Live data from Hacker News

Google is discontinuing Inbox

fastcompany.com

211–220 of 459 posts

Re: Google is discontinuing Inbox

#211
I think this choice may be partially inspired by the fact that lots of people never switched to Inbox and people like myself actually switched back at some point. For me pinning UX kind of sucked and I really missed the Gmail density of information.

What's sad is that Inbox stopped evolving almost immediately after they released it. This seems to be a thing at Google. Release something, hype it, and then just walk away instead of maintaining and improving it. If there was anyone working on that at all in the last 3 years; sorry I failed to notice that there was anything happening at all. It looks to me that there was a skeleton maintenance team at best. So, it looks like there was some infighting and the Inbox team got starved of resources. Gmail on the other hand was improved a lot over the past few years.

In general it strikes me that essentially all attempts by Google to do a bait and switch of their products in the past few years have been impopular and somewhat underwhelming in their outcome. They've killed a lot of popular products in favor of things that then flopped. They've repeatedly walked away from products that maybe had issues but were entirely fixable only to replace them with something worse.

There's something deeply wrong with how Google is being managed since Alphabet was created. They are lacking a clear direction/strategy. Is it Fuchsia, Chrome OS or Android that is going to be the OS of choice? I'm not sure they know the answer themselves. I'm not sure their OEMs know either. My advice, kill two out of three and get it done within the next 12 months. IMHO, Android would at this point be by far the most disruptive thing to kill. There's a big risk of forks surviving any attempt by Google to kill that and ending up being a headache for Google.

Similarly, which of their billion chat clients are we supposed to actually use at this point? Same advice, pick one, kill the rest ASAP. IMHO keeping and fixing hangouts is the best course of action at this point. It's the only one that's been around long enough to actually have a user base (despite it's many flaws and terrible UX).

Re: Google is discontinuing Inbox

#212

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Outside of bundling Bundling is the main development that Inbox brought to the table.

Going to the video tape: https://gmail.googleblog.com/2014/10/an-inbox-that-works-for... Three things are highlighted: Extraction of info from items and display (now in gmail) Bundles (some made it into gmail) Reminders, assists, and Snooze (now mostly in gmail) So i'm not sure i'd agree with you here, but i definitely would agree that of the big three, bundling made it in the least :)

Inbox users have had all of this and more since 2014, though. And even if Gmail has some of these features the interface is not nearly as natural for using them.

Re: Google is discontinuing Inbox

#213
post #141
post #117

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Trips was the killer feature. I hope they port it. The ability to collect all my related information (a particular trip for example) into a single view was genius.

Alternatively, you can try Tripit[1] which has more features, but there is definitely more friction involved as you either need to grant access to your email account or manually forward emails. [1] https://www.tripit.com

I use TripIt a lot (manually forwarding emails). I don’t trust them with my email credentials. :-)

I do love the service. Their website design feels aged and worn, but the functionality is great. I love trying out confirmation emails from new travel services to see if they can parse them. And they usually do a good job.

Re: Google is discontinuing Inbox

#214
Is anyone interested in building a new email client/service based on the inbox-as-a-todo-list paradigm?

Maybe something that would work with any email provider but would sync todo/done/snoozed state with our server. Or perhaps could embed that state in IMAP flags.

I'd be open to working on the backend and arch if there's interest.

Re: Google is discontinuing Inbox

#216

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sorry, not even close. Categories is just automatic folders, every email client has had folders for decades.

Is there a difference, other than bundles are inline with your other emails and categories are accessed in separate tabs?

You cannot create custom categories, you're limited to the 5 options Gmail provides you.

Re: Google is discontinuing Inbox

#217

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's likely not google get bored, but users didn't adapt product on large enough scale.

It is a cycle. Google drops a product due to low uptick, so users don't take on further products. There are three products that I can think of that have lasted: search, email, ads (which is search, really). [edit] oh, and maps!

Voice. I've been using Voice for probably 10 years now. Most of the functionality has been subsumed by Hangouts, but it's still there and they even updated it within the last year.

Re: Google is discontinuing Inbox

#218
Google's communication strategy (and any other strategy really) is just a reflection of internal incentives structure and organization structure. One would hope that this is the other way around, but it is what it is.

Re: Google is discontinuing Inbox

#219

This is really unfortunate. Inbox's primary differentiator was never in any one individual feature like Snooze or Smart Reply. No, the real value of Inbox was that its design was built around a fundamentally different philosophy on what email is and how it should be managed. Gmail takes a traditional approach to email management. Messages come in, you read them, maybe organize them with labels, then archive them, del…

Exactly this is the key difference and what I'll miss. I really hope they add a "Inbox mode" to Gmail... Which they'll probably don't.

Re: Google is discontinuing Inbox

#220
Inbox so far is the very best email client I used. It is not an email client, rather a task manager. Mails, reminders, auto reminder, auto-grouping, oh, and TRIPS!

Oh man, trips, every incoming email related to a trip is automatically merged into the bundle, airline tickets, car rentals, hotels, flight schedule changes, you simply need nothing else, it was all there.

The new Gmail recently introduced is not getting close to Inbox.

I can't believe they do it.

Post reply on HN