Live data from Hacker News

Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

info.model9.io

11–20 of 163 posts

Re: Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

#11
Maybe I am prejudiced but I have the feeling that mainframes get sold to shops with a lot of money based on the salesman's skills and, well, I wouldn't be surprised if there was a kickback here and there, to oil the old engine. Not because they are the best tech.

That may be a bigger obstacle to people getting in that area. You can make money in non-corrupt companies where your career won't get stuck.

Re: Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

#12
Mainframe skills shortage is a complete fabrication, it simply doesn’t exist. In June of this year a local company laid off 850 people, a company with a large mainframe installation (SS&C formerly DST Systems). Hundreds were mainframe programmers. This is after a decade offshoring. There are thousands of former mainframers here. And this is just in Kansas City, Mo.

Anecdotal but representative I believe. Mainframes are costs centers, always will be. And the target of cost cutting. Millenials aren’t dumb!

Re: Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

#13
post #4

Fear of not keeping up with the Technical Joneses is a huge influence in our industry because everyone sees "old" programmers booted first when a company or the economy sours. Nobody wants to be That Guy (or Gal). If mainframes are perceived as a shrinking or outmoded technology, obsolescence fear kicks in and people avoid it. It may need some clever marketing to trick people into giving up that fear or impression. B…

Dunno, I'm a millennial (didn't even know I was part of that group till recently, gotta love being profiled by things I cannot control) and all it took me to like Mainframes (although I don't work with them) was hearing an older developer tell me all about them and their capabilities. I'm a total computer nerd aside from a programmer so I love learning about tech old, new and upcoming.

Yeah, all it would take for me to take on a mainframe is "we need someone for a permanent position that you can live on". I'm in this profession because I loved computers as a kid and it's never stopped. You wanna show me something novel? I'll be happy to learn it (assuming there's a livable job in there at the same time). They just have to be willing to teach it.

Re: Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

#14
post #2

My recommendations: - Give lots of young people the opportunity to learn the necessary mainframe skills (ideally by themselves). Lots of today's great programmers learned their programming skills on their own. This is very hard to do for mainframes because of access to them. - Pay really good salaries and advertise it. Money nearly always has a huge attractive force.

> This is very hard to do for mainframes because of access to them.

Bingo. I work in an AS/400 shop. I simply can't invest myself personally in the work because I know my access to that environment is predicated on working for this particular company.

I can hone my Linux skills and even my Windows Server skills any time. I can bring it home. I can use it myself. I can own it.

I can't do that with the AS/400. Just spinning up a "virtual machine" in the office to play around on is a licensing mess, and there's no "cloud" where I can rent one for a reasonable fee (that I've found). I have no sandbox.

Since my continued access to that environment isn't guaranteed or even convenient, I don't really want to dive in. And if I don't want to dive in then learning about it at all feels like a waste of time. Which then means I end up learning the absolute minimum before moving back to familiar territory.

Re: Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

#15
post #11

Maybe I am prejudiced but I have the feeling that mainframes get sold to shops with a lot of money based on the salesman's skills and, well, I wouldn't be surprised if there was a kickback here and there, to oil the old engine. Not because they are the best tech. That may be a bigger obstacle to people getting in that area. You can make money in non-corrupt companies where your career won't get stuck.

I bet the kickbacks are like any other enterprise IT sales process: wine & dine, golf and box seats. Except the restaurants and courses are probably much nicer. Decision makers have pretty strict policies to follow that restrict gifts over a certain dollar amount but invite a bunch of employees to a box seat at a sporting event you already paid for and how much that gift is worth depends on how you measure the value.

Re: Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

#17
Let me add a shameless plug here:

https://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/118484/mainframes...

It's a proposed Stack Exchange website dedicated to mainframes. It is in commitment phase, which means people need to come up and commit to support the site - with questions, answers, moderation, comments - in numbers sufficient to ensure its viability.

Re: Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

#18

Mainframe skills shortage is a complete fabrication, it simply doesn’t exist. In June of this year a local company laid off 850 people, a company with a large mainframe installation (SS&C formerly DST Systems). Hundreds were mainframe programmers. This is after a decade offshoring. There are thousands of former mainframers here. And this is just in Kansas City, Mo. Anecdotal but representative I believe. Mainframes a…

I'm not sure if your argument supports your conclusion:

1) You mentioned layoffs, but you didn't mention how long it took those people to find new jobs.

2) For those who couldn't find new jobs, how many of them avoided interviews or job offers because they were unwilling to relocate?

3) How transferable are "mainframe" skills to other "mainframe" installations? (As a non-mainframe-programmer, I have no idea how much one's skillset is peculiar to a specific mainframe vendor, mainframe OS version, etc.)

4) I get the impression that long-term mainframe developers actually have two parallel skillsets: (a) technical skills related to mainframe work in general, and (b) skills related to their particular installation's line-of-business and specific applications. For laid-off employees who couldn't find work, is it possible that their (b)-style skillsets were just not marketable to many other employers?

Re: Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

#19

Mainframe skills shortage is a complete fabrication, it simply doesn’t exist. In June of this year a local company laid off 850 people, a company with a large mainframe installation (SS&C formerly DST Systems). Hundreds were mainframe programmers. This is after a decade offshoring. There are thousands of former mainframers here. And this is just in Kansas City, Mo. Anecdotal but representative I believe. Mainframes a…

I'm not sure if your argument supports your conclusion: 1) You mentioned layoffs, but you didn't mention how long it took those people to find new jobs. 2) For those who couldn't find new jobs, how many of them avoided interviews or job offers because they were unwilling to relocate? 3) How transferable are "mainframe" skills to other "mainframe" installations? (As a non-mainframe-programmer, I have no idea how much…

FWIW, a couple of years back I had a gentleman who was a 30 year mainframe programmer in a Rails & Postgres class that I taught. He learned both, was humble enough to take an internship for a Rails job at over 50 and then turned it into full employment.

Anecdotal, but I found it interesting to watch the portability of experience.

Re: Millennials and Mainframes: How to Bridge the Gap

#20
post #10
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

IBM runs a student competition to try get people into it: https://masterthemainframe.com/

Is there something similar available if you are no student?

Not that I know of, and as a student I found the competition cycle also a bit off-putting, since it discourages just messing around a bit during random down-time that's not aligned to the schedule.
Post reply on HN