Live data from Hacker News

Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

info.model9.io

31–40 of 163 posts

Re: Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

#31
post #26

Do we need to bridge the gap? Or, to be brutally direct: Do mainframes deserve to survive in the coming decades?

To be brutally direct, why do you think mainframes should not survive "in the coming decades"?

Asking out of complete ignorance: What can a mainframe do that other kinds of machines can't? I barely understand what a mainframe is or why you'd use one over other technologies.

Re: Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

#33
post #26

Do we need to bridge the gap? Or, to be brutally direct: Do mainframes deserve to survive in the coming decades?

To be brutally direct, why do you think mainframes should not survive "in the coming decades"?

I don't believe the GP expressed an opinion, but simply asked a question.

Re: Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

#34
Back in 1996, I lived in Columbus, GA. There are a couple companies down there that used Mainframes for their processing. Synovous/TSYS, AFLAC and Blue Cross Blue Shield. Those companies teamed up with Columbus State University to provide a program for people to learn how to program in the technologies they used:

- Cobol, CICS, Rexx - DB2, IMS, VSAM - JCL

You got paid to go to 6 months of school, and if you already had a Bachelors degree, you got a second one for the classes you took. You went from 9 - 5 each day, and you were guaranteed a job at one of those companies, and if you worked for at least 4 years, you didn't have to pay back the loan you got to go through the training.

I was part of the second group of people that trained, and it started my professional career as a developer. Once Y2K was done, I moved on from mainframe programming to Java and .NET.

Re: Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

#35
post #27

My first professional job was to write RPG for an AS/400 mainframe (or whatever it's called these days), and even I don't know what the word "mainframe" is supposed to suggest to the modern user. As far as I could tell, it was just a single bog-standard server rack (amusingly sitting alone in a room that was far, far too big for it; a reminder of the massive bank of computers that used to do the same job) whose only…

You have it go the other way, as well. We were running some accounting software on an System i (AS/400, iSeries, like you said whatever IBM calls it this decade), and recently switched to something that runs commodity hardware.

Another company that I knew from our user group meeting also switched - the batch processing was so slow, they had to go back to the IBM. Their shipping process just wasn't fast enough otherwise. This wasn't a small company, either. If you're familiar with firearms you've probably heard of them.

You can run the 5250 at 27x132, and if you really need screen space you can run Eclipse/Visual Age on your desktop and have a 'real' environment to code on.

Re: Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

#36
post #28

Ok, maybe this is a silly question, but I am a millennial.... Question: what is a mainframe and why would I want one? In my mind I think of it as a big, but inelastic, compute resource. If that's true, why wouldn't I want to use something horizontally scalable instead?

This vid has some good photos https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=45X4VP8CGtk (also discussed on HN previously).

You don't want one if you ask me.

Re: Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

#37
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To be brutally direct, why do you think mainframes should not survive "in the coming decades"?

Asking out of complete ignorance: What can a mainframe do that other kinds of machines can't? I barely understand what a mainframe is or why you'd use one over other technologies.

Plain and simple, they are the biggest servers available. Built to be highly reliable and to have high IO throughput.

There are also many features in z/OS (the flagship OS) which are not available elsewhere. Things like workload manager or instrumentation facilities.

Re: Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

#38
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To be brutally direct, why do you think mainframes should not survive "in the coming decades"?

Asking out of complete ignorance: What can a mainframe do that other kinds of machines can't? I barely understand what a mainframe is or why you'd use one over other technologies.

I think their selling point is running cheaper and easier than the equivalent power in server clusters, as you don't have to deal with coordination and its overhead.

That being said, I think that advantage has mostly gone away with modern cloud computing and its matching infrastructure.

Re: Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

#39
post #28

Ok, maybe this is a silly question, but I am a millennial.... Question: what is a mainframe and why would I want one? In my mind I think of it as a big, but inelastic, compute resource. If that's true, why wouldn't I want to use something horizontally scalable instead?

It's bit like asking why would you use a truck when several vans can do.. and be more "horizontally scalable".

Mainframe is a really big server, and it is actually plenty elastic. You can divide it into smaller logical servers (LPARs).

The only downside is price. But I think for larger installations and certain workloads it will come out similar with a server fleet.

Re: Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

#40

Do we need to bridge the gap? Or, to be brutally direct: Do mainframes deserve to survive in the coming decades?

As a precursor, I don't have anything necessarily against the concept of a mainframe. It's just one big shared computer, not too much different than a kube cluster etc. But if there is one thing that definitely deserves to die in the mainframe world, it is IBM's predatory tactics for vendor lock in. Mainframes running linux I can see being around for a good time.

Watch this video for a pretty cool story behind IBM and EBCDIC.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FUIqtevjod4

Post reply on HN