Live data from Hacker News

Britain Is Poorer Than Any US State (2014)

forbes.com

61–70 of 110 posts

Re: Britain Is Poorer Than Any US State (2014)

#61
"All that redistribution hasn't made the Nordic poor richer than the American poor but it has made the rich poorer."

I'll take issue with this - the poor in Nordic countries and Britain have a much stronger social safety net. So maybe a better conclusion is that in Britain they are still as poor as before, but with access to similar health care as the rich (who are slightly less rich to allow for this).

Re: Britain Is Poorer Than Any US State (2014)

#62
post #55

There's a documentary on Netflix about physicians setting up shop on a race track to offer treatment to the poor and indigent in Bristol, TN: https://www.newsweek.com/remote-area-medical-shows-what-amer... You wouldn't see these scenes in even the most deprived corners of Newcastle-upon-Tyne or the Rhondda Valley. The crowds the event attracts! This is what a developing country looks like.

Ahh, HN, where someone doing a good deed is an illustration of how the United States is secretly a third-world hellhole.

What is the good deed you're referring to?

Re: Britain Is Poorer Than Any US State (2014)

#63
post #10

GDP per capita per hour worked is a better metric to use when comparing countries. Most Western European countries have fewer hours worked per worker, but when they work have the same productivity. I'm not sure about the gini coefficient, but both of the numbers given seem low. The US's was over 0.42 from what I've read in other sources.

This seems to be on the right track. How about asking the question... How many hours does the median wage earner have to work to earn the cost of living? (food, housing, transport ion, etc.)

Re: Britain Is Poorer Than Any US State (2014)

#66
post #55

There's a documentary on Netflix about physicians setting up shop on a race track to offer treatment to the poor and indigent in Bristol, TN: https://www.newsweek.com/remote-area-medical-shows-what-amer... You wouldn't see these scenes in even the most deprived corners of Newcastle-upon-Tyne or the Rhondda Valley. The crowds the event attracts! This is what a developing country looks like.

Ahh, HN, where someone doing a good deed is an illustration of how the United States is secretly a third-world hellhole.

It isn't a good deed when the deed is something that every other developed country expects from society as the most basic right.

Re: Britain Is Poorer Than Any US State (2014)

#67
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ahh, HN, where someone doing a good deed is an illustration of how the United States is secretly a third-world hellhole.

What is the good deed you're referring to?

Is that a rhetorical question, or did you really not read the GP comment?

Re: Britain Is Poorer Than Any US State (2014)

#68
post #46
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Switzerland isn't in the EU and is doing fine. Switzerland poverty rate - 6.6% Germany poverty rate - 16.7% Source: https://www.indexmundi.com/factbook/compare/switzerland.germ...

I'm going to assume you're not British / European, but for the record Switzerland is in Schengen and EFTA, Britain is heading for being in neither.

Britain is already in neither; it's never been in Schengen, and left the EFTA when joining the EEC as the EU was then. Although the other 3 countries in EFTA are part of the EEA (edit: which is how they're part of the single market), Switzerland isn't. Instead, they participate in the single market via a bunch of bilateral treaties:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Switzerland%E2%80%93European_U...

Re: Britain Is Poorer Than Any US State (2014)

#69
post #55

There's a documentary on Netflix about physicians setting up shop on a race track to offer treatment to the poor and indigent in Bristol, TN: https://www.newsweek.com/remote-area-medical-shows-what-amer... You wouldn't see these scenes in even the most deprived corners of Newcastle-upon-Tyne or the Rhondda Valley. The crowds the event attracts! This is what a developing country looks like.

Ahh, HN, where someone doing a good deed is an illustration of how the United States is secretly a third-world hellhole.

[deleted]

Re: Britain Is Poorer Than Any US State (2014)

#70
post #32

So given this information as well as the UN report on US and the fact that the US is in poverty like conditions [1] I think it’s safe to say everyone is broke. This post from reddit on /r/funny isn’t funny - it is the truth [2] [1] https://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?N... [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/funny/comments/9fq5e4/the_simpsons_...

Inequality is one thing, but the US is still a wealthy country.

> a wealthy country

Who is the country in this context though, does GDP mean the people are wealthier?

Post reply on HN