Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

news.ycombinator.com

71–80 of 224 posts

Re: Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

#71
post #70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you think other large tech companies are like this? If so, which ones?

I don’t have firsthand experience but my understanding is that Facebook shares a similar culture. No idea about others though.

What about Amazon?

Re: Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

#72
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe a higher ratio overall?

I see. Do you think people at Amazon are inferior?

The previous account you created to post these is one that we ended up having to ban for trolling.

We've banned this account. Please stop creating accounts to do this, or we'll ban your main account as well.

Re: Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google is also a very good learning opportunity; there is lots of training available to employees, you will be working with very talented people, and will get to see how the planet-scale dogfood is made first hand.

> you will be working with very talented people Do you think they are more talented than other companies, like, say, Amazon?

Really, for the most part, the talent goes to the best places to work. That's subjective but the major factors for most people are mission (e.g. charity good, privacy violation bad), working environment and compensation.

Amazon isn't really particularly good at any of these, so you'll tend to find more talent at places that do better. Facebook and Google both have better compensation and from what I've heard from friends (who've also had experience with Amazon), both also have a better working environment.

Re: Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

#74
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It will not only open doors for you for all your future jobs Is this true though? I guess it might help with the first contact, but I've heard from x-googlers that they still had to prepare and pass all those whiteboard CS-riddle based interviews again, for next endeavors.

Sample size of one: my company tends to ding candidates from Google if they have any whiff of the kind of status- or compensation-driven thinking displayed in this comment section. Can sometimes indicate limited independent thinking and low concern for others. Definitely can close doors.

What's compensation driven thinking ? There's a difference between only caring about money vs asking for what you deem fair. Startups always abuse the naivete of new grads and low ball them by saying they are working for a grander cause. That is BS too.

Re: Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

#75
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Put another way, you'll learn much more about how to identify and work with talented people on difficult projects at Google than at a startup. At a startup you're worried about how you'll pack a bologna sandwich for lunch tomorrow, at Google you're a sous chef for a 5 star banquet hall in NYC.

I think it goes both ways. There are plenty mundane things at BigCo for people to do.

I've done both extremes, and you're absolutely right, but the point still stands no matter how many cases we can find that might hint at the opposite :)

Re: Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

#76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sample size of one: my company tends to ding candidates from Google if they have any whiff of the kind of status- or compensation-driven thinking displayed in this comment section. Can sometimes indicate limited independent thinking and low concern for others. Definitely can close doors.

What's compensation driven thinking ? There's a difference between only caring about money vs asking for what you deem fair. Startups always abuse the naivete of new grads and low ball them by saying they are working for a grander cause. That is BS too.

This isn't a fair assessment.

Startups can't pay BigCo wages because they don't have the money to. They have to leverage other, harder-to-value benefits which BigCo generally can't offer.

Increased responsibility, fewer "rules" on how to execute, more tightly focused mission are a few.

Naturally this differs company to company and there are always bad actors.

The compensation equation works out differently for each individual. Not everyone should work at a startup.

Re: Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

#77
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google is also a very good learning opportunity; there is lots of training available to employees, you will be working with very talented people, and will get to see how the planet-scale dogfood is made first hand.

I've heard that many things are arcane in-house proprietary stuff, not easily transferable knowledge/experience.

This used to be the case, but these days many fundamental Google tools are open.

Borg is Kubernetes, flume is externally available as Google Cloud Dataflow (it's basically Apache Beam), Tensorflow is open source, many of Google's internal java libraries and tools are available externally (Guava, Guice, Dagger), and absl (c++ common libraries) are also available externally.

More importantly, assuming you land on a team with strong software engineering culture (this is likely, but admittedly not guaranteed, even at Google), the general skills you pick up for software design, planning, testing, etc. are transferable anywhere.

That said, all of this applies mostly to software engineers. If you're applying for an SRE position, then I've heard the experience is less transferable, but it's not something I could comment on first hand.

Re: Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

#78
Check out http://levels.fyi and see if you'd be happy with the progression of leveling up / compensation at Google. At a startup, while the risk is higher, the prospect of receiving compounded gains on value that you've created early on is hard to overlook. And the linear loss you are taking for both is basically just the time you spend there. Are you comfortable doing that right now?

Re: Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?

#79
post #63

Are you happy with the moral downside of working for a company that sells its users’ privacy for profit? A company that values automation more than customer service?

That's a good question. However, its easier said than done. Say whatever you want about Google and the likes and hate them, but for a dev, it's still one of the best places to learn, grow and get paid well. At that point most peoples moral compass tilts. I know so many people who said they would never work at Microsoft, Facebook, Google. However when they got an offer they accepted it. :)
Post reply on HN