Live data from Hacker News

Cycling Is Key to Safer, Healthier, More Vital Cities

citylab.com

261–270 of 382 posts

Re: Cycling Is Key to Safer, Healthier, More Vital Cities

#261

Not in any city with a real winter (-10F to 20F) I already loath going into my ice cold car and waiting for the heat.

I don't bike in winter, but 'Fat Biking' has gone way beyond fad here in Northern Michigan.. You see people commuting around town in them all winter long... a foot of new snow is not a problem for these folks. But it is a smaller city.

Re: Cycling Is Key to Safer, Healthier, More Vital Cities

#262

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Fixed gear, skinny tires. I'd probably be better off with cyclocross tires, but if you're optimizing for what you're going to be riding on 90% of the time, for winter commuting 90% of the time it's dry/wet pavement or hardpack snow. If the fatbikes give people confidence to ride in winter, more power to them, but personally I think it's overkill. For the cold you've got to keep your extremities protected. I've got bi…

Is there a temperature at which you call it quits? Those -30 Edmonton days seem like good days to choose other ways to commute.

When you are working hard -30 isn't that cold. I haven't biked in that, but I have ice skated - a light sweater was all I needed to be comfortable. Exercise generates a lot of waste heat.

Re: Cycling Is Key to Safer, Healthier, More Vital Cities

#263

> On a bike, you inherently have to make a physical connection with people. In a car, you're separated by glass and steel. But when you're out on a bike, you can actually see everybody, you can say hello to the people that you meet along the way. This is an underrated aspect of commuting by bike. I ride 8 miles into San Francisco every day, and more often then not I get a little bit of human interaction somewhere alo…

[deleted]

Re: Cycling Is Key to Safer, Healthier, More Vital Cities

#264
post #28

A 2 key points about well designed bike lanes that aren't bought up enough are: 1. raised / structural separation between the road and bikes path. 2. bike paths can be used for just about anything that is not a car/motorbike or a pedestrian. Skaters, skate boarders, mopeds and bikes can all share a common separated path way. I have tried biking in Boston and it is a nightmare. Bike Lanes marked on the road are taken…

If it's a true old school style moped (small engine/electric motor with pedals) that's probably fine, but something like a vespa or small motorcycle should be in a separate area.

Yeah. I meant something along the lines of a low powered scooter, than a proper Vespa.

I'd say anything above 50cc is probably off limits.

Re: Cycling Is Key to Safer, Healthier, More Vital Cities

#265

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Fixed gear, skinny tires. I'd probably be better off with cyclocross tires, but if you're optimizing for what you're going to be riding on 90% of the time, for winter commuting 90% of the time it's dry/wet pavement or hardpack snow. If the fatbikes give people confidence to ride in winter, more power to them, but personally I think it's overkill. For the cold you've got to keep your extremities protected. I've got bi…

Is there a temperature at which you call it quits? Those -30 Edmonton days seem like good days to choose other ways to commute.

Below -25c° I start to waffle, but it only gets that cold for maybe 10 days out of the year.

Re: Cycling Is Key to Safer, Healthier, More Vital Cities

#266
I think a big issue is how quickly things are changing in terms of what vehicles are used. There is an explosion in commuter vehicles now, both of the rentable and privately owned variety. I think the rentable ones are probably experiencing the most rapid change.

Motorized scooters, semi-motorized bikes (the ones that "flatten hills"), "hoverboards," motorized skateboards along with those one-wheeled self-balancing things that I want so badly. :) Haven't seen motorized roller skates in the real world but I'm betting on them arriving soon.

And then there are the self driving cabs that we know are coming soon. Combined with the rentable scooters and bikes, these can allow mixing it up in interesting and practical ways.

It seems like thinking of cars, bikes and pedestrians as 3 distinct categories is not going to work for long. Maybe a bit fanciful, but I could almost imagine rainbow stripes drawn on the roads, with red being for cars, purple being for pedestrians, and if you're using a motorized skateboard or a bike, you'd tend to ride in the greenish area.

Re: Cycling Is Key to Safer, Healthier, More Vital Cities

#267
post #224
post #208

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't see why it couldn't be done by almost anyone given that they live close enough to work. Anything less than 10 miles is doable assuming you have a good route.

>almost anyone I think that you considerably overestimate the capabilities of “almost anyone”

Will power is a capability most people are lacking in, so I guess you are right. Most people have the physical ability, though few realize it.

Re: Cycling Is Key to Safer, Healthier, More Vital Cities

#268
post #57

I’m simply never going to support any policy framework that would require me to cycle in Chicago in the winter. I know it’s possible but I’m not doing it.

And we can talk about how maybe you should because it's better for you, but this brings up a larger issue: when it comes to how whole populations behave, comfort is a factor that can't be totally ignored. Basically it creates a trade-off. Some percentage of people will decide one way and some the other way. This is going to affect adoption if you try to build a city around this idea. Incidentally, there are also issu…

^ This is precisely why I think biking is crazy.

Re: Cycling Is Key to Safer, Healthier, More Vital Cities

#270

I love cycling. I grew up in my father's bicycle store and nearly 50 years later, he's still running the business and we've all worked in it at one time or another. I ride bikes around the neighborhood with my kids every day. With that said, the U.S. is not the Netherlands. Like most Americans, I depend on my vehicle to get my kids to school and myself to the grocery store, which are 4-5 miles away from my house. Thi…

The purpose of building more infrastructure is to get more people on bikes, not just to placate the ones already on bikes. Getting more people on bikes will reduce traffic and pollution, not increase it.
Post reply on HN