Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

news.ycombinator.com

191–200 of 224 posts

Re: Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

#191

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is correct. You'll still repost prorated signing and relo, but some of your stock will have vested.

Surprised there is no one-year cliff now. Also did you have to return the pre-tax amounts or the post-tax amounts?

I stayed beyond one year, so idk. But I'd expect pre-tax.

Obviously you wouldn't pay tax on the amount you return, so it's not really an important distinction.

Re: Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

#192

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's compensation driven thinking ? There's a difference between only caring about money vs asking for what you deem fair. Startups always abuse the naivete of new grads and low ball them by saying they are working for a grander cause. That is BS too.

This isn't a fair assessment. Startups can't pay BigCo wages because they don't have the money to. They have to leverage other, harder-to-value benefits which BigCo generally can't offer. Increased responsibility, fewer "rules" on how to execute, more tightly focused mission are a few. Naturally this differs company to company and there are always bad actors. The compensation equation works out differently for each i…

They could have the money, say they hired less people, but payed the ones they had better for example.

Re: Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

#193
> but I get about 6% options over 4 years

on what conditions can you turn that into something you can spend?

there is usually a good reason people offer magic beans instead of cold hard cash... an 99% of the time it is because they are less valuable, and possibly valueless (even if the company does well the requirements to cash in will often be prohibitive)

Re: Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

#194

Advice from someone who had a similar choice and went the startup route: choose the Google option. It will not only open doors for you for all your future jobs, but you can invest the money now and create a nice start for yourself. There will never be any shortage of interesting startups to work for in the future.

I couldn’t agree more—I would add live below your means because you don’t want to get used to that lifestyle/level of income where it would be impossible to step back later if you wanted.

>impossible to step back later

Life finds a way. -2008 joeb

(Being real, this is good advice. Find the lowest-cost digs you can get; stay flexible, lease; don't get involved with securities you can't unload. Remember that you're on a 5-year plan.)

Re: Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

#195
You could always try the startup for 1 year and see how it goes. This way you get past your cliff, and you will have a much better idea of whether or not it has a chance of becoming something. If its flopping around like a fish then you can always go to a big co. Yes it would have cost you some $$$ short term, but you would have probably learned a lot more simply by having to wear more hats. Plus its a lot of fun to build something new from the ground up.

Re: Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

#196
post #29

Advice from someone who had a similar choice and went the startup route: choose the Google option. It will not only open doors for you for all your future jobs, but you can invest the money now and create a nice start for yourself. There will never be any shortage of interesting startups to work for in the future.

> It will not only open doors for you for all your future jobs Is this true though? I guess it might help with the first contact, but I've heard from x-googlers that they still had to prepare and pass all those whiteboard CS-riddle based interviews again, for next endeavors.

I'm sure it does open some doors. It closes other doors.

I would be leery of hiring from Google. I would need to be convinced that the candidate strongly rejects Google's culture.

Re: Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

#197
post #196
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It will not only open doors for you for all your future jobs Is this true though? I guess it might help with the first contact, but I've heard from x-googlers that they still had to prepare and pass all those whiteboard CS-riddle based interviews again, for next endeavors.

I'm sure it does open some doors. It closes other doors. I would be leery of hiring from Google. I would need to be convinced that the candidate strongly rejects Google's culture.

I'm curious what culture at Google you object to?

Re: Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

#199

Depends on what you'll be working on at Google, IMHO. Coding to sell more ads? Hell no. Coding to siphon more data on users from adjacency businesses to eventually sell more ads? Also hell no. That's like 85% of Google's business, so...

I don't know the access to resources, sheer scale, research, and good pay would make it pretty enticing for me. But really it comes down to what you are looking for long term. Do you want to optimize, finances, lifestyle, work in a particular space, learn more and eventually start your own thing? A job at Google probably scores well along most of these dimensions.

Re: Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

#200
post #25

Disclaimer: I'm a founder of an early stage startup, so I'm biased. You need to figure out what your goals are. We can't answer for you because we don't know what you want. If your goal is just money (which is fine, don't be afraid to say this), then definitely go to google. In 10 years you'll be earning 500k per year, and have put away a ton of cash too. Financially, if the startup is successful you_might_ make $10m…

Disclaimer: I'm an ex-FANG, ex-founder, now-again-FANG, so I'm also biased. I'm somewhat bothered by your comment about money: > If your goal is just money (which is fine, don't be afraid to say this), then definitely go to google. I find this disingenuous, as money is also a big reason why people do startups, both the employees and the founders. The founders could have chosen to implement their idea inside Google or…

Startup Non-founders statistically /rarely/ have their options worth much of anything in the end. Startups also generally pay less than FANG companies to boot (typically until they are no longer startups).
Post reply on HN