Live data from Hacker News

Dear Moon

dearmoon.earth

131–140 of 246 posts

Re: Dear Moon

#131

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually for Apollo 17 it was found to be easier to train a geologist to be an astronaut than the other way around.

I guess as long as a high enough percentage of the crew are flight people, you can teach someone else to not get in the way too much?

Or it turns out that 20 years if field experience is harder to teach than 5 years experience in wearing pressure suits and zero/low gravity.

Re: Dear Moon

#132
post #43

It's worth keeping in mind "Elon Time". 2023 is a "no earlier than" date. It's if everything goes to plan, no new problems arise. I'd love to see it happen on schedule but I have doubts.

You might want to listen to the livestream -- Elon answers a question from the press about how certain the date is, and basically says the same thing you just did.

Re: Dear Moon

#133
post #87

Honestly, this is beautiful. Let's fucking do it. No seriously...let's do it. We're humans - this is the kind of funny, beautiful, impossible stuff we can uniquely do. Capital allocation? Bleh, don't be so boring and uninspired!

How much of your capital do you plan to allocate? And do you plan to allocate any of mine (i.e., the taxpayer)?

I plan to allocate about 1B, so probably around $3 of yours. I’m sure you’ll survive.

Re: Dear Moon

#134

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Its an Elon project? 1 in 10 odds it happens?

It's not just about the odds of this project. Missions like these make the public interested again. We might very well be in the beginning stages of a public-private space race, with "space startups" popping up in multiple countries (SpaceX, Blueorigin, [sic] ULA, Onespace[0]). These things can snowball, especially if somebody finds a way to extract resources from the Moon and asteroids. [0] https://www.space.com/406…

All we need is next gen super conductors making He3 fusion possible and the race is on.

Re: Dear Moon

#135
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For those missing the reference: https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Ben_Affleck Ben Affleck, talking to Michael Bay about the movie Armageddon, in which oil drillers are sent to an asteroid to drill a hole in it, drop a nuclear bomb into the hole, and then detonate that bomb: >I asked Michael (Bay) why it was easier to train oil drillers to become astronauts than it was to train astronauts to become oil drillers. He told…

Actually for Apollo 17 it was found to be easier to train a geologist to be an astronaut than the other way around.

The Apollo astronauts were also trained quite extensively in geology. Highly recommend the Apollo 12 episode of From the Earth to the Moon for a great look at that.

Re: Dear Moon

#136

Are they actually going to the moon if they are only going to orbit it? Sorry my English isn’t the best

They aren't going to actually orbit the moon, they're going around the moon. It's called a "free return trajectory". This is actually less than Apollo 8 did (edit: only talking about the orbit): Apollo 8 actually went into lunar orbit with a burn, and then left lunar orbit with another burn. However, this is using "orbit" in its formal sense. Most people would look at the diagram of the spaceship flying around the mo…

It's a (roughly) Zond-7 trajectory.

Re: Dear Moon

#137

This guy is only worth $3B, he may be spending half of his entire net worth to make this happen. I hope he inspires the richest billionaires of the world to fund such lofty ventures.

Man, think of all the Transformers movies he could buy (20).

Re: Dear Moon

#139

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Which Elon project has failed?

Model 3 still a bit rocky, eh?

It'll outsell every luxury sedan in the US in its first year.

If that kind of outcome gets you implicated for failure, BMW must be distraught as it looks at those dwindling 3 series sales figures.

Re: Dear Moon

#140
post #2

This may go down in history as the most amazing (and maybe most expensive) art project of all time. I am just flabbergasted; this is astounding. I sincerely hope that the BFR comes to fruition in the way SpaceX has been billing it, and reasonably close in terms of timeline.

A better use if this money would have been to try and eradicate proverty and hunger in Africa or unemployment in Europe.
Post reply on HN