerable to Attack, Report Finds

#61
Also vulnerable to attacks: Automobiles, Air gapped computer, many routers, cell phones, ATMs, Gouvernment infrastructure...

https://www.wired.com/story/car-hack-shut-down-safety-featur...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_gap_malware

https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/05/hacke...

https://koolspan.com/hack-a-cell-phone/ https://www.cnn.com/2013/10/24/world/europe/uk-phone-hacking...

Is anyone shocked yet?

Re: Voting Machine Used in Half of U.S. Is Vulnerable to Attack, Report Finds

#62
post #40
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The state of Oregon has vote by mail. Its awesome. My ballot gets mailed to me a few weeks before the election. I fill it out, and can either mail it back (I have to pay for a postage stamp) or drop it off at a ballot drop box all over town. there are all sorts of safeguards for things like not getting your ballot in the mail, etc. I was also automatically register to vote as an independent when I got my drivers lice…

This actually a bad idea: The reason for in person voting is poll monitors there are watching to make sure nobody knows how you voted. There are have been cases of "vote for me or I'll break your legs". When you vote from home someone can come by and watch you mail your vote the "correct" way in.

In theory. Has this actually happened, since the introduction of postal voting, in the United States?

To be useful it would be necessary to visit 10,000’s - 100,000 houses and threaten violence.

The voting system does not need to resolve this issue. Threats of violence are already illegal, and any group conducting such acts at that volume would be quickly apprehended. Call the police.

Can you imagine how quickly twitter / the internet would blow up if stand over men were going door to door threatening voters?

Re: Voting Machine Used in Half of U.S. Is Vulnerable to Attack, Report Finds

#63
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It’s a little taxing, but everyone involved enjoy the process This is part of the problem in the United States. Voting is a chore, and you're often going to lose money (unpaid time off) to do it. If elections were national holidays and voting was treated as a privilege instead of a chore, we would be much better off.

I live in Colorado. A couple of weeks before the midterms I'm going to get a packet in the mail containing my ballot, instructions for filling it out, a pamphlet where every candidate on the ballot gets a paragraph or two to make their case, and a prepaid return envelope. I fill out my ballot at my leisure, stuff it in the envelope, sign the envelope underneath the flap, and drop it in a mailbox. There's a receipt wi…

We do that in Switzerlamd as well. I have never voted by going to some place.

Voter turnout is still not very high.

Re: Voting Machine Used in Half of U.S. Is Vulnerable to Attack, Report Finds

#64
post #55
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The state of Oregon has vote by mail. Its awesome. My ballot gets mailed to me a few weeks before the election. I fill it out, and can either mail it back (I have to pay for a postage stamp) or drop it off at a ballot drop box all over town. there are all sorts of safeguards for things like not getting your ballot in the mail, etc. I was also automatically register to vote as an independent when I got my drivers lice…

If you mail it do you get a confirmation that it was received and processed? How does one know that it wasn't destroyed while en route? Does the ballot come with a tracking number that you can punch in on website to see if your vote was processed correctly?

I get an email ack that it was received. Was it scanned and correctly tabulated? Unlikely given the history in my county (Sarasota)

Re: Voting Machine Used in Half of U.S. Is Vulnerable to Attack, Report Finds

#65
post #59
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How often is this an issue? Sounds like a made up scenario for the US.

It's better to worry about these things before they are problems. I don't know if it's happened in the US but it is absolutely a very common attack against voting systems, and any voting system not resistant to it should be considered suspect.

Switzerland, one of the most democratic places in the world has done this for a very lomg time.

While im theory its relevant a practical issue has never happened once as far as I can remember.

Going to hugly distributed areas to beat all voters up seems like a terrible attack vector.

So maybe in some places it could be a problem but I dont see it as much of a problem in a modern First World Democracy.

Re: Voting Machine Used in Half of U.S. Is Vulnerable to Attack, Report Finds

#66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seems simple enough to just make it a national holiday.

I can't believe it's not either a national holiday or an accepted thing for all employers to give the day off. I know legally they have to give you an hour to vote, but the entire day sends a message that this is an important thing for you to do.

> I know legally they have to give you an hour to vote

Are you certain about this?

Re: Voting Machine Used in Half of U.S. Is Vulnerable to Attack, Report Finds

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can get an ID card that works as legal id but isn't a driver's license, but it still requires going to the DMV and burning at LEAST several hours, which isn't an option available to everybody.

I'm sure their friendly neighborhood community organizer will charter a bus for them to get their ID cards. If they're citizens, there will be somebody who wants their vote badly enough to walk them through that process and even buy them a sandwich for their trouble. Let's join the rest of the world and make sure that the people voting in our elections are citizens. Community organizers have proven to be extremely ef…

Transportation to a DMV office isn't the main limitation. Having the freedom to miss a day or two of work to spend waiting in line is a bigger problem, especially when those offices don't necessarily process non-driver ID cards on all ordinary business days.

> Let's join the rest of the world and make sure that the people voting in our elections are citizens.

The proper time to verify citizenship is during the registration process, when there's time to be thorough. You can't do a reasonable job of validating ID or checking that a person is only registered to vote in one place at the polling place.

Re: Voting Machine Used in Half of U.S. Is Vulnerable to Attack, Report Finds

#68
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This actually a bad idea: The reason for in person voting is poll monitors there are watching to make sure nobody knows how you voted. There are have been cases of "vote for me or I'll break your legs". When you vote from home someone can come by and watch you mail your vote the "correct" way in.

In theory. Has this actually happened, since the introduction of postal voting, in the United States? To be useful it would be necessary to visit 10,000’s - 100,000 houses and threaten violence. The voting system does not need to resolve this issue. Threats of violence are already illegal, and any group conducting such acts at that volume would be quickly apprehended. Call the police. Can you imagine how quickly twit…

It has happened in history.

Re: Voting Machine Used in Half of U.S. Is Vulnerable to Attack, Report Finds

#69
post #49

The HN consensus seems to be that digital voting is very difficult to do right. I trust the consensus opinion, but this also makes me sad. The bigger picture that I think we’re missing here is the opportunity for huge-scale direct democracy. I know the usual debates against DD, but I think there’s ways to safeguard against those problems. E.g. you can’t vote on an issue without hearing both sides of it and passing a…

>a test that demonstrates that you understand the pros and cons of each side Then you just moved the controversial part of the process back to what the pros and cons are , or another step further still to who decides what the pros and cons are .

Yes, the gatekeeper problem is tricky. I ultimately think that each side would submit pros and cons, with no rules around what they can submit. Otherwise we run into the gatekeeper problem. So some sides would submit sensational, false claims. And we’d have to trust the people to decide what’s true and false. We’re already trusting us, the people, to make these decisions when we elect representatives. We might as well directly face the consequences of our choices, rather than shifting blame to a representative.

Re: Voting Machine Used in Half of U.S. Is Vulnerable to Attack, Report Finds

#70
post #67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm sure their friendly neighborhood community organizer will charter a bus for them to get their ID cards. If they're citizens, there will be somebody who wants their vote badly enough to walk them through that process and even buy them a sandwich for their trouble. Let's join the rest of the world and make sure that the people voting in our elections are citizens. Community organizers have proven to be extremely ef…

Transportation to a DMV office isn't the main limitation. Having the freedom to miss a day or two of work to spend waiting in line is a bigger problem, especially when those offices don't necessarily process non-driver ID cards on all ordinary business days. > Let's join the rest of the world and make sure that the people voting in our elections are citizens. The proper time to verify citizenship is during the regist…

I will support any system that insures that all voters have verified citizenship.
Post reply on HN