Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Save my dying Startup

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 31 posts

Re: Ask HN: Save my dying Startup

#21
I think the main page of the site has too much information. It is difficult to find out what is the main purpose of this site?

The site have stats and recent activities sections where only one user keeps reporting some values. These sections should be removed as it makes me think does this site has only user? Such sections make sense when site has enough activities to report, otherwise new users would think no one is using it so it is not worth signing up.

Basically the website looks more like old-styled corporate website than call-to-action website. You may have to hire professional website designer to get any mileage. Alternatively put only one thing which you do the best and remove everything else.

Re: Ask HN: Save my dying Startup

#24
See that big dark grey blank area in your header? Give me the strongest benefit/advantage I could get from using your service up there. For instance: YaTrader: Information Advantage For Financial Junkies.

I need to see it spelled out clearly and boldly.

Re: Ask HN: Save my dying Startup

#25
post #16

The only reason you'll fail is because your product sucks, not lack of marketing or money. You are trying to do too much too soon, making everything mediocre crap. 1) Simplify everything; figure out what the one thing your site does well is (whatever is doing most successful, which looks like contests/predictions). Get rid of everything that people aren't using, like yaNotes. 2) Don't do international, focus on build…

Agree with the above. The problem is that by the sounds of your description your product has one killer feature - an algorithm to rate peers' predictions - but the website itsef looks like a generic consumer portal/network

Marketing spend itself shouldn't be an issue - you can drive traffic organically through blogging and even banging on the doors of your friends' old contacts.

Re: Ask HN: Save my dying Startup

#26
I have no encouragement to sign up. Why not? Because I can't see what kind of discussion is happening in the community. If I click on any of the communities I get a sign up pop up and no discussion. I'm not handing over my info till I see what kind of discussion is happening. I get frustrated and then I'm off to Motley Fooll CAPS or Stockhouse.

Re: Ask HN: Save my dying Startup

#28
I agree with most of the comments here: trim the fat. Hack away the unnecessary. Omit unnecessary words. And other such sage wisdom.

An idea: if you have enough of a core user base who would be willing to help fund you, consider http://kickstarter.com. You could have one helluva comeback story on your hands if you tell the story right and make it emotionally resonant. Play with the idea however you like, I don't want to be too specific as it will hinder the process.

Re: Ask HN: Save my dying Startup

#29
post #9

For me, the text is just one huge blob, so I made a half-assed attempt to format it so that it's more readable: The website he is referring to is http://www.yatrader.com --- Dear HNers, I am writing this post in hopes of getting some help on saving my startup which is slowly decaying before my eyes; countless hours of work, tens of thousands of dollars spent, and a ton of sacrifice just dying. There is a wealth of kn…

It sounds to me like you did a very good job at Product Development, but a failing job at Customer Development. You should have validated your assumptions against a small customer base, focusing on the most minimum of viable products. Then, let your customers pull you for new features rather than brainstorm all the possible ways your product "could" be used.

A feature that people "could" use, but don't actually use, is not really a feature - it's wasteful development.

It sounds like there's really some valuable stuff in the product. Is there a core of what the product could do (trimming it down to an MVP) that you can then validate through a Customer Development or similar process?

I know - it's Monday night quarterbacking (or whatever the other analogy is here), but I find you learn more from failures than successes. And anyone who's been through this more than once will tell you that failures are far more common than success. The only true failure is giving up, so use this as an opportunity to learn, pivot, and find the winning solution.

Re: Ask HN: Save my dying Startup

#30
Interesting post. Perhaps you and the guys from Intrade could work something out. I know their CEO and he is always looking out for cool ideas and joinh ventures. Why not mail him. His eamil is john.delaney @ intrade.com

Say Billy Flynn suggested you make contact with him.

Post reply on HN